4 ms·
The bicycle like standing seat does look awful. Reclining, though, is a silly feature on coach airline seats. At best, you temporarily get more room at the ex
by tyingq 8y ago
The bicycle like standing seat does look awful.
Reclining, though, is a silly feature on coach airline seats. At best, you temporarily get more room at the expense of the person behind you. Until the person in front of you reclines. Reclining seats when the seat pitch is so tight is just dumb.
Oh, and if you get the paywall: http://archive.is/vqTNf http://archive.is/vqTNf
- gomox 8y agoIf you ever do a long haul flight in economy (which I assume you haven't) you will realize the obvious purpose of reclining coach seats: to allow people a fighting chance of remaining asleep instead of being constantly awakened by their falling heads.
- moftz 8y agoMy head just barely remains upright whenever I don't use the reclining function. I always feel bad invading the space of the person behind me, especially when it's a tall person who is already at the limit for room. Although I'll lean back all day long when it's a child behind me.
- gvurrdon 8y agoBeing such a tall person, your concern is appreciated. In economy class my knees touch the back of the seat in front even before it reclines.
- Someone1234 8y agoDitto. If the person reclines I'm literally pinned between their seat-back and my seat-front. I take painkillers for flying because I cannot wave my magic wand and spend 6x as much for higher class.
- moftz 8y agoI'm tall as well so it's more of just a courtesy that if I don't recline, the person behind me will pay it forward and not recline unless needed. On a red eye, it's always appropriate to recline though. Honestly, I just want to be knocked unconscious, stacked up and strapped down like firewood with others, and then woken up upon arrival. Flights would get so cheap and there wouldn't be any need for any amenities. I think I just hate the fake comfort that airlines try to give us. I'm never really going to enjoy sitting in a little seat inside a metal tube so just cut it with the forced nostalgia of the golden age of air travel and just get me to where I need to be a quickly and cheaply as possible. I'm flying overnight to Europe soon. The plan is to just take a couple anti-histamines and so I don't have to experience any of the flight.
- joezydeco 8y agoThe reclining seats also allow you to be shaken awake every 15 minutes as someone uses the headrests as handholds while walking up the aisle in the dark. That 45 degree upward incline in both directions is a bitch.
- tyingq 8y agoActually I do a lot of flying. the fact that the upright position isn't designed well doesn't really negate my point. A well-designed non reclining seat would work better with tight pitches.
- rootusrootus 8y agoWRT reclining, I disagree. The seats need to be upright enough so that emergency egress is easy, but that runs contrary to what is comfortable for many people. I don't need much recline, but allowing the seat to move back an inch or two (as measured at the top) makes a huge difference in posture.
- Someone1234 8y agoDelta's seats still do. They've just reduced the recline, not eliminated it.
- derekp7 8y agoI'd like to see reclining seats keep the top stationary, but move the bottom forward. That way when you recline you are only taking away your own space.
- rootusrootus 8y agoThat would probably require a larger seat pitch. No argument from me.
- cimmanom 8y agoNot having the top of the seat angled forward to push your head into a weird position would go a long way towards fixing that without reclining.
- tyingq 8y agoThen I would argue for leaving them permanently reclined. An inch or two of recline isn't really "recline" given the initial bolt upright setup. I don't see the tiny amount of recline affecting emergency egress...it might even improve it.