3 ms·
I've often wondered why it is the school's brand that matters. That seems to be all signaling, as in "look I got into Harvard". Of course when you get there it'
by lordnacho 8y ago
I've often wondered why it is the school's brand that matters. That seems to be all signaling, as in "look I got into Harvard". Of course when you get there it's not like they teach you secret math that nobody else knows about.
What could be done relatively cheaply is to make an examination org. You recruit a bunch of people to make a math test. You get a bunch of people to certify that it's hard. You publish a syllabus.
Then you examine people who sign up for it, and give them a diploma if they pass.
No need to live somewhere for 4 years. No need to study things you don't like. Prodigies will pass the test at 16 and get on with their lives. People who've had a life beforehand can do it in their own time after the kids are gone.
There will have to be some marketing done to convince people these tests aren't easy and can't be gamed. But everyone will benefit once believable and cheap certification is common.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sokoloff 8y agoCollege attendance is not about learning specific topics in order to pass an exam, IMO. It's about learning to think critically, work in project teams, evaluate superfluous and incomplete data, learning how to learn, learning time and priority management, interpersonal relationships, etc. I went to MIT. Most of what I value (personally and economically) that I learned at MIT could not be readily "tested" in a straightforward certification exam.
- lordnacho 8y ago> College attendance is not about learning specific topics in order to pass an exam, IMO. It's about learning to think critically, work in project teams, evaluate superfluous and incomplete data, learning how to learn, learning time and priority management, interpersonal relationships, etc. My take on that is that by having a bunch of different exam passes, that is what you demonstrate. You're not going to pass a bunch of math and physics or whatever classes without having at least some degree of personal organisation and commitment. And you'll certainly learn overarching things like critical thinking by learning a bunch of different topics. I went to Oxford, where you ostensibly learn by sitting in tiny little classes of 1 or 2 kids with a prof three times a week. You discuss the topic at hand and they evaluate whether you understood anything. They'll probe whether you understood things properly or just recited what you read. And you get to ask the prof whatever you want. But at the end of it all, everything simply depended on taking a bunch of sit-for-three-hours exams.
- sokoloff 8y agoGraduating may have depended on sitting for those exams, but did all of your learning depend only (or even primarily) on those exams? I'll bet you learned more from the years you spent outside the classroom interacting with your fellow students in the residences, dining halls, student activities, etc.
- lordnacho 8y agoDepends on what you mean by learning. I don't think I learned anything about thermodynamics, control theory, or algorithms anywhere other than while reading and doing exercises. Even the tutorials are of limited use for that, mainly providing a shortcut to the answer when needed. The larger learning of "how do you you get stuff done in your life, what kind of stuff do you want to do?" is one of those things you get once you look back. It's actually hard to do while cramming for exams. I really do think a lot of exam prep is a waste of time, but then we're looking for a replacement for a 4-year degree costing $250K or something like that. Surely if you just do the exams at a cost of $1K you can find communities of like minded people for a lot less than what remains?
- sokoloff 8y ago> [surely] you can find communities of like minded people for a lot less than what remains? I'm not so sure. The amount of free time available to discuss the topics of life with other like-minded people who also have that same amount of free time I have not been able to replicate (nor come close to) since graduating.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoIf I understand correctly, Western Governors University does this now.