6 ms·
They may just be taking a calmer view of EV demand rather than betting the farm at every turn like Tesla. One or two quarters of running at capacity on a brand
by taneq 8y ago
They may just be taking a calmer view of EV demand rather than betting the farm at every turn like Tesla. One or two quarters of running at capacity on a brand new factory isn't enough reason to massively upgrade your production capacity, if you think it's just a hump and that demand will settle down again. The Model 3 may be "affordable" compared with the Model S / X, but US$35k is still luxury car territory.
- nradov 8y agoJust to be pedantic, in the US market $35K is technically the low end of premium car territory. Actually luxury car territory starts significant higher.
- wil421 8y agoSignificantly higher? A brand new 3 series is 40k, an Audi A4 is 39k, and a C Class is 41k. I’m not even looking at the smaller 4 door models from Audi and Benz which are even less than the Model 3. Maybe Europe gets a smaller 4 door BMW. I didn’t even count the offerings from Japan which are even less.
- nradov 8y agoAn Audi A4 is really not a luxury vehicle in any meaningful sense.
- wil421 8y agoThat’s a pretty laughable statement unless you’re in Europe and get the lower trims we don’t. Pretty much all car reviews put the A4 in the luxury sedan segment[1]. Not the segment with the Accord or Camry. Following your logic the model 3 isn’t a luxury car either. [1]https://www.caranddriver.com/features/g15379432/small-entry-level-luxury-cars/ https://www.caranddriver.com/features/g15379432/small-entry-...
- arethuza 8y agoObviously different markets classify "luxury cars" is very different ways leading to the confusion e.g. https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-news/best-cars/top-10-best-luxury-cars https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-news/best-cars/top-10-best-lux...
- wil421 8y agoThose are not mid size sedans. Some of those are not even Sedans like the Range Rover and I-Pace.
- arethuza 8y agoThe point I was trying to make is that different markets define "luxury" in different ways - I don't think anyone here in the UK would call an Audi A4 a luxury car - even at its highest spec level. Edit: Sort of reminds me of the differences in defining "class" between the US and the UK :-)
- lancewiggs 8y agoThat’s a statement that’s easy to make from a privileged position. Luxury is in the eyes of the beholder, and that car costs two thirds of the median income (before tax, healthcare, housing, food) in the USA.
- georgerobinson 8y agoIt's the same in Western Europe, the difference is that cheap lease deals and finance have made them affordable for a significant amount of people and so these cars are extremely common. You see more 3 series than Toyota's or Hyundai's.
- oblio 8y agoAre you sure about that? https://www.bbc.com/news/business-46774053 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-46774053 Every sales graph I've ever seen has relatively cheap cars such as the Fiesta, Golf, Corsa, etc. at the top. Not big Mercedes or BMWs.
- georgerobinson 8y agoYes. I'm not saying that people in the market for a Ford Fiesta are instead going out and buying a 3 series. People who want a hatchback and going out and buying hatchbacks. But people who want saloons and estate cars are largely buying from the three Germans, and not Japanese or Korean.
- sliken 8y agoI've heard one of the more popular cars people moved from to buy a model 3 is the toyota prius... definitely not a luxury car.
- georgerobinson 8y agoToyota Prius do not exist in Western Europe outside Uber. They are synonymous with Uber driver and rarely ever bought for private use.
- BoorishBears 8y agoIf the A4 isn’t a luxury vehicle, the Model 3 is what?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- argonaut 8y agoThis is being unnecessarily pedantic. "Premium" is synonymous with "entry-level luxury" (one example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luxury_vehicle#Premium_compact_/_entry-level_luxury https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luxury_vehicle#Premium_compact...). Cars in the 35-45k range are routinely referred to colloquially as "luxury" cars. I agree you can quibble with this terminology, but it is absolutely common to refer to these cars as luxury, albeit the absolute low end of luxury.
- supernovae 8y agoA Jeep Wrangler will cost you 35k for a base model these days and 40k for a "premium" that well, most people still upgrade and tweak for 10s of thousands of more when they get home. My volt was super expensive in 2011, but 8 years on it still drives like the day it came from the factory. Unlike my Jeep (which i love) that is only a year old and already has aches and pains and squeeks and of course, drinks gas like its going of style. BTW, when people shop for cars, the purchase price isn't the TCO. How much fuel will you be using and how much maintenance will you dump into it?
- sliken 8y agoAgreed. Seems like Tesla may have misjudged the model 3 demand and should have increased the number of production lines more slowly. I think in Fremont factory has 6 lines. One for X, one for S, and 4 for the model 3. Seems like they should just move one or two of the lines from model 3 to the model Y, which shares 75% of the same parts instead of committing to building several new lines in Reno and China. While the model 3 may be luxury, it looks crazy cheap compared to the electric Audi, Volvo, BMW, and Porsche competitors... doubly so if you consider range. The model 3 even looks pretty good on a cost to own basis compared to non-luxury cars like the Toyota Camry or Honda accord. The cheapest Tesla (around $40k these days), isn't too far off the average cost of a new car ($34,000) and most will save easily $6k in maintenance and gas over the life of the car. I suspect most would consider the model 3 interior too spartan and plasticy to be consider luxury.
- novaRom 8y ago>> While the model 3 may be luxury, it looks crazy cheap compared to the electric Audi, Volvo, BMW, and Porsche competitors... I tried Tesla test drive and one thing I don't like is how cheap it feels inside. Low quality materials. So you cannot compare just their prices without mentioning materials and build quality.
- sliken 8y agoI rented a Tesla S (75d I believe) for 3 days. Felt pretty awesome, and stomping on the accelerator put a smile on my face every time. The nav system was a pleasure, actually better than Google Nav on a top of the line phone. The voice recognition for nav and music playing worked really well. I've used similar nav systems from BMW, Subaru, and Toyota and they seemed like lame software running on a 5-10 year old phone. Poor touch screens, smaller screens, poor voice recognition, and poor nav. I'd rather they just have an aux port for music and let me hang my own tablet on the dash somewhere. Overall fit/finish for the model S was not as nice as an Audi I've been in, but was plenty good for me. The model 3 is of course substantially less luxurious. Single smaller display instead of two displays. Many less buttons/switches. I've only done a test drive in the 3. But I do have several friends that have switches from S to 3, or 3 to S, and they speak very highly of the 3. No doubt the 3 is built to a much lower price point, and you can tell. I think part of the Tesla plan is to have you touch nothing but the steering wheel or the display. I suspect the voice commands will get better over time, they already handle nav and music well. But when it comes down to it, I'd pick performance, handling, and range over more expensive interior. Not like Audi, Volvo, or BMW is selling anything close to the model 3 price and range. I drove a Chevy Volt (comparable on price, but not so much on range or performance) and it was nowhere close to the model 3. Who is willing to buy a slower car and pay 50% more for 2/3rds the range just to get a nicer interior? Not me.
- distances 8y ago> The Model 3 may be "affordable" compared with the Model S / X, but US$35k is still luxury car territory. Indeed, Model 3 is still very far from affordable. In Finland it sells starting at $70,600 (taxes included). I'm assuming there are also import duties from the US, though don't know the details. Needless to say, at this price point there are probably more people looking for an apartment than a car.