28 ms·
This Place Is Not a Place of Honor (1992)
- andrewflnr 8y agoI went looking for this page to confirm the exact quote for a story I'm writing. The original link on HN where I found it was dead, so I had to go to the wayback machine. Hopefully no one has to do that again... Previous discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11851871 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11851871
- gwern 8y agoCouldn't you have used https://urbigenous.net/library/WIPP/ https://urbigenous.net/library/WIPP/ or https://prod-ng.sandia.gov/techlib-noauth/access-control.cgi/1992/921382.pdf https://prod-ng.sandia.gov/techlib-noauth/access-control.cgi... which turn up if you google any of it?
- andrewflnr 8y agoI was really trying to find the exact thing I had seen before. I think the "motherf_cking webpage" aesthetic adds to the effect. Also, the PDF is a bear to search for the juicy parts, and I actually don't remember seeing that first link.
- PaulHoule 8y agoNo it's just a place where you can find enough Plutonium to destroy your enemies or enough U238 to run your civilization for 1000 years... I used to dream that maybe 2500 years from now the Scientologists and the Mormons would fight it out over Yucca mountain but now it's clear the Scientologists won't last that long.
- stcredzero 8y agonow it's clear the Scientologists won't last that long Good. However, references?
- umvi 8y agoI could see celebrity participation in Scientology declining, but the actual organization itself has a ton of money and I don't see it going away anytime soon. If anything I see it going underground and pivoting into a full blown crime syndicate if their legal moneymakers aren't sustainable anymore.
- grahamburger 8y agoHa! That would make a great story. Mormons already have a hollowed out mountain[1] but at least ostensibly it's full of genealogical records not plutonium. (Also I'm a Mormon.) [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Granite_Mountain_(Utah) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Granite_Mountain_(Utah)
- blhack 8y agoWhy so much work into storing genealogical records?
- crooked-v 8y agoMormon belief is that baptism is one of the few strict requirement for entry into Heaven, but that it can also be performed for the dead by volunteer proxies. Even the most obstinate sinners and nonbelievers will gain entry into the lowest-but-still-pleasant level of Heaven if they haven't committed the unpardonable sin[1]... so long as they've been baptized, in person or by proxy. Combine those premises and it becomes an obvious moral imperative to gather as much historical genological information as possible to perform proxy baptisms for as many deceased people as possible. Of course, this presumption of religious axioms also has a history of upsetting people of other religions, and the extensive information-gathering involved often uses borderline unethical methods, such as the various geneology research service websites that are run in one way or another by the LDS Church and include terms of service that let them use the info you piece together however they like. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_sin#Mormonism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_sin#Mormonism
- sk5t 8y agoThe unpardonable sin seems quite... vaguely specified, and open to endless debate. What sin is a sin against the Holy Ghost? What sin is not?
- grahamburger 8y agoIn Mormon culture it's understood to be something you can only do if you've had life experiences that should convey extraordinary faith. (IMO GP makes a bigger deal of this particular quirk of Mormon doctrine than is needed for the topic, fwiw.) Judas Iscariot is commonly referenced as an example of someone who as a disciple of Jesus should have believed in His divinity but betrayed Him. Most Mormons aren't concerned about accidentally committing an unpardonable sin, and most teaching in the Mormon church focuses on the idea that all sin is forgivable because of Jesus' atonement, with scant mention of the idea that there might be sins that could be unforgivable. (Note that despite commenting on this thread and being a Mormon I'm hardly an examplary Mormon in a variety of ways. It's rare that a topic comes up on HN that I know much about though, so may as well contribute some info in the spirit of satisfying intellectual curiosity!)
- NikkiA 8y agoThat was basically the plot of the sequel to Planet of the Apes (the original 1968 film, none of this reboot nonsense), no?
- dang 8y agoFor the curious, 2017: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15210404 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15210404 2016: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11851871 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11851871 2011: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2211025 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2211025 2009: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=948606 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=948606
- saltcured 8y agoWe should create something like the olympiad to gather together and re-tell the epic story of danger every few years, rather than building a monument and hoping it still means something on its own.
