7 ms·
I really think we as a society need to figure out how to properly fund unbiased reporting without letting the government step in as a censor but while letting o
by munk-a 8y ago
I really think we as a society need to figure out how to properly fund unbiased reporting without letting the government step in as a censor but while letting outlets be called out for outright falsehoods - I think this is a very hard problem to solve and solutions have been tried many times in the past.
- bmmayer1 8y agoWhat, exactly, is unbiased reporting?
- nkozyra 8y agoAn unattainable ideal, sure, but one that noble media organizations can aspire to. Notably through: open editorial processes, balanced sourcing and attribution, a robust correction policy, a non-combative relationship with readers, use of a neutral styleguide, eschewing advertorial content and NO EDITORIALS/OPINION PIECES.
- bmmayer1 8y agoCould you give an example of a "noble media organization" that comes the closest, in your view, to achieving this goal?
- nkozyra 8y agoI don't think any comes that close. Most are stuck in an unfortunate race to the bottom against cheap social/internet/clickbait news and the shackles of archaic old media.
- Mediterraneo10 8y agoThe Weather Channel?
- nkozyra 8y agoTongue in cheek, but they have really mastered clickbait
- ars 8y agoReuters
- kristianc 8y agoThe FT
- chrisseaton 8y agoI think the FT is biased in favour of free markets and globalisation.
- kristianc 8y agoMost of the economics profession is biased in favour of some regulated form of free markets and globalization. That's a bit like saying scientists are biased in favour of anthropic climate change: it's a rational bias based on 200 years of evidence.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- exolymph 8y agoNot every value that people hold is economically reducible.
- kristianc 8y agoIn the FT's case, it is. The FT doesn't 'know a lot', it largely reflects the mainstream consensus of the economics literature and think tanks - which are broadly pro market with regulation, in line with much of the economics profession. The FT has come out and said that if most of the economics literature was in favour of Brexit, they would have been too, but it wasn't, so they weren't. There was a lot of concern with Nikkei's investment in the FT that that would no longer be the case and that it would kowtow to it's corporate owners - if proved not to be the case.
- pytester 8y ago
- secabeen 8y agoAP/Reuters for basic stories. https://www.adfontesmedia.com/ https://www.adfontesmedia.com/
- SeanLuke 8y agoC-SPAN
- munk-a 8y agoI think opinion pieces and editorials can be included as long as they are clearly marked and delineated from the actual news. In fact, I think it's almost impossible to write an unopinionated news story as choosing to write a story is an opinion of itself - the clearer we can isolate these opinions the better.
- nkozyra 8y agoThe problem is these tend to reinforce opinions people have about an organization or "the media" even when clearly denoted.
- munk-a 8y agoI'd like to imagine there's some way for society to recover to the state of semi-trusted media, maybe we just need to have enough voices that the truth comes out in majority - like industry run newspapers, the cotton lobby's paper is clearly biased on this article about reducing fabric tariff's from mexico but the jeweler's quarterly newspaper doesn't have a vested interest. As I said, it's a hard problem. I like the discussion on trying to find an answer though!
- secabeen 8y agoThe challenge is that even when clearly marked as opinion, they still accrue to the reputation of the publication. If you look at the Most Read links on WaPo or NYT, the opinion pieces are often more than half.
- achenatx 8y agoone of the easiest ways is to avoid using most adjectives. Not taking a point of view, not speculating, not predicting the future. Limit the use of verbs with strong negative or positive connotations. Stick to what people did, what they said, and let people draw their own conclusions. Story selection is also a form of bias. <<The usual tensions between reporters and government representatives have escalated to extreme levels in the Trump age, due largely to the President's near-daily attacks against the media. His portrayal of the people who cover him as his "enemy" and the "enemy of the people" has been denounced by historians, press freedom advocates and politicians in both parties.>>
- s_y_n_t_a_x 8y agoThat's something you should have learnt in grade school.
- gutnor 8y agoIt could be done with a new separate branch of government. It used to be there was good money to make doing it privately, but nowadays the system needs government funding. Impartial and accessible (also meaning average Joe can understand it) information is as fundamental as the judiciary in order to maintain a working democracy. There are various element of it in various countries. Like national offices of statistic. There are stuff like the BBC and variety of EU initiative to inform about various processes. Democratic government keep complete record and have public service already make analysis and summary for ministers to work with. So it's not like it is out of the realm of the achievable. Maybe an official rating could be created based on a service like politifact that independant newspaper must display on their frontpage like the food safety rating for restaurants. Teach the kid at school that anything not rated is basically fiction and that will take care of the majority of the population. There is the risk of it becoming a propaganda arm of the government, sure, but you can have the same argument with every branch of the government. There is no intrinsic reason to trust the judiciary, the military or the police, except a tradition of being trustworthy which is really what maintain the whole system running: a lot of honest people everywhere. In any case, that's a moot point since the journalism it replaces is dying, and we know the new media that is killing it is not even pretending to have any kind of integrity.
