2 ms·
A bunch of others have made the obvious reply, that knowing the keys doesn't transfer legal ownership. But you still have a good point: Ethereum -- which the a
by SilasX 8y ago
A bunch of others have made the obvious reply, that knowing the keys doesn't transfer legal ownership.
But you still have a good point: Ethereum -- which the article is about -- specifically endorses the philosophy of "code is law", that you can actually replace all of law enforcement and courts with smart contracts on the blockchain, that there's no need for an external power to override its results.
Dumb contract spec? Give out the private keys? Tough. "Code is law."
This is a philosophy not universally held by blockchain advocates, but definitely held by Ethereum advocates (if inconsistently -- see DAO hack). So it's a fair response in this case.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Scoundreller 8y agoYour post confuses me. Ethereum did a rollback, so how can they continue with their “Code is Law” belief? An inconsistently adopted/implemented belief doesn’t sound like a belief at all.
- SilasX 8y agoI agree they've been hypocritical about it, but it's at least what they claim to support.