- chris_wot 8y agoExcept that won't work in this case. This project was designed to outlive cultures due to the timeframes before radioactive waste becomes safe.
- nixpulvis 8y agoor define the cultures ;)
- saltcured 8y agoTo be honest, I was just trying for the repeat posting meta-joke... But, I do think that some active process and culture to guard or maintain a waste pile is probably necessary. So, don't fixate on some naive visitor you have to protect from all harm in the distant future. Settle for minimizing the delay and accumulative harm before new visitors figure it out and become the new keepers of the message.
- spaceflunky 8y agoMaybe have a competition every so often for the best pieces of art or graphic design explaining the danger. (maybe add it to the olympics?) That way we keep this alive in the public consciences and even if the competition dies out, hopefully at least one work will survive 10,000 years.
- nkrisc 8y agoI always imagined a concept such that instead of trying to deter people from entering was designed to convey that it was trying to keep something dangerous from escaping. Someone trying to keep you out of an ancient tomb? Clearly there are valuables in there. An ancient tomb that's locked from the outside? That's creepy.
- stcredzero 8y agoAn ancient tomb that's locked from the outside? That's creepy. Going by 20th and 21st century media, there should be lots of Asian tombs with "seals" placed on the outside of them. Reality is probably quite different.
- jhanschoo 8y agoIndeed, any uninhabited place with signs of past human activity just invites grave robbing by any sufficiently pre-modern society.
- r00fus 8y agoIsn’t that exactly what an psychopath/despot/arch-villain would want? To unleash destruction on the world... and be the one to find, conquer and control it. I think perhaps the Finland approach of complete obscurity may be better.
- wnkrshm 8y agoThat's what I thought as well when I saw the picture of the human being poisoned by the radioactive waste and dieing. A culture might think: "This may be a great poison, let's use it to destroy our enemies and lay waste to their lands forever". Not entirely unlike some of our own plans for using nuclear weapons only with less bang.
- nkrisc 8y agoYeah but if they know what's in there they're going to want it regardless. I thought the purpose of these messages is to deter people who might not realize the danger of what's inside and accidentally poison themselves.
- devindotcom 8y agoThis is the executive summary of the full paper from 1993, which is well worth a read for several reasons and can be found (slowly) here: https://www.osti.gov/biblio/10117359 https://www.osti.gov/biblio/10117359
- bosaisi 8y ago"An analysis of the likely number of deaths over 10,000 years due to inadvertent intrusion should be conducted. This cost should be weighted against that of the marker system."
- FooHentai 8y agoA practical consideration. If you spend human life time on efforts to prevent loss of human life, you risk a net loss if you don't trade the cost against the benefit.
- myself248 8y agoOr just leave it unmarked and hope the pile of remains outside the entryway gives the next adventurer a hint. And then just accept human nature and let the pile slowly grow.
- pontifier 8y agoMaybe we are thinking of this with too much of a helicopter parents view. If there was a high exposure death area, and a way to easily send an animal into it, the truth and reality of the danger there would be very easy to convey.
- yellowapple 8y agoYeah, pretty sure any advanced civilization will quickly figure out "hey this place is pretty radioactive; we shouldn't stick around", while any primitive civilization will quickly figure out "hey this place is definitely cursed; we shouldn't stick around". Having a visual cue there (I like the jagged pointy structures) would certainly help reinforce that and/or delineate exactly where the radioactive/cursed place actually is.
- Ma8ee 8y ago> while any primitive civilization will quickly figure out "hey this place is definitely cursed; we shouldn't stick around". After a while, when quite a few people have died, and maybe their whole village and all their farmland is contaminated. This is exactly what we are trying to avoid. See for example the Goiânia accident: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goi%C3%A2nia_accident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goi%C3%A2nia_accident
- yellowapple 8y agoBy that example, it sounds like "after a while" would be "a couple weeks". That's a short enough timeframe to piece together "oh darn, this happened because we went into that scary place with all the jagged rocks and took the curse of that strange land back with us". Maybe that particular village is doomed, but villages do communicate/trade with other villages and could spread the word that "hey, we visited this weird place with jagged rocks and a couple weeks later we all got crazy sick, so like, don't go there". Soon enough, the Curse of the Jagged Land will become part of the local folklore/religion, at which point Mission Accomplished. Worst-case, you might see an uptick in animal and/or human sacrifice at the site to appease the God of Plutonium.
