8 ms·
How the Kleiner Perkins Empire Fell
- gkolli 8y agoVery interesting take on KP. Anyone from the inside (recent startup founders, ex-employees, etc.) want to chime in? Would love to hear.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mathattack 8y agoI’ve had very positive interactions with them. (Not an insider.) They we’re very professional and helpful.
- probdist 8y agoI'm a former early employee at a KP backed start up. Nothing but respect and good vibes from the folks I met with or presented to from KP.
- dopeboy 8y agoI've done some contract engineering work for them onsite. Super professional and talented engineers inside.
- srcmap 8y agoI was an employee worked for KP invested Startup by 3 extremely smart MIT Phds. Smartest people I ever worked with - one of them can do Analog, FPGA, Linux kernel all the same time. We created a system with 10G interface (15 years ago) deployed in Comcast and generated 40+ million revenue with < 10 employees. After that, KP installed their own CEO with old analog modem background, fired the extremely experience VP of engr, hire/fire 3 CTOs and hire 160 people to "scale" the company and burn all the cash without deliver one single product in the next 6 years. The CEO also manager to get rid of all 3 founders.
- peteradio 8y agoNOICE!
- iamleppert 8y agoMaybe they should implement OKR’s over there and see how it goes for them??
- heymijo 8y agoI laughed. I can go glass half-full or empty on OKR's. They obviously have value, but using OKR's at Google is one of the biggest selection biases possible. Google seems to have done so many things in its history that would be death for other org's. The episode about firing all managers is a great in-depth story of stupidity. Yet Google succeeded because they had and have an absolute lock on the search market. Dear Doerr, convince me about OKR's another way. I would also love to see what OKR's looked like throughout some of the products at Google that they have sunset or flopped. G+, RSS, Wave, Hangouts, etc. - OKR's are a useful tool but they aren't what made Google a $750 billion company.
- iamleppert 8y agoI only jest because I did see John speak and give a presentation about his OKR system while I was working at Airware (now defunct). I was just fresh from LinkedIn, where OKR’s had recently been implemented. I got to see how they systematically eliminated some of the best employees in favor of those who were willing to game the system and create fake goals for themselves. As I sat in the audience, I thought to myself, “Finally I’m meeting the fabled creator of OKR’s.” Airware went out of business a few years later.
- heymijo 8y agoI would have been mad. Heck, I'm mad just reading that. It's bad management. If you are going to use metrics you have to know that they are going to create perverse incentives. It's management's job to be vigilant in seeing/hearing and looking for those perverse incentives and then determining if the trade off is acceptable.
- village-idiot 8y ago
- areoform 8y agoSomething that gets missed out a lot from the conversations about VC firms is the problem of generating deal flow. Good VC firms (and great investors) need to not only know how to invest and support a great company but also how to get them through the door. I suspect it's why socially adept people thrive in VC so much - they can quickly learn how to create a spider's web around them and listen in for deals. For most of its life, KPCB had a web around the firm. Great companies would come in and pitch themselves. So, for the most part, the job was to "only" pick whom to invest in (picking is just as hard!). As an extreme outsider, it seems that their operating rubric is so focused on this that they've lost the institutional capacity to spin new webs of their own. They are reliant on outsized personalities delivering the win rather than the institution itself pulling it in. That's a tricky spot for the firm to be in. And it's a tricker spot to navigate out of. They'll have to rebuild institutional knowledge and prospect like other firms now; a mindset shift that could be hard for most veterans to get into as early on this would have been a negative signal in their careers and for their firm. Now, that it's a requirement; it has to be a tough sell to everyone involved (note: I don't know anyone at the firm. I have simply seen this pattern play out a few times). They can hire fantastic new investors who know how to hunt, but will the firm be able to listen to them? This is a firm where getting rid of nametags was noteworthy enough to make it into Fortune; imagine how hard a sell getting down into the mud must be. FWIW, such firms eventually recover. Eventually. They're just too big not to. But it is a painful road until that point. I wish the best of luck to them.
