9 ms·
"Ceci n'est pas un UI." This specific example may be new, but the concept of fooling users with websites containing images of the system's own UI is not new --
by userbinator 8y ago
"Ceci n'est pas un UI."
This specific example may be new, but the concept of fooling users with websites containing images of the system's own UI is not new --- for example, all the fake antivirus alert boxes. That had a relatively easy mitigation --- using non-default appearance on your system (e.g. an XP-style "you have a virus!" dialog box image would just look silly if you weren't using XP with the default theme), but it seems the trend toward un-customisability is just going to lead to this being even more easy to exploit.
Of course, mobile browsers hiding important information and being even more un-customisable makes this worse.
Well, even I, as the creator of the inception bar, found myself accidentally using it!
When reading a product's documentation that has screenshots explaining how to do something, I've also accidentally tried to manipulate them instead of the actual dialogs. I'm sure others here have had similar experiences too.
- walrus01 8y agoI have an unquantified theory that the number of users that can distinguish between a Windows 7/8/10 dialog box that is presented directly by the operating system, versus as an image inside a browser coming from external http/https server, is diminishing greatly every year.
- sandworm101 8y agoExcept all the colorblind people who have altered their system defaults enough that anything internal to the browser will look very out of place.
- saagarjha 8y agoHaving the entire web be unaccessible is a somewhat poor compromise, though…
- benj111 8y agoOr Linux users.
- washadjeffmad 8y agoWhich have a lower overall usage of the proprietary chrome browser, as well. Firefox is the pre-install default for most distros, and only Chromium is provided in default repos. They're also significantly more likely to use some form of ad and JS blocking. So until the appearance changes based on the UA and system theme (and maybe can read bookmarks and plugins), this trick mostly affects mobile Chrome users.
- Terretta 8y agoYou could always try pulling their system colors in through CSS: https://www.sitepoint.com/css-system-styles/ https://www.sitepoint.com/css-system-styles/
- ben_w 8y agoLast time I was in Davis CA, someone was trying to get me to sign up to their charity. They had an iPad, and were adamant that the padlock on the screen proved it was secure. I couldn’t convince them that it was just a picture, and that I could fake it if I wanted to.
- Waterluvian 8y agoIn high school we would screenshot the windows 98 desktop, make it the wallpaper, hide everything, and watch people fluster about.
- alexb7c4 8y agoIn office, adding screenshot visual studio startup splash screen to the wallpaper and watch the dev. Best moment is when they see visual studio being first thing to start after system reboot.
- laumars 8y agoha I did a similar thing too. Except it was fake error messagebox and on Windows 3.1 (or might have even been 3.0?) It worked quite effectively on 3.x because you could just minimize progman.exe
- bgeeek 8y agoWe did similar with the dos prompt, which must have been about 1991.
- laumars 8y agoThat's the era as me (Windows 3.0 was released in 1990, 3.1 a couple of years later). I'm surprised your school let you have unfettered access to the DOS prompt - that would have gotten abused within minutes at our school. Even the BBC BASIC interpreter ended up getting removed from the network because people like myself would abuse the PC Speaker (which, to be honest, was the last the mischief I'd cause). Frankly though, I preferred the actual BBC Micros and Amiga's that those IBMs were meant to replace.
- avip 8y agoAs popularized in "webdude vs. sales guy"
- astura 8y ago"You can't arrange by penis."
- dzhiurgis 8y agoProlly need some sort of ml to parse every image used on device and tag potentially dangerous ones. Wouldn’t be too expensive on devices with tensor units... Apparently Apple already reports your offensive photos already, can’t imagine why browsing should be treated differently.
- saagarjha 8y ago> potentially dangerous ones How do you define this? > Apple already reports your offensive photos already What?
- dzhiurgis 8y ago> How do you define this? Same as every tech company do with tons of other spam types. > What? https://techcrunch.com/2017/10/30/no-iphones-dont-have-a-special-folder-for-your-sexy-pics/ https://techcrunch.com/2017/10/30/no-iphones-dont-have-a-spe... >> This analysis generally happens inside a sandbox, and very little of what the systems determine makes it outside of that sandbox. There are special exceptions, of course, for things like child pornography, for which very special classifiers have been created and which are specifically permitted to reach outside that sandbox. Unsure what is Techcrunch's source for this but it kinda makes sense.
- deno 8y agoThis is not new, antivirus software already shows reactive methods do not work.
- baybal2 8y agoNew? I think that was around since IE6 times. Autohide menu bars are bad designs, and you have this on top of that. Fullscreen API must be removed from browser for security reasons, new window hints should be removed too.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- chicob 8y agoSomeone I know would constantly leave a macbook unlocked, so I prepared a script that would turn down the volume, whisper the owner's name, open weird sfw pictures online and other mildly annoying things, but not very often (like once a week). This was meant as a joke, and I never actually went through with it. I know the person very well but it still felt douchebaggy. But the idea was to make an app file, save it to some seemingly legitimate folder, and adding it to the autostart list. The trick to hide the thing was to drag and drop Safari's logo onto it, and naming the app "Safan": it almost goes unnoticed when checking the Activity Monitor, thanks to the system font's proportions.
- oedmarap 8y agoBlurred lines aside, for posterity you could name it "Safari Auto-Update Utility" and use an app icon that has the Safari logo coupled with a cog wheel or so.
- chicob 8y agoI thought of something like that, but then the user could kill it as a precaution since an auto-update utility or any other secondary application can be temporarily disabled. Killing "Safari", on the other hand, would terminate everything the user's currently doing in it. I guess I could have named it Disk Memory Manager or some other important-sounding thing.
- washadjeffmad 8y ago'Ghost of Steve Jobs' then.
- m1sta_ 8y agoIf everything were standard then a screen reader could confidently identify fraudulent content.
- baud147258 8y ago"Ceci n'est pas un UI." Shouldn't it be "Ceci n'est pas une UI."? Since interface is a feminine word in French, the article in front of UI need to be feminine too.
- remram 8y agoThen it should probably be "une IHM", for "Interface Homme-Machine".