- jakebasile 8y agoI feel like there's something to think about here since we couldn't even keep the page with this information active for a decade and the goal is to keep the actual warning around for 10,000 years.
- nixpulvis 8y agoOr, to realize that we did in fact keep it active, just through archive.org, the modern day Library of Alexandria on steroids. EDIT: Makes things hard if the warning sign was a link however, yes. Could just add a published date then, and I'd assume things would be fine.
- nixpulvis 8y agoThis is a nice little script. function wayback_link(url) { return `https://web.archive.org/web/${url}`; } console.log(wayback_link("https://github.com"))
- patrickyeon 8y agoI just went to https://web.archive.org/web/news.ycombinator.com https://web.archive.org/web/news.ycombinator.com (no date in the url) and it sent me to the most recent snapshot.
- nixpulvis 8y agoPerfect, of course that's how this should work. Updated :P
- yellowapple 8y agoIf you use DuckDuckGo as your default search engine, it's also enough to (in Firefox or Chrome or any other browser where the URL bar functions as a search bar) prepend the URL with "!wayback " (without the quotes, but with the trailing space). You could also do the same with "https://web.archive.org/web/" https://web.archive.org/web/", but "!wayback " is easier for me to remember.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y agoRepeating my comment from the last discussion: This whole thing is an offshoot of antinuclear FUD. If civilization collapses to the point where people no longer realize that radiation is dangerous, then so many people have already died that a few more people dying early from radiation is just background noise. In addition, knowing human nature and our propensity for conspiracy theories, there will be people in the future who think all those signs were put there to dissuade people from finding a massive buried treasure. After all, the phrasing is pretty much what you would expect if someone had buried a treasure and wanted to scare people from digging for it.
- walrus01 8y ago> In addition, knowing human nature and our propensity for conspiracy theories, there will be people in the future who think all those signs were put there to dissuade people from finding a massive buried treasure. After all, the phrasing is pretty much what you would expect if someone had buried a treasure and wanted to scare people from digging for it. I have to agree with this. What if in 1955 America we had discovered the equivalent of these warnings, and hints of a huge artificially constructed underground tunnel complex in the same location as Yucca Mountain, and we thought it was buried artifacts from some more technologically advanced precursor or alien civilization? Dozens of billions of dollars would have been made available to excavate the site, damn the cost and damn the consequences.
- roenxi 8y agoAnd, ironically, the discovery of high-energy rock would probably be a celebrated scientific (or at least religious) advance for such a civilisation. Marie Curie's exploits aren't remembered as foolish. She likely died of radiation overexposure and is remembered as one of the heros of science. And many in her lab if I recall correctly. The 10,000 year warning is an interesting thought experiment, but if there is anyone who claims it is relevant to the acceptance of nuclear power they are simply not very imaginative about all the things that can go wrong over 10,000 years. A civilisation-level mind blank on where the garbage dump is doesn't rate at any meaningful level. The half life of lead is 1.53×10^7 years. It is a nasty toxic substance; it has killed people. We still use it. It is objectively a bigger threat on a longer time scale than nuclear waste. As usual, nuclear power is special because we could conceivably manage the damage. Most industrial processes cause damage at a scale so large the cost of a no-harm policy would be prohibitive. With nuclear the cost is simply a bit high.
- hirundo 8y ago> We considered ourselves to be a powerful culture. For the Level 1 message I suggest a sculpture of two vast and trunkless legs of stone, over a pedestal with the words ‘My name is Ozymandias, king of kings: Look on my works, ye Mighty, and despair!'
