4 ms·
I remain very confused about the focus on mobile banking apps. I watched as Windows Mobile sites extensively covered each and every bank that left the platform
by ocdtrekkie 8y ago
I remain very confused about the focus on mobile banking apps. I watched as Windows Mobile sites extensively covered each and every bank that left the platform like it was an incredible tragedy.
Banking is the most obvious case for doing over the web. It is silly to limit yourself to platforms which your specific bank happens to support, given the incredible multitude of banks, and the likelihood that most banks' apps probably suck anyhow.
- amelius 8y agoThe problem that a banking app solves is that it makes authentication simple; you can log in usually just by typing a PIN code on screen, and then you can do things like check transactions or balances, and even transfer small amounts of money without a hassle. This may not sound like a huge advantage, but remember that bank website authentication usually requires the use of a security token device. And this device is something you probably don't want to carry around all the time.
- tangue 8y agoI can do that with the website of my bank. Why do you want an app ? For security purposes ? ( true question as I don't understand the need for an app )
- saagarjha 8y agoApps can use biometric authentication, which is somewhat more convenient.
- amelius 8y agoBecause most banks only allow access through either the app (without token device, for small payments), OR through a website (with token device).
- tangue 8y agoOk, I didn't think about it but it might depend on countries. AFAIK only businesses needs token devices to do a wire transfer in Europe - at least in France (for individuals you usually need to register your phone number with your bank and add beneficiaries to a white list via text message confirmation for wire transfers in the SEPA zone) everything else is freely accessible via the website.
- alias_neo 8y agoIn the UK at least HSBC and Barclays need a hardware token device to set up new payees and perform certain transactions. HSBC recently allowed (and encourage) moving that token to the mobile app but they do NOT support using your phone number. Santander uses your phone number to send OTP by text for such purposes, and Monzo, the "modern bank" doesn't have a website, everything is done by app. Out of those Banks, Monzo is the only one that will allow you to run their app on a rooted phone.
- penagwin 8y agoConvenience with cashing checks too. Most banks (even tiny local ones) have a way for you to take a picture of both sides of the check. I'm not aware of any bank websites allowing you to do this? Sure it's easy to add but A) They're banks B) It's more akward, and less convient then the device that's in my pocket 24/7
- newnewpdro 8y agoYour comment implies the security of a pin code on your phone screen is equivalent to an air-gapped hardware token, which is obviously false. I think at this point we have enough examples of mobile phone numbers being insecure and mobile app stores being full of malware to categorically state your smartphone is not a secure enough device for accessing substantial sums of money.
- amelius 8y ago> Your comment implies the security of a pin code on your phone screen is equivalent to an air-gapped hardware token, which is obviously false. No, some banks allow only small payments after accessing the app without hardware token.
- penagwin 8y agoHe doesn't make that claim at all! It certainly would be less secure, but it's limited to smaller amounts of money. It depends on the banking app. For example, I'd rather have a 4 digit pin code to check my current balance then my 24char password. Also I have touchID so the security pin thing is a non-issue on my mobile device.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoI can deposit checks via my phone if I use my bank's app.
- TACIXAT 8y agoI can leave a phone in a drawer for the 4 times a year I do this.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoThis is what I do for Vudu's Mobile Disc to Digital. Have an Android phone I only power up when I want to convert a disc.
- _bxg1 8y agoI tried to use my bank's mobile site once and got my account locked because of "suspicious activity" (probably because my IP address was unusual/kept changing, because, you know, cell towers). When I talked to support, they recommended I use the native app.
- Mikeb85 8y agoDunno what the state of banking apps in the US is, but in Canada you can use them to instantly cash cheques, transfer money to others, pay vendors through NFC (without using Google or Apple as intermediaries), trade stocks, pay bills, etc... It's pretty damn convenient compared to websites, or banking apps of 5 years ago.