5 ms·
I think the real problem is that people keep throwing around the word "average" which is insufficient to explain the data. To properly understand what's going o
by chongli 8y ago
I think the real problem is that people keep throwing around the word "average" which is insufficient to explain the data. To properly understand what's going on, you need to know both the mean and the standard deviation (the central limit theorem helps with the distribution).
Men and women can have an identical mean across a large number of traits but if the standard deviation is not the same then we can expect large differences at the extremes. This is in fact what we see. Boys' and girls' mathematics scores are pretty much identical at the mean but boys have a slightly higher standard deviation. Boys are thus overrepresented in the 1st and 99th percentiles of mathematical ability.
I think the other problem is that we as society only want to look up, never down. Many feminists demand that we equalize the representation of the sexes in all of the high-paying, intellectual fields (engineering, management, finance) but never in the dirtiest, most dangerous, outdoor fields (mining, logging, fishing, trash collecting) where men are similarly overrepresented.
- ska 8y agoI’m sure you can find examples of nearly anything, but that last part really isn’t an accurate portrayal of what many/most feminists are saying. Their claim is more that a) women have unequal access/opportunity in high status jobs, and b) that lower status jobs are gendered in a way that systematic rewards women less... contra your claim, feminist thinkers as a whole spend a lot of time focusing on looking around/down, to use your metaphor. Regardless of the accuracy - and I definitely have questions about some of the thinking that comes out of that that space - I think it's important to address the arguments people are actually making, rather than others characterizations of those arguments.
- SkyBelow 8y agoSomething to consider is that when you look down, the bottom is not low status jobs. It is living on the streets, prisons, and mental institutions (prisons have largely supplanted these, at least in the US).
- ska 8y agoI don’t see how that was excluded from what I said, can you elaborate ?
- lliamander 8y agoThe idea that our social institutions systematically favor/reward men over women seems to be contradicted by the fact that men are also disproportionately represented at the absolute bottom of the social hierarchy. It does not necessarily disprove the hypothesis of systematic sexism, but it is an observation which requires explanation. Update: fixed wording.
- ska 8y agoOh, gotcha - that is one of those things that seems superficially contradictory but isn't. But it does need discussion. I'm no expert on feminism but most of what I've heard [people who've though a lot more about this than I have] say/write on the subject acknowledges this as one (of many) aspects in which our society treats people unequally in gendered ways. Perhaps unsatisfying, but they also tend to view it as not their principal priority to fix; which I guess is fair. For completeness, I would add the "welfare trap" to SkyBelows list, which then pulls in a lot of women. The "bottom" here is not a very comfortable place to look, and involves a sad stories from many different directions. I think one of the ways it reflects in a gendered way is that for men at the lower margins we (i.e. "society") are more likely to say 'you are on your own, deal with it yourself' and for women more likely to say 'we know better, here is what you are going to do'.
- lliamander 8y ago> I'm not nobodies expert on feminism but most of what I've heard [people who've though a lot more about this than I have] say/write on the subject acknowledges this as one (of many) aspects in which our society treats people unequally in gendered ways. I recognize that you are in some sense just the messenger here, but I will just point out that this response appears to use a form of equivocation. Saying that society merely treats people (of both sexes) unequally in gendered ways is not the same as saying that society favors men over women. This kind of equivocation is what is called a Motte and Bailey[0]. > Perhaps unsatisfying, but they also tend to view it as not their principal priority to fix; which I guess is fair. Aside from the logical error, I don't mind that they their priority isn't helping disenfranchised men. Indeed, an important requirement to effectively helping people is to keep your scope narrow. > For completeness, I would add the "welfare trap" to SkyBelows list, which then pulls in a lot of women. Totally fair. > The "bottom" here is not a very comfortable place to look, and involves a sad stories from many different directions. True. [0]https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Motte_and_bailey https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Motte_and_bailey