- havana59er 8y agoGreat poem. https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/46565/ozymandias https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/46565/ozymandias
- MrMorden 8y agoRead by Bryan Cranston: https://youtu.be/T3dpghfRBHE https://youtu.be/T3dpghfRBHE
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- aluminumtunes 8y agoThere is a great doc about this place https://youtu.be/qoyKe-HxmFk https://youtu.be/qoyKe-HxmFk
- Mizza 8y agoObligatory song about genetically engineered fluorescent cats: http://www.theraycatsolution.com/#10000 http://www.theraycatsolution.com/#10000
- saalweachter 8y ago> "Rubble Landscape": A square outer rim of the caliche layer of stone is dynamited and bulldozed into a crude square pile over the entire Keep. This makes a rubble-stone landscape at a level above the surrounding desert, an anomaly both topographic and in roughness of material. The outer rim from which rubble was pushed inward fills with sand, becoming a soft moat, probably with an anomalous pattern of vegetation. This all makes for an enormous landscape of large-stone rubble, one that is very inhospitable, being hard to walk on and difficult to bring machinery onto. It is a place that feels destroyed, rather than one that has been made. "Landscape of large-stone rubble" describes, among other things, New England, where all of those stone boulders were carefully (or more often carelessly) stacked into stone walls to more-or-less clear the fields for planting or pasturage.
- vkou 8y agoThe first thing people unfamiliar with the dangers of radiation will do, is to quarry all those dramatic spikes and walls, for usable stone.
- justin66 8y agoThe people studying this have generally advocated a layered defense. First, people dig up the strange stuff on the surface if they have a use for it (although it should be designed to make this difficult, expensive and not especially useful). They don't have to be especially advanced to do this, maybe. Second, perhaps they develop the ability to dig deeper and they discover more elaborate warnings. Eventually, they get to the equivalent of a vault where they've received plenty of warnings and, one hopes, are savvy enough to interpret them and make an educated choice as to whether they should proceed. (there's an assumption that wisdom, caution and linguistic ability might grow in a future society alongside the ability to prospect and dig, which might or might not work out) The strange spikes and so on are just one possible approach. Simply hiding the stuff a mile under some salt can work and at least one site does that. I think you're going to see a ton of stuff hidden that way just because it's the path of least resistance once the regulatory permissions are secured (which is hard enough). I think this approach has been written about in the NY Times and so on.
- edgarvaldes 8y agoPersonally, this seems a more interesting experiment from the perspective of language and communication, and only incidentally about the risks of nuclear pollution.
- salthound 8y agoThat is exactly what it was, a very interesting piece of foundational research in anthropology justified by allusions to the dangers of nuclear pollution.
- Herrin 8y agoFor anyone interested in things like this, I'd recommend "Deep Time" by Gregory Benford[1]. It has a chapter devoted to WIPP[2] and this messaging. [1] Amazon link: https://www.amazon.com/Deep-Time-Humanity-Communicates-Millennia/dp/0380793466 https://www.amazon.com/Deep-Time-Humanity-Communicates-Mille... [2] Seems to be online, albeit poorly formatted, here: https://www.physics.uci.edu/~silverma/benford.html https://www.physics.uci.edu/~silverma/benford.html
- inflatableDodo 8y agoIs also worth looking into the related and awesomely named, 'Human Interference Task Force'. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Interference_Task_Force https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Interference_Task_Force I think their best work has to be the ray-cats. http://mentalfloss.com/article/27476/ray-cats-artificial-moons-and-atomic-priesthood-how-government-plans-protect-our http://mentalfloss.com/article/27476/ray-cats-artificial-moo... http://www.theraycatsolution.com/ http://www.theraycatsolution.com/ https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/ten-thousand-years/ https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/ten-thousand-years/
- frankhorrigan 8y agoI've actually thought about this quite a lot. Not because I have an expertise in the matter--I don't. But because it's such a fascinating thought experiment. My proposed solution goes something like this: It is hard to convey that there is nothing of value and only danger within. So what if you just made the site actually dangerous on the surface? Is it possible to build something like a lake of acid that would make the area uninhabitable, dangerous, and impossible to develop? Or, to keep it more abstract: Maybe the problem is that we're looking for the right symbol. But instead of symbols we should make the fact of the area itself the deterrent.
- CptFribble 8y agoGiven enough time, literally anything that indicates the slightest bit of "don't go in here" will make someone ask "why go to the trouble if it isn't valuable? I'm pretty sure the only way to keep people out is to hide it.
