3 ms·
Every time I nark on ICD-9, -10, -11, someone claims there's some hidden benefit as yet unrevealed to us mortals. Just clap louder and Tinkerbell will fly. Is
by specialist 8y ago
Every time I nark on ICD-9, -10, -11, someone claims there's some hidden benefit as yet unrevealed to us mortals. Just clap louder and Tinkerbell will fly.
Is this true? Even in finely contrived circumstances using the biggest suspensions of disbelief?
I've looked a few times, have found no studies showing ICD-* improve patient outcomes, reduce costs, or any other healthcare benefit. (Consultants and insurers do okay, though.)
When will we learn? This is just another rehash of ontology vs folksonomy, symbolic vs machine learning AI, data dictionaries vs screen scrapping, etc.
Source: Implemented 5 health exchanges, was active during transition from ICD-9 to ICD-10.
- sbuttgereit 8y agoWhen I was working on a project that involved ICD codes, one thing that kept cropping up in my mind was even how consistently the codes would be used. I other fields of endeavor, when I see such voluminous, nuanced classification codes, the real result is that it becomes confusing as to 1) what code any given subject should be classified as, 2) the people doing the classification cannot know all the codes available and therefore will classify to something close that they know... even if a closer code exists, 3) there can be general disagreement on what any given code means and where dividing lines sit between similar codes, and 4) in medical offices, where several codes may be available and could reasonably apply, I've seen choices made based on the financial differences between the codes where they existed (not to mention that all the previous problems in coding a condition for the practitioner is also a problem for those deciding how codes may/may not be covered or paid for). Given all that, it seems to me any coding system like this, which apparently fails to account for the limits of human judgement and usage patterns, will ultimately fail. Naturally, I assume that the goal in constructing such a system is the collection of nuanced data, but expect the result to be a muddle of that data as the system is misused. And based on the medical offices I have worked with over the years, there is nothing about the medical profession that will mitigate those issues.
- nradov 8y agoYou can always find occasional errors and discrepancies but the vast majority of coding is done correctly. Medical coders go through an extensive training and certification process.
- sbuttgereit 8y agoI understand that there are training/certification processes for medical coders and I expect that to certainly help. But is there a basis to the claim that errors are occasional and that coding is done correctly? Or is that just an anecdotal assertion? My observations are just anecdotal, but do come from a fair amount of on the ground experiences. I expect their to be limits on the effectiveness of that sort of thing. My original comment dealt with the complexity issue, but there's how well that training/certification ages over time... such that common codes are handled well due to daily reinforcement, but less common codes will tend to fare worse. Unless there are required maintenance trainings and re-certification requirements (I'm not aware of that either way), I expect on average for there to be issues in practice. While there has been medical procedure coding of some sort for a very long time, this rather more complex coding that we're generally discussing with this story is still in rather early days. Nonetheless, I would be interested to see an actual study on how the complexity of coding systems like ICD fare at actually capturing the information they try to; I just tried searching the ACM Digital Library, but didn't find anything... though that could just be weakness of my search terms.
- nradov 8y agoIt's not just an anecdotal assertion. I know that public and private payers conduct audits and reviews on a subset of claims to verify accurate coding. Private insurers don't release their audit results but if you search around you can probably find something from CMS for Medicare claims. Certified medical coders are required to complete several hours of additional training every year in order to maintain their status. ICD-9 had been in use for many years. ICD-10 is only slightly more complex. Most provider organizations typically only use a small subset of the available codes so it's not too hard to keep track of the common ones.
- thanatropism 8y agoWhen you have a chronic, relatively rare disease and are moving countries.
- nradov 8y agoHidden benefits have nothing to do with it. ICD is primarily targeted toward billing (claims). As long as providers are paid by separate payers (regardless of whether the payers are private insurers or some sort of government single payer system) there has to be some sort of consistent coding system to describe patient conditions.
- noelsusman 8y agoThe benefits seem pretty obvious to me. I work for a hospital and a few years ago we discovered that we had a serious problem with sepsis. Every hospital struggles with sepsis, but our sepsis mortality rates were higher than our peers. As a result, we invested significant resources into improving how we handle sepsis, and our mortality rates have gone down. None of that would have happened if ICD codes didn't exist. Frankly, ICD codes aren't even there to improve outcomes or reduce costs. They exist primarily for billing purposes. Anything else we get out of them is a bonus.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThey exist primarily for billing purposes. Anything else we get out of them is a bonus. Yes. If you work in insurance and have the right code, you know you can pay it without pending the claim and sending a letter requesting additional information. If you have the medical records but no code, you may have to ask for additional info to determine if it is covered.
- specialist 8y agoI'm still struggling with the notion that an insurer, and not the health care providers, now determine medical necessity.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoYou can get a doctor to write a letter of medical necessity. Sometimes that will get it covered. But, yeah, the US healthcare system has issues.
- nradov 8y agoMedical necessity isn't a binary condition. Two providers presented with the same patient chart will frequently come to different conclusions. Insurers (both private and government) do employ doctors to perform medical necessity reviews.
- specialist 8y ago