6 ms·
Some of these facilities have thousands of employees. A few hundred firings in a year seems, at a glance, plausible. In my experience when I was younger, low s
by Waterluvian 8y ago
Some of these facilities have thousands of employees. A few hundred firings in a year seems, at a glance, plausible.
In my experience when I was younger, low skill labour in warehouses often were employed with a wide net. Hire just about anyone and then fire the ones who show up drunk, high, not at all, slack off, pick fights, etc.
It's hard not to sound politically incorrect but these jobs attract unemployable people and they end up doing unemployable things and find themselves fired. My wife has similar stories about a Chrysler plant but holy cow those ones are unionized and never get fired.
I don't have all the facts but I'm just saying that on the surface, this is just kind of how it works. For all I know there may truly be something rotten and Amazon is being far more of a slave driver than is normal.
- subway 8y ago> Some of these facilities have thousands of employees. A few hundred firings in a year seems, at a glance, plausible. The article mentions these numbers are for a specific warehouse, and provides the total number of employees at that warehouse (~2500). If you're firing over 10% of your workforce annually for performance, you have fucked up expectations.
- jsnider3 8y agoDoesn't "rank and yank" traditionally advocate firing the bottom 10% of your workforce as part of the annual review process?
- subway 8y agoI'd personally consider the whole concept of a vitality curve to be rather fucked up. It's been all but abandoned by the biggest names behind it (GE, MS).
- throwawaysea 8y agoI don't think the fact that some companies have abandoned it means much. GE's peak days as a company were when they enforced a high bar using a curve. The same is true for Microsoft, whose better days ended around 2005. Although their stock performance in recent times has been strong, it is largely riding on the refresh of contracts relating to Office and the transition of clients from on-premise to cloud. There has been little actual innovation from the company, and although the culture has improved under Satya Nadella, employees regularly talk about workplace politics, low-quality hires, etc.
- negamax 8y agoI would disagree re: MS. They are doing pretty good in enterprise space, their bread and butter. Also whole XBox ecosystem is getting stronger as well
- jacquesm 8y ago> If you're firing over 10% of your workforce annually for performance, you have fucked up expectations. Or a seriously broken hiring process.
- beering 8y agoHow do I properly filter applicants for low-skill jobs? If I'm hiring for an Amazon warehouse, I'm not going to ask for a resume, and background checks only catch certain things. How else am I going to know you'll be a good worker in the warehouse other than hiring and seeing how it goes?
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>How do I properly filter applicants for low-skill jobs? You hire anyone with a pulse and fire anyone who's performance is not satisfactory. If you're Amazon's size you implement some sort of system using mostly objective metrics (e.g. a no-show counts as X points but a no call no show counts as Y points and you get fired at Z points) so you can quantify performance then you figure out your churn rate and size your pipeline to compensate.
- conductr 8y agoThis is all post employment. It’s not a predictive hiring model which is needed but pretty much impossible at this scale. Sounds horrible but it’s like asking for a model to determine which bums will use your charity for food instead of crack.
- bluGill 8y agoMore than that, for low skill jobs you don't want strong filters. If someone comes in and says "I was a slacker who never showed up, but now I'm reformed", "I got fired for being drunk at work but I learned my lesson", or "I just got out of prison for some awful crime and want to try honest work": you should hire them just on their word that they are reformed. Of course in all cases their word isn't worth much, but these are the first jobs of those who actually are reformed and you need to keep giving them fifth chances. If we don't slackers, drunks, and criminals need to be supported by society in some other way, which becomes a reward for bad behavior. So for low skill jobs you hire anyone, fire the ones who aren't good workers and promote the rest.
- post_break 8y agoI bet Fedex and UPS have a higher churn rate. I quit after the second day working in the hub.
- subway 8y agoRemember, this isn't the churn rate we're talking about. It's involuntary separation. I'd imagine the annual churn rate is way above 10%. I don't doubt FedEx and UPS have high churn rates, but I also suspect they don't fire 10% of their package handlers annually.
- sct202 8y agoThat 10% fired doesn't adjust for churn tho. Over the course of a year there were at minimum 2500 employees working there, we don't know how many unique people worked there over the course of a year to find out their firing rate.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- donarb 8y agoUPS does a lot of seasonal hiring during Christmas. This includes workers in distribution centers as well as helpers on delivery trucks.
- bluedino 8y agoI work for a mid-size manufacturing company, and we fire (or they quit) way, way more people than we keep
- stvswn 8y agoI wonder what the rate is at places which skew towards similar entry-level positions; for example, what % of people get fired annually in the fast-casual restaurant industry, or in retail? I don't know. I do think that in these sorts of industries, it's important to be able to hire people with a "probationary" mindset, because if firing weren't possible an employer would become a lot more risk-adverse. It's actually really important to people with no credentials or who might have a risky profile (a criminal conviction, for example) that they be allowed to prove themselves and start building a resume, so we should be careful about incentives in these cases.
- lazzlazzlazz 8y agoNetflix fires almost 10% of their workforce annually.
- subway 8y agoNetflix also compensates the ever-loving fuck out of you up until that moment.
- folkrav 8y agoI'm fairly certain most jobs at Netflix aren't low-skill warehousing.
- jkchu 8y agoDo you have proof??
- folkrav 8y ago> I'm fairly certain
- subway 8y agoYes, but for any given job at Netflix, you go in knowing other most gigs are going to pay at least 30% less for the same work. Amazon isn't paying their warehouse employees a premium rate to offset the risk of falling in the bottom 10%.