- mLuby 8y agoThe authors seemed to think hiding the site was impossible. However I find it difficult to believe it's harder to hide it than it is build massive earthworks all over it.
- dcbadacd 8y agoWhich raises the question, has someone maybe hidden something like this somewhere already on the earth?
- ls612 8y agoAside from the fact that we'd notice something that radioactive today. It is easy enough to hide something from being seen, it would be harder to hide it (especially something as carefully monitored as radiation) from a technologically advanced civilization.
- DoctorOetker 8y ago
- bobcostas55 8y agoThere's a great documentary about this, called _Into Eternity_. Highly recommended.
- js2 8y agoI’m reminded of this big red sign I saw in a men’s room, just above a big red button: “ATTENTION DO NOT PUSH RED BUTTON UNLESS IT IS AN EMERGENCY” It took every ounce of my will power not to push the damn button. https://i.imgur.com/xnfVpOh.jpg https://i.imgur.com/xnfVpOh.jpg
- mindcrime 8y ago“Some humans would do anything to see if it was possible to do it. If you put a large switch in some cave somewhere, with a sign on it saying 'End-of-the-World Switch. PLEASE DO NOT TOUCH', the paint wouldn't even have time to dry.” -- Terry Pratchett
- theandrewbailey 8y ago"I pressed it because a number 2 was imminent."
- hanoz 8y agoI think we need only reflect on our own likely response to any conceivable attempt by a previous civilisation to so forewarn us, to realise the futility of our attempting likewise.
- Roedou 8y agoWell, we looked at those gigantic pyramids, translated the hieroglyphs in some places to mean that a dangerous curse would afflict anyone who entered, and then went in to explore / loot the places. So... yeah. That's the level of being willing to ignore warnings that we have to prepare for.
- EForEndeavour 8y agoI think that's exactly the mindset that the Sandia National Labs panel adopted: how would we react to any conceivable attempt to warn us away from such a site? What wouldn't work on us, why, and how could we improve that? The article summarizes their conclusions.
- jcadam 8y agoThis whole discussion reminds of the novel A Canticle for Leibowitz. i.e., a society arising in the centuries after a nuclear war failing to learn from their ancestors' mistakes.
- nvr219 8y agothis is one of my favorite things
- Aloha 8y agoFor anyone curious, here is the full report. https://prod-ng.sandia.gov/techlib-noauth/access-control.cgi/1992/921382.pdf https://prod-ng.sandia.gov/techlib-noauth/access-control.cgi...
- Animats 8y agoThat's just a discussion of a potential marker. Here's a real one.[1] This is the SL-1 reactor site in Idaho. Reactor destroyed by a steam explosion in 1961. Already, the marker looks dated. [1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/96/SL-1Burial.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/96/SL-1Buri...
- niftich 8y agoA few days ago, I was just thinking of the phrase 'This place is not a place of honor' and the foreboding aesthetic of the field of spikes warning nuclear waste buried below. I first saw this document many years ago, yet it stuck with me enough to have my mind wander to it on occasion. Every time this is posted, many comments on this topic echo comments made in the past. This is reassuring, because many people throughout the years will independently arrive at some of the same critiques, as diverse as those critiques may be. There's concerns about the longevity of the artifacts intended to communicate the message, there's concerns about whether the symbolism will be understood to signify danger, and there's concerns about whether the message of danger will be heeded. There's also the argument that drawing overt attention to the site is more risky than concealing its location, and that avoiding the circulation of information about it is wiser than publicizing it and risk it becoming a legend that some may someday seek. While it's difficult to design a message that transcends time, culture, and biology, and conveys the authority of the writers and the gravity of the warning, violence against intruders conveys the danger to those who value their existence. It won't necessarily protect against malevolence of someone seeking to unearth a weapon, or the arrogance of individuals willing to compel or force others to put themselves in danger in their stead, but the properties of nuclear waste in particular may enable a design that proves fatal to anyone who may enter the protected chamber, such that once they're through, they can never leave. Technology and telecommunications could still be used to extract material from the site, but only the most dedicated adversaries would be able to proceed. Thinking on this, the obscurity argument is compelling. It relies on the vastness of the planet to approximate random chance, and force dedicated adversaries to devote time and resources in spacetime (in an analogue to cryptography and keyspace), while clearly marking a location aids those are intrigued by it and lets them skip to planning on how to exploit it. In times when a trustworthy defense force may protect the site from adversaries, the public location is hard to exploit, but in times when no such force exists, the obscurity forces an adversary to expend more work than if the location were known.
