4 ms·
It's different from AllAdvantage with the addition of market mechanisms to correctly price the attention consumed by ads. That's why users get tokens for viewi
by nostrademons 8y ago
It's different from AllAdvantage with the addition of market mechanisms to correctly price the attention consumed by ads.
That's why users get tokens for viewing, why users can turn the ads off entirely, and why the tokens are tradeable on exchanges. It creates a built-in feedback mechanism. If BAT is priced too low, then everybody will opt out of ads (because it won't be worth it to them), very little BAT will be available on the market, and advertisers will have to bid up the price of BAT to run their ads. If BAT is priced too high, there will be excess ad inventory, no advertisers will buy in, and the price of BAT will fall until it reaches an equilibrium.
AllAdvantage.com failed in a large part because they mispriced the rebates going back to users. They burned through all their VC cash, didn't provide enough value to advertisers, and went out of business. Brave avoids that by letting the market make the pricing decisions.
This is something that couldn't have been done at all before cryptocurrencies, which is what makes this project somewhat interesting.
- manigandham 8y agoWhy would advertisers bid higher when this is not the only channel and comes with less targeting and increased fraud potential? Why would users opt-in at all to see ads when they're already blocked? There seems to be missing component of why both sides want to interact through the Brave network.
- nostrademons 8y ago> Why would advertisers bid higher when this is not the only channel and comes with less targeting and increased fraud potential? Brave's model - like all ad-supported ones - depends upon them getting very big, enough that they get a substantial fraction of total user attention. They're going for this by blocking all existing ads, which in today's web makes the browser significantly faster and less annoying. They're at about 5.5M users as of January 2019, up from 3M in July 2018. That's still a long way to go, but it's growing fast. > Why would users opt-in at all to see ads when they're already blocked? Because they get money for it.
- manigandham 8y ago"“A lot of users don’t want to cash out [when they receive BAT],” he added. “It’s not a huge amount of value for most people, so they may prefer to just use it to give back." In that case, it's just an ad network. Users watch ads, publishers get paid. Only difference is a new middleman and 2 hops for payments. Also if the money does add up to a sizable amount then it will be overrun by ad fraud.
- rvnx 8y agoIt's an incentive adnetwork, users are paid for watching (openly) and clicking ads and installing offers (implicitly, because they get more money if they do). Is it sustainable for advertisers ? Would you want to pay for visitors forced to click on your ads ?
- krageon 8y agoUsers aren't paid for watching, they are paid for the browser loading the advertisements. I promise you that the moment this becomes even remotely profitable, people will be running VPSes with automated browsers (or multiple local instances rendering to a virtual frame buffer, with mice/keyboards simulated to generate clicks). There is no way around this kind of automation, except perhaps given some pretty invasive rootkitting done my the browser (and that still doesn't mitigate the virtualisation problem). Given that these things are possible or even pretty easy to do, it is an inescapable fact that this model will fail.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Because they get money for it. When that becomes a real motivation, it'll collapse the system, because view-fraud will either overwhelm honest views or Brave will be forced to take invasive measures to try to prevent such fraud.
- rchaud 8y agoI believe view fraud is exactly what happened to the dotcom-era company that offered to pay users. I recall reading about it in Michael Lewis' book "Panic!" No wonder Brave is trying to pay people with a useless e-token.
- michaelbrooks 8y agoWebsite based ads stay blocked. The ads you're viewing are built into the browser which removes any privacy concerns because they aren't sending your personal data to any servers. All personal data stay within the browser and remains there forever or until you delete the browser or format your HDD.
- robertsasu 8y agoThere is still a synchronization of how many seconds you watched the ads. I really doubt that these ads will not be directed to users, depending on their preferences. The same thing facebook and google does. If a company comes and will offer millions of dollars to track users, like what kind of ads a specific user / target group is watching, will brave say no ?
- dragonwriter 8y ago> It's different from AllAdvantage with the addition of market mechanisms to correctly price the attention consumed by ads. It doesn't price attention (which cannot be measured) it prices ad deliveries to the user agent. Once a threshold of interest is raced, the incentive to create a discrepancy between the latter and former to make off with BAT for, easentially, free (devaluing actual attention) will either collapse the system or force Brave into all the intrusive measures other vendors who want to try to assure customers that interactions being monitored involve actual human attention have taken in the past.