- extra88 8y agoDon't be so sure, they still run their disc rental service out of 17 distribution facilities. They added a lot of automation in their heyday but there's still a fair amount of low-skill work to be done. https://www.cnbc.com/2018/01/23/netflix-dvd-business-still-alive-what-is-it-like-to-work-there.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/01/23/netflix-dvd-business-still-a...
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoOne in ten per year sounds about right for these sorts of jobs. I bet if you drilled down you'd find that approximately that same 10% of people is getting fired from every other jobs too. There's always a minority that is screwing up fairly often. Combine that with rigid bigCo policies on timeliness, performance, etc and you can see how 10% per year get fired.
- negamax 8y agoI don't think companies really care. I have seen mass quit recently on a well oiled machine. Tech force, bad management practices. Nothing really changed and no one seem to care. In the end the quit rate was only increasing (the time that I quit)
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoI worked plenty of jobs like that until I got my degree. My experience lines up with yours. It's unsurprising that enough people screw up enough that a few hundred per year get fired. Edit: Don't get me wrong, the tracking system makes this sound like a particularly shitty job as far as shitty jobs go but most people should be able to hack it.
- jiveturkey 8y agoMy experience is similar, at many various low skilled jobs I've held. It's too bad they didn't say what the median time on the job was before getting fired. That would shed some light. The unemployable type get fired relatively quickly.
- bluedino 8y agoBut if we paid them more...
- jsnider3 8y agoThen Amazon would replace them with robots tomorrow instead of a few years from now.
- gist 8y agoI love the way you very skillfully walk on eggshells to be circumspect and polite to make your point so as to avoid backlash and ire. [1] It's as if anything anyone says today is assumed to be not politically correct unless they go out of their way to appear kind, considerate and caring. [1] Back in the day we would have just said 'they got fired because they are lazy losers'. I am reminded of the people working today at the seafood department at no less than Whole Foods. They didn't have the item that I normally get (literally every other day) and had no clue when they would get more in and didn't seem to care at all that I was a regular customer for that item. An actual 'shop owner' (small entrepreneur with a seafood store) would have likely cared much more and taken note that a regular customer desired the missing product. What did I think? Hmm "I guess that's why they are working the seafood counter at Whole Foods". Could there be other reasons why that is their job? Of course there could be other reasons but in any case the lack of caring about what they did (either the companies fault or their fault who knows) was very apparent and typically is. Interestingly the women who showed up the other day at my office (immigrants and honestly don't know immigration status they work for a contractor) were way more motivated even though they barely spoke english.
- 1000units 8y agoThis is maybe too harsh. A non-negligible portion of these people have what we today call learning disabilities.
- gist 8y ago> A non-negligible portion of these people have what we today call learning disabilities. Well sure but if you do and if that doesn't make you 'a winner' it makes you 'a loser' doesn't it? Point is if I have no athletic skills and can't play football or hockey or soccer 'because of disabilities' doesn't that make me 'a loser' in some way? The point is although people think that using the word 'loser' implies someone has control over the outcome but many times that is not the case. Often they have control but more often there is something else that is preventing them (family, abilities, intelligence) and so on.
- 8y ago
- dangerboysteve 8y agoI imagine all these facilities have a high churn rate of employees to begin with.
- village-idiot 8y agoGiven the stories I’ve heard about Amazon warehouses, I’m perfectly willing to believe they’re hiring with a wide net and there’s something rotten going on.
- ActorNightly 8y agoI did a research a while back on the sources of the articles. The reports of poor working conditions come from like 2 - 3 workers. There isn't really proof that its a widespread problem. Across the number of warehouses that Amazon has, its plausibile to believe there are a few locations that have a higher demand and/or managers trying to show better numbers, which translates to more stress on employees. Pick anyone who has worked for a large corporation, and they will probably tell you that there are location that are a PITA to work at in terms of demand and stress.
- jahaja 8y agoIt's really dystopian to me that somehow the people at the bottom of society are reflexively regarded as at fault, "they're lazy, dumb etc", rather than just a corporation looking to increase profits by scare tactics. They're truly second class citizens. This practice would not just be illegal here, it would also cause "obvious exploitation" outrage. Peoples worth as humans - which should include being able to sustain a livelihood and a decent life - is now more or less directly correlated to their worth in the marketplace. Unless they're able to prove their worth in the marketplace, hat in hand, no one cares about them, and they're discarded as trash. Just look how casually people accept workers loosing their livelihoods here, all from some sort subconscious idea of the ultimate fairness of the current supreme deity, the Market.
- ActorNightly 8y agoThe solution to that is more social programs, better education, and healthcare reform. I would bet many corporations would be on board with paying more taxes towards that, because its a lower cost to them then dealing with unions.
- orev 8y agoIsn’t it possible that many of these people are “at the bottom of society” because they’re lazy, etc? I’m not saying that’s everyone’s situation, but it is the case for many. There are plenty of people who spent their formative years partying and doing whatever else except for schooling, and these are the types of jobs that are left for them. It is a failure of society on some level, but it should not be up to the corporations to take on those people who are unemployable due to their own behavior and approach to life.
- ActorNightly 8y agoSome fall into the category, but quite a few are low skill immigrants that simply did not have opportunity for higher education.
- jyounker 8y agoI grew up in really shitty conditions. People at the bottom are usually there not because they suck as people, but because they started there, and the deck is stacked against them from the very beginning of their lives.