6 ms·
>> No one seems to have a problem accepting that, on average, male and female bodies differ in many, many ways. Why is it surprising or unacceptable that this i
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
>> No one seems to have a problem accepting that, on average, male and female
bodies differ in many, many ways. Why is it surprising or unacceptable that
this is true for the part of our body that we call “brain”?
Because the differences between male and female "bodies", meaning anatomical
differences like sex characteristics, are obvious and self-evident, while
differences in brain structure are not and therefore require careful study.
Further, because there are well-known and deeply entrenched cultural biases
that risk derailing this careful study and therefore any initial assumptions
that coincide with these cultural biases must be eliminated before serious
work can begin.
Finally, because any result that just so happens, completely by chance, and
despite the scientists' best effort, to agree with preconceived notions about
"how things are" should be considered extremely suspicious and scrutinised
again, and again, and again, and again, and noone who really wants to
understand the relevant subjects should feel comfortable accepting such
results as settled, much less defend them as "scientific orthodoxy".
In other words, because "bias" is as much a problem in science as it is in
society, and because in the science of sex differences it is doubly so.
- tynpeddler 8y agoAnd just to show how complicated science in general is, your thinking is another example of bias. Requiring a higher burden of proof for findings that someone might be uncomfortable with is bad science. The burden of proof must be equally high for everyone. The real problem here isn't the science, is the pseudo-science and the journalism. It's pretty common for people to take single studies out of context and act as if their cherry picked study is the final word. Science journalists are supposed to bridge the gap between experts and laymen, but there seems to be very few good science journalists, and there seems to be lots of hacks and conmen.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> Requiring a higher burden of proof for findings that someone might be uncomfortable with is bad science. That is not my comment. My comment claims that cultural bias can influence the result of scientific studies and we must be vigilant not to let this happen. Do you disagree?
- justwalt 8y agoDidn’t you say that one result as opposed to the other should be considered extremely suspicious and looked at again multiple times? Should the opposite result also be viewed this way?
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoI said that, yes. I didn't say anything about results that make people uncomfortable. Can you explain why you brought up the subject? >> Should the opposite result also be viewed this way? Does the opposite result coincide with a commonly held preconception?
- threwawasy1228 8y agoI think what they are arguing is that, YOU are feeling uncomfortable with one of the results, and thus are biased toward exploring it more than the other which validates your views. You here are showing that bias again by saying that because the opposite coincides with commonly held preconceptions, it should be taken without as much scrutiny. If this isn't what you meant I apologize but that sure seems to be what you are saying.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoIt's very unpleasant to take part in an online conversation only for people to try to psychoanalyse you and discern hidden motives in your comments. My comment says what I meant to say. What it doesn't say, I didn't mean to say on the subject. Responses to what I didn't say are none of my business and I won't bother with them any more.
- ThrowawayR2 8y ago> Does the opposite result coincide with a commonly held preconception? The only reasonable answer is "It doesn't matter." As long as the result is reproducible, coinciding with commonly held preconceptions or not is of no relevance whatsoever. All results need to be equally validated for reproducibility.
- SolaceQuantum 8y ago"Requiring a higher burden of proof for findings that someone might be uncomfortable with is bad science. The burden of proof must be equally high for everyone." If the burden of proof is set at the level in which a statement can be made such that there is evidence that cannot be explained by other phenomena then both of you can be correct. (TBH I don't agree that one level of skepticism should be warranted for all things. If someone claimed P=NP my expectations are significantly higher than if someone claimed that HN commentors primarily comment in English.)
- kbenson 8y agoI agree that some things would require more evidence, but it's problematic when that is applied simply because they results are inconvenient in one way or another, and when it keeps being applied so the results never have to be acknowledged. Look at climate change. People are far to willing to discount information that is at odds with their preconception of the world. To differing degrees, this is a problem on both sides.
- SolaceQuantum 8y ago"... it's problematic when that is applied simply because they results are inconvenient in one way or another..." IMO the problem is that it's not 'simply' because the results are inconvenient in one way or another. That seems like a rather handwavy or dismissing cognitive understanding of what the person is saying. In their perception it is because a given conclusion has a known and studied bias- this isn't particularly simple, nor is it about inconvenience. It is that the evidence provided may have caveats that have also been studied that would skew the evidence to be explained by other factors. This is similar to the claim about the convtroversies behind global warming or antivax, except the amount of evidence is overwhelming such that the scientific consensus of possible skew is extremely low. I don't know (and have not heavily researched) if brain architecture and gender identity and human behavior (as a trifecta) have the same amount of evidence (I was under the impression that the technology to study the brain architecture is new enough that the research hasn't been wholly settled- if this is incorrect let me know).
- wtdata 8y agoThe all process you described there is called science. Stopping people from doing science just because of political ideology, is a very dangerous proposition.
- chongli 8y agoI think the real problem is that people keep throwing around the word "average" which is insufficient to explain the data. To properly understand what's going on, you need to know both the mean and the standard deviation (the central limit theorem helps with the distribution). Men and women can have an identical mean across a large number of traits but if the standard deviation is not the same then we can expect large differences at the extremes. This is in fact what we see. Boys' and girls' mathematics scores are pretty much identical at the mean but boys have a slightly higher standard deviation. Boys are thus overrepresented in the 1st and 99th percentiles of mathematical ability. I think the other problem is that we as society only want to look up, never down. Many feminists demand that we equalize the representation of the sexes in all of the high-paying, intellectual fields (engineering, management, finance) but never in the dirtiest, most dangerous, outdoor fields (mining, logging, fishing, trash collecting) where men are similarly overrepresented.