- craftinator 8y agoAs I understand it, the reason you'd want to communicate that a radioactive waste dump is harmful is because of the very slow feedback loop that it causes. It would take people a long time, and many deaths/mutations to figure out that such an area is harmful; the signal has a very long wavelength, and could easily get lost in noise. It's easy to attribute that harm to other things, much like how many cultures didn't know about lead poisoning, even though it was happening all around them. I think a simple solution would be to dramatically increase the feedback loop, by putting nerve gas or landmines or other fast acting dangers in the area. It would very quickly be understood to be a "cursed" and dangerous place, and after very few deaths, people wouldn't go there anymore.
- newman8r 8y agoThis is always a fun read. I've been pondering creative ways to keep intruders off my land when I'm away for several months or more. I like the idea of using fake rattlesnake sounds near the structures - I'm thinking about rigging something up.
- jojoj 8y agoReminds me of the berlin holocaust memorial and it makes total sense.
- concernedLemur 8y agoThe giant spikes of varying styles are the most readable, but also the most intriguing and inviting. So, you have to figure on a few realities. First: With tectonic activity and geologic timescales, you’ll see possibly the entire continent migrate to a new climate, before full turnover. This could mean glaciation, mountain ranges, canyons and river or dense jungle. How it looks now, it might not look in one million years, at all. If there’s wildlife, no one will care about signage if the wildlife is healthy. Second: Archeological expeditions will try to explore the architecture, and some will die, before they figure it out. So, with explorers in mind, the spikes are a good landmark to raise general awareness that this unnatural structure exists, but, realistically, one has to expect attrition before any interested party gains full understanding, and thus a means of wayfinding that produces a sort of conceptual mummy’s curse should be engineered with an entrance. Third: There’s no consideration for intelligent animals of different sizes or scale in proportion to non-human bodies. From crustaceans and mollusks, to dancing bees, to talking dogs or socially regimented elephants and woolly mammoths that communicate with infrasound. What about those guys? Space aliens, you can bet will be fine, but nascent intelligent life that erupts in the wake of an extinct human civilization might need a clue as well...
- praptak 8y agoIt is a bit strange to worry about the safety of (a small subset of) people several hundred generations down while at the same time ignoring the possibility that Earth may not be hospitable to humans within two generations.
- RankingMember 8y agoPlan for the worst, hope for the best? I don't think the people planning for nuclear waste containment are ignoring the possibility of an inhospitable Earth in storing nuclear waste- it just makes good sense (to me at least) to make sure that a radioactive substance be as well-marked and stored as possible for whatever comes next.
- uryga 8y agofrom the "Personal thoughts" section of the document: > An analysis of the likely number of deaths over 10,000 years due to inadvertent intrusion should be conducted. This cost should be weighted against that of the marker system. i'm curious re: where you're coming from with "ignoring the possibility that Earth may not be hospitable to humans within two generations" – I feel like that's outside the scope of this document. also, couldn't the same be said about any plan with a long enough timeline?
- praptak 8y agoRight, I wasn't clear - my thought was in fact outside the scope of the document. I meant that it is strange to devote a large amount of resources to this document (which may prevent a few deaths in 10k years), while we might have already exceeded the carrying capacity of Earth (global climate change being the most imminent threat, but not necessarily the only one) and thus not have anyone to be around in 10k years.
- GuB-42 8y agoI don't like these messages. They are really patronized for the ones who are likely to be our future selves. Radioactive "waste" is rare material, full of energy. It is dangerous and we may not know what to do with it now but it may turn out valuable in the future. Just describe precisely what's inside.