3 ms·
If you want advertisers, you need to care about what the industry wants. Obviously that's for Brave to deal with, not the users, but showing ads for money is an
by manigandham 8y ago
If you want advertisers, you need to care about what the industry wants. Obviously that's for Brave to deal with, not the users, but showing ads for money is an ad network.
Microtransactions have been tried many times. I spent half a million testing it. Didn't work because of user behavior. And unless users are buying with their own money, it's just converting the BAT they earn from ads into BAT they pay the publisher. This is an ad network.
Even the block-and-replace-ads model has been tried before. Everything from iframes to browser toolbars. Again, this is an ad network.
If you have to use language like "economic layer" to describe your business model, you're either hiding something or you don't have one. Or we can just use the standard definition: brave is a browser-based ad network.
- PudgePacket 8y agoBrave doesn't need advertisers though, it needs users. Once it has users then advertisers need Brave. I don't see how Brave has to win over advertisers at all, they'll come around when Brave can offer some non-insignificant amount of money to them.
- LowLevelHacker 8y agoI'd like to incentivise unique users to visit/revisit the site, is that part of the idea that of BAT?
- manigandham 8y agoIt is supposed to be possible for publishers to spend their BAT on paying users to visit or promote their content.
- manigandham 8y agoAdvertisers have several supply paths to inventory and what gets chosen is a complicated series of decisions. Brave is just not very enticing. Having a large user base isn't useful if there isn't effective delivery and performance. It's always possible to get the low-end performance marketers because they'll buy anything if it works but it won't be good quality. Also the current trade of content for ads makes sense. When it's opt-in, I fail to see why users would enable ads if they can get the content for free anyway. And if the ads are all low-end spam then I definitely don't see why they would choose them. It's a very tough 3-way marketplace to bootstrap where the user has all of the control and none of the incentive.
- ignoramous 8y ago> Brave is just not very enticing. Sure, but folks I know use it because it has other utilities than just block ads (like use less power, for instance) whilst retaining the compatibility that comes with being based on Chromium. > Also the current trade of content for ads makes sense. When the rate of folks blocking ads keeps increasing, does it though, in the long run? > When it's opt-in, I fail to see why users would enable ads if they can get the content for free anyway. And if the ads are all low-end spam then I definitely don't see why they would choose them. I hope you do realise the number of ifs and buts in your assumptions? > It's a very tough 3-way marketplace to bootstrap where the user has all of the control and none of the incentive. I realise that you are intimately familiar with the industry, but it takes a substantial rethink to overhaul something as entrenched as the online ad business. There's novelty to Brave's approach, I don't think anyone can deny that. Browsers are gateway to the web, equally how Google (homepage) is, and folks are right to take that market on, instead of taking the giants like Facebook and Google at their own game. I would like to refer you to how telegram has replaced browsers for most folks I know (they literally use it to search memes, videos, photos, links); and how WhatsApp has replaced email. The ads would be where content is. If browsers increasingly act as arbitrators of that content, then they're best placed to monetize it, as well, imo. It is another matter for folks who simply detest ads, they're not intended users Brave is targeting, but some folks do feel guilt blocking them and wouldn't mind a middle ground. Also, you must realise that a large portion of the internet don't use any form of ad-blockers whatsoever, and when they stumble on Brave (because it is great for battery life and other features), they'd be more than happy to keep seeing ads that aren't all encompassing and privacy respecting, I'm sure.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Once it has users then advertisers need Brave. No, once it has users, advertisers need to advertise in a way which Brave does not manage to block. There are a number of already known methods for that; they are less cost effective than current ad models, but so would be what Brave is offering.
- RenRav 8y agoI have a massive 10-years old block filter and never tolerated ads, but Brave changed this. I think now advertisers can make money off me finally. The majority of brave users will be past ad-blockers, so advertisers can now make some money from this group. I don't want to do anything with the BAT, I just want to see how advertisers respond and see how it progresses. I can't wait to see ads on my phone for once.
- krageon 8y ago> I can't wait to see ads on my phone for once. This made me smile slightly. If you don't mind me asking, why?
- justsee 8y agoBrave's an open-source, privacy-respecting browser with a digital wallet baked in. The microtransaction opportunities that are opened up by having such a low-friction economic layer native to the browser is what's particularly interesting about Brave. Even the criticisms of Brave's microtransaction potential are encouraging, because they're usually unserious, rely on hand-waving references to previous weak and incomparable attempts and appear to emanate from accounts that have an agenda beyond good-faith technical / behavioural evaluation. I understand the need to incorporate an optional ad network within it, and already see that it's a far superior model compared to the current ad-tech ecosystem that it can and should replace. It remains to be seen whether it can get commercial traction but considering how quickly and deeply the mood has shifted against Google / Facebook / the current ad-tech ecosystem you'd have to say there has been no better time to trial a new approach to funding content on the web.
- manigandham 8y agoMicrotransactions are about user behavior, not tech. We had a low-friction experience with a browser extension and that's been possible for several years. Convincing people to value content, judge the price, and spend their own money is the real challenge. And if people aren't spending their own money then it's just an ad network in the browser to replace an ad network on the page. Not revolutionary and open to all the same concerns of ads today. 99% of people don't notice "privacy", they care about intrusiveness and annoying experiences. That's what's visible so having an ad is the same effect for them regardless of how it's delivered. If you want to judge my perspective then read this first [1]. It's great to have alternatives and I'm as interested as you to see how this experiment works out. 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19593812 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19593812
- justsee 8y agoMicrotransactions are about user behaviour and tech. Your exploratory attempts with a browser plugin do not sound comparable to what Brave is attempting. Attempting to dismiss Brave by begging the question isn't convincing: "Brave won't succeed and isn't revolutionary if we assume the revolutionary bits won't succeed." Claiming - after your initial uninformed and dismissive commentary - to now be an honest and good-faith participant is curious. Innovating on a new utility-scale ad / content model in a multi-sided market with a new browser relying on a new cryptoeconomic infrastructure which if successful threatens huge, well-funded industry participants is certainly a challenge. But the Brave team are pretty peerless when looking at the needed skillset, the moment in time for an industry-wide shift seems to be here and the mix of incentives: battery life, speed, memory, privacy, user growth pool tokens for donations, future content payment options, on-device learning model, zero-knowledge proof privacy, cross-device syncing etc are very compelling.
- peteretep 8y ago> If you want advertisers, you need to care about what the industry wants No no. If you want advertisers you need to offer a return on investment. That's it. Any rational advertiser is going to pump as much money as has a return into advertising.
- manigandham 8y agoYes. I just disagree that Brave will deliver users that provide a return. Ads are opt-in, payment models are undefined, and verification is lacking.