- verall 8y agoIt really does bring up though questions though, like when you look at the current administration and what they have done with the White House press office. Imagine if there existed a well-respected and trusted national news outfit that was suddenly being run by Sarah Huckabee Sanders. With the normal United States executive branch spoils system it would be a shitshow. It'd have to be like 4th branch of government or at least run separately like the Fed does.
- babyloneleven 8y agoIt shouldn't be part of the Executive but its own branch, as independent as the judiciary
- 8y ago
- save_ferris 8y agoUnbiased reporting has never existed in the history of the US press, and likely never will. The very decision to publish or not publish story inserts a little bias. The press can't possibly cover everything, so they have to decide what should be printed, and it's not always a straightforward decision. 40 years ago, there were several nationally recognized publications (NYT, WaPo, WSJ, etc.), and all of them had a bias. NYT editorial leaned left, WSJ editorial leaned right, and everyone knew this. The political leaning was baked into brand of the publication. This all changed in the internet era. The collapse of print advertising decimated the industry. Publications became more incentivized to publish questionable reporting because clickbaity headlines brought more ad traffic. The Trump campaign was covered ad nauseum because having his name in a headline significantly increased traffic to an article, and thus revenue. The online advertising model is fundamentally incompatible with the kind of journalism you're looking for, but we as a society are hooked on it because it means we don't have to pay for the content.
- davidw 8y agoPapers like the NYT, WP and WSJ are doing ok. It's the local ones that are dying or getting bought out and gutted. This is a big problem, because no one else sits through those hours of local meetings that mean so much to our cities in terms of transportation, housing, schools and so on.
- brainpool 8y agoSecond that opinion. Local media is crucially important. Not least as it serves as a public record in an edited and readable form, moreover, most journalists at the “big” papers also have a background in local press. That’s where you learn the ropes and the craft of reporting.
- massysett 8y agoNot true. Television stations have reporters. Radio stations have reporters. Some are for-profit, some are public. They report on local meetings. Websites are cropping up that have reporters that cover local matters: https://www.marylandmatters.org/ https://www.marylandmatters.org/ https://marylandreporter.com/ https://marylandreporter.com/ Maryland Public Television sends three reporters, plus an anchor and all the associated production staff, to cover the Maryland General Assembly each year. They sit through the hours of debates. They interview lawmakers. The newspaper never was the only source of local news, and now more than ever there are places to get local news if people bother to look.
- fma 8y agoI wonder if libraries can have some journalists on staff? Or a librarian that is part time librarian, part time journalist. As far as bias...it's hard to be unbias. Maybe there's some questionnaire that determines your bias, and libraries hire journalist that have different bias so they can keep each other in check. The funding would of course, but local taxes.
- diminoten 8y agoYou need to give up on the government not being involved at all, because that's the only realistic way it'll ever happen.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- notatoad 8y agoIt's a problem that Facebook, Twitter, or YouTube could solve essentially overnight, if there was any motivation for them to do it. They are the media companies of our day, and they have the capital to hire local reporters in the 500-1000 largest metro areas in the us.
- ardy42 8y ago> It's a problem that Facebook, Twitter, or YouTube could solve essentially overnight No, it's not. All of those companies are extremely averse to putting boots on the ground, preferring software solutions instead. Proper journalism worthy of the name (e.g. stuff beyond formulaic reporting like sports scores and financial prices), can't be done by software.
- notatoad 8y agoTo be clear, my suggestion was that they should put boots on the ground, not that they should employ bots or ml. There are journalists looking for work and there are media companies with more money than they know what to do with. Facebook could hire local journalists. I know they won't, because they don't care about the quality of content on their platform. But there's no reason they couldn't hire actual journalists to do actual reporting for their platform, except that nobody is demanding it of them.
- jfk13 8y agoOf course they could. But if they did hire local journalists all over the country, those journalists would have a strong incentive to produce content that drives maximal "engagement" on facebook's platform. That's just a recipe for even more clickbait and outrage-driven reporting. No thanks.
- preommr 8y agoI feel like that's a very naive way to look at it. Lots of entities have enough capital to get a news company going, the problem is profitability and long-term sustainability. Not to mention running an actual news agency. Just because a company is profitable in one area doesn't mean they're guaranteed success in another. How are companies like Facebook supposed to solve this problem? Where is the money to pay for these journalists going to come from? The ad revenue generated by that wing of their company? If it was that easy, then existing media companies wouldn't be struggling. If you're counting on there being synergy between their existing userbase then I don't think it's worth it because there's so many risks. If a company starts pushing a certain type of news, their credibility and their brand would be so closely tied together with their news branch that either the news would be very bland and have a n agenda while also potentially alienating a large portion of users. This could very well lead to killing their main product. Companies like google are already under fire for being partial. Add in them actively writing about things like politics and it'd be like adding a barrel of oil. Not to mention the anti-trust laws involved. Companies like the ones you mentioned are already overpowered let alone giving them the keys to present actual news.