6 ms·
No, this is not "just" a merger! Prior to this latest crap, the databases were separate, including separate access controls, on a "need to know" basis. Now a s
by mschuster91 8y ago
No, this is not "just" a merger! Prior to this latest crap, the databases were separate, including separate access controls, on a "need to know" basis.
Now a shitload of agencies and their agents across the EU, including in untrustworthy countries like Poland, Hungary and Austria, can access all the sensitive data in one place.
This is NOT good.
- TomMarius 8y agoWhy did you select these particular countries, especially Austria, as an example?
- mschuster91 8y agoSimple: Poland and Hungary are under multiple investigations for turning their systems to "illiberal democracies". Austria is on the list because their right-wing party FPÖ is in control of the security agencies (both police and secret service and military), which has led other EU countries to restrict information exchange with their secret services (https://www.handelsblatt.com/politik/international/spionage-wie-rechtspopulisten-die-geheimdienstkooperation-in-europa-gefaehrden/24207944.html?ticket=ST-5501081-txd1cJHQdEjFYYUdbtRe-ap5 https://www.handelsblatt.com/politik/international/spionage-...). For what it's worth I'd also put Italy on the list, with the open fascist Salvini as Interior Minister they're also not a stellar light of democracy any more.
- raxxorrax 8y agoI feel the need to defend "illiberal democracies" once again: They didn't implement this shit. They would certainly like to, but they are not the problem. The current problem is the EU as an institution that implements policies based on fear. Not some fringe parties with limited success... You just don't point the finger on someone incontinent while your pants are soaked. Totally not classy.
- sgift 8y ago> They didn't implement this shit. Without the EU council - the assembly of the countries - saying yes there's no new law in the EU. Therefore, saying they didn't implement this shit is wrong. If they didn't want to, they could have stopped it. They also still can stop it if they want to. The vote of the parliament is not the last step. The council has to agree. http://www.europarl.europa.eu/about-parliament/en/powers-and-procedures/legislative-powers http://www.europarl.europa.eu/about-parliament/en/powers-and... Apart from that most of the legislation that the commission initiates is done because the EU council asked the commission for it. So, the countries asked for this in the first place.
- raxxorrax 8y agoSure, and those other governments just fell on the wrong button. Complete distortion of the current political landscape. edit: ... and legislative process.
- peteretep 8y agoSolid explanation, and even if I feel that including Austria on the list feels a bit OTT, you've linked to a credible news-source showing that it's a valid concern among intelligence agencies. Shame on anyone downloading your comment.
- LoSboccacc 8y agoyour superiority compelx is showing let me guess: German?
- petre 8y agoAustria has a draft law that would require real names for online comments. The right wingers (FPÖ) lost the election but the centre right (ÖVP) pretty much borrowed from their program. And they'd be stupid not to, because they nearly lost the first time, before the right wingers asked to repeat the elections.
- jstanley 8y agoNot to mention untrustworthy countries like the UK, Germany, and France.
- mschuster91 8y agoAt least these three countries do not have right-wing extremists and authoritarians in government. I admit that we're not perfect, 13% support for right-wingers is 13% too much and our secret services are also plagued with scandals at the moment, but still: not remotely comparable with what is going on in HU/AT/IT/PL.
- kacamak 8y ago>At least these three countries do not have right-wing extremists and authoritarians in government. No, they have jihadists and an authoritarian government.
- raxxorrax 8y agoIt is plain stupid and negligent to give biometrical data to the German government. Your argument about the prevalence of bad guys in parliament is devoid of any reasonable conclusion in either direction. And certainly not sufficient for a general case for laws of this kind, as it lacks even a minimal justification for implementing surveillance on this scale. But you obviously don't see right-wing parties as a threat, since they would get access to that data too. Although I would admit that they probably wouldn't accomplish anything that a Seehofer could do as well.
- ben_w 8y ago> It is plain stupid and negligent to give biometrical data to the German government. Really? Germany requires all citizens to have a biometric ID card. The ID cards were introduced separately in East and West Germany decades before reunification. What makes you think this is “stupid and negligent” when it’s been around for so long? I’d expect any social/political/legal bugs to have been solved by now.