- jiveturkey 8y ago> For most of its life, KPCB had a web around the firm. [... Then they didn't.] Was this an organic thing of their own doing, or was this due to disruptors, like A16Z?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mindgam3 8y ago[reposting earlier comment reply as a top level comment + edited] Disclaimer: my whole career is on the consumer software side, so I can only speak to that. I have zero insight on Kleiner as it relates to enterprise. My first time inside KP was in 2003, working out of their office for a few months during a coding internship at Digital Chocolate. Great snacks and drinks freely available made quite impression on me as a college student. Second time was in 2011 when I came in to pitch my first startup with Aileen Lee. It was a pre-revenue consumer play, not particularly in her wheelhouse of e-commerce, so nothing came of it. She was pleasant and professional. My only complaint was that she/Kleiner didn't seem particularly "hip". Not that VCs are particularly known for their cool factor, but for some reason I had expected something a little less square based on Kleiner's reputation. I think this otherwise excellent article does a disservice by not mentioning Ilya Fushman joining on their timeline of key events. (It does mention him later, mostly in passing). I've never worked with him, but we have mutual acquaintances and have probably been to a few of the same parties. From my perspective as a not-total-outsider, Fushman brings some fresh thinking to a firm that is badly in need of relevancy/culture refresh. If they'd had someone like him there in 2011, for example, that would have made for a much more interesting meeting for me and other other consumer-facing entrepreneurs. Not sure if and when they'll ever regain the kind of dominance they had at their heyday, but I do think being hipster credibility matters for consumer plays, and with Fushman on board Kleiner now has a solid chance to play in this space again.
- username223 8y ago> pre-revenue consumer play So, translating that into English, you were losing money giving something to individual people, but hoped you could do... what? Start charging money? Harvest data? Get bought before you ran out of VC money? This sort of "founder" bafflegab is annoying.
- nemothekid 8y agoHe could have done any of those things, but it's not relevant to the story. In this case what 'pre-revenue consumer play' means they were a company focused on showing user growth before generating revenue, and the VC they pitched had more experience e-commerce companies (which usually have some revenue).
- olivermarks 8y agoMy semi outsider observation is that it's a crap shoot which sector you place your bets on. Doerr lost his shirt on green tech when it went out of fashion. We are arguably now in another dotcom style investment bubble: KP lived through the earlier dot com boom and bust and was probably overly cautious in betting on which platform companies would be winner takes all post web 2.0 era. You can only have the midas touch for so long before age and experience gets in the way as much as it helps
- bobsil1 8y agoMy vague impression is they were conservative, didn't make the leap to Net valuations based on traffic and little revenues.
- bedhead 8y agoI remember about 7-8 years ago seeing John Doerr give a talk somewhere and he literally started desperately fighting back tears because he thought humanity was imminently going to go extinct because of climate change. I realized he'd lost his mind and figured KPCB was toast. Not sure if I'm supposed to feel good about some validation of that.
- Kurtose 8y agoSpot-on.
- hendzen 8y agoThere is an interview with Andy Rachleff (former VC at Benchmark and CEO of Wealthfront), where he notes that the problem with Kleiner is that the old partners never retired. They just stayed on and did very little actual work but since they owned huge stakes in the partnership they collected much of the carry. Over time new firms (like Benchmark) formed that basically pushed out partners who started coasting. If you are an ambitious young VC which kind of firm would you work for?
- winningcontinue 8y agoA top heavy old partner institutional firm is not a bad thing. The they're usually hands off once you invest and take their money. The problem is they're too conservative with their capital, and only invest in trends that have passed by decades ago to pursue the next big thing. As an entrepeneur in the dining and technology space knows how and where I want to grow my company, I'd rather see my angel investment funders come from the old cohort than the younger firms seeking radical changes.
- mathattack 8y agoIn the case of Kleiner, the article puns it on a wrong bet (green energy) rather than being too conservative.
- maxgiraldo 8y agoI'm still under the impression that if you gave the same set of companies to every VC in the world and had each of them bet on the winners, that you wouldn't see that much of a difference in portfolio performance from the very worst to the very best VCs. There's no magic formula for choosing companies that firms like KP have--a lot of it is based on their reputation. Plus, the next Facebook is not going to look like Facebook or whatever that maxim was. The better companies tend to go to the VCs with the better reputation and the cycle continues.
- village-idiot 8y ago> Plus, the next Facebook is not going to look like Facebook or whatever that maxim was. Everyone fights the last war.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rdlecler1 8y agoThe article didn’t mention the spin out of G2VP which was surprising.
- droplet123 8y agoIs that the cleantech fund? How do you think they will do now?
- United857 8y agoAs usual, the headline is rather sensational. Kleiner is like a Microsoft or Oracle of VC. They're not the latest or sexiest, but they've hardly "fallen" -- still one of the biggest funds out there in $ terms and will still be around for a long time to come. Disclosure: previously worked at a Kleiner-backed startup, but have no stake in it anymore.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]