- ska 8y agoI’m sure you can find examples of nearly anything, but that last part really isn’t an accurate portrayal of what many/most feminists are saying. Their claim is more that a) women have unequal access/opportunity in high status jobs, and b) that lower status jobs are gendered in a way that systematic rewards women less... contra your claim, feminist thinkers as a whole spend a lot of time focusing on looking around/down, to use your metaphor. Regardless of the accuracy - and I definitely have questions about some of the thinking that comes out of that that space - I think it's important to address the arguments people are actually making, rather than others characterizations of those arguments.
- SkyBelow 8y agoSomething to consider is that when you look down, the bottom is not low status jobs. It is living on the streets, prisons, and mental institutions (prisons have largely supplanted these, at least in the US).
- ska 8y agoI don’t see how that was excluded from what I said, can you elaborate ?
- reallydude 8y ago> differences in brain structure are not They are different enough that investigators can distinguish the differences in skeletal remains, so I'm not sure that holds.
- BurningFrog 8y ago> Because the differences between male and female "bodies", meaning anatomical differences like sex characteristics, are obvious and self-evident, while differences in brain structure are not and therefore require careful study. That careful study has been done. The science is settled, and there to learn for anyone with an open mind.
- Niten 8y ago> Further, because there are well-known and deeply entrenched cultural biases that risk derailing this careful study and therefore any initial assumptions that coincide with these cultural biases must be eliminated before serious work can begin. I somewhat agree with this statement. But judging by the ink spilled over sex differences in places like the New York Times, and by the views on the subject that one is allowed to hold in the polite company of higher education and industry, and by the intensity of the backlash when one publicly deviates from those views: I suspect the "deeply entrenched biases" most significant for present-day researchers lean quite opposite from what you assume.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- JudgeWapner 8y ago> "bias" is as much a problem in science what burden of proof was required to come to this conclusion and why is that burden so much lower than the one required to conclude there are gender differences in human brains? Liberal universities are some of the most politically-correct, left-leaning bastions in the world. Members are imediately called to resign if they dare state anything against the progressive groupthink [1]. Yet you state as if it were well-established fact that "bias is a problem". this is not even counting the programs, scholarships, and active recruiting for more women in science. I see 2 problems with accusations of "bias". For one, they're never levelled at an individual so the problem can be addressd at the source. It's always something nebulous, like "bias exists in science". So it's kind of like accusing all scientists of being sexist (or implicitly, male scientists, unless you want to clarify that women, too, are part of the problem), while at the same time accusing none of them. It's a tool that conditions its accused members to atone for something they didn't necessarily do, or if they did at one time, they're never forgiven. It makes everyone in the group feel guilty, regardless of whether they actually did something they should feel bad for. The second problem with bias is that there's no bar for it "being a problem" ? In otherwords, if "it" exists in even one person somewhere in academia, one time, is it a problem ? If so, how long of a period does there have to be without bias for it to no longer be a problem ? If, say, a CMU professor makes a sexist tweet, how long is there a "sexism problem" at CMU? Forever? Until he is fired? Until he apologizes? None of these terms is defined, because I suspect it's not a problem intended to be solved. It's a social manipulation tool. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/08/us/yale-lecturer-resigns-after-email-on-halloween-costumes.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/08/us/yale-lecturer-resigns-...
- imhelpingu 8y agoSometimes people have "bias" due to experience with reality, but definitely any result you dislike should be repeated again and again. It's obviously a big problem for science when reality is coherent.
- oarabbus_ 8y ago>Because the differences between male and female "bodies", meaning anatomical differences like sex characteristics, are obvious and self-evident, while differences in brain structure are not and therefore require careful study. That seems like a very odd, unscientific position to take. We know that men and women have different physical characteristics and hormonal affects (as an obvious example, women have a menstrual cycle while men do not). Ergo, the hypothalamus and pituitary gland (two areas of the brain which play pivotal roles in the human endocrine system) are structurally different between the sexes; this is obvious and self-evident.
- Viliam1234 8y agoLuckily, we all know that the soul is completely separated from the body, so no amount of difference in hormones or brains can have an impact on our thinking, feeling, or behavior, which are completely determined by the society. Also, differences between males and females in animals are completely irrelevant for humans, because humans have nothing in common with animals. Thus spoke the latest science (of 17th century, but who cares, science is still science).
- AlexTWithBeard 8y ago"Scrutinizing the result again and again and again" sounds like keeping asking the same question until you get the answer you want.
- frotak 8y agoThe irony of your closing statement ("any result that just so happens....to agree with preconceived notions about "how things are" should be considered extremely suspicious and scrutinised....and noone who really wants to understand the relevant subjects should feel comfortable accepting such results as settled") is that such "settled" facts in the scientific community are exactly the things that Cahill has been challenging in the neuroscience field. Specifically to his point that: > the rationale was there aren’t any differences between males and females, so you avoid the unnecessarily complicated feature of the female hormonal cycle and study the male. In other words...the "settled" science actually excludes the explicit study of, and furtherance of our understanding of, the female brain. Which in turn leads to a lessened ability to treat and address all sorts of conditions. So by all means decry bias...but be aware that bias can be introduced by scientists wanting to cut corners and make research faster and easier so they can publish more just as much as they can be introduced by gender superiority zealots.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoWell, Cahill has his opinions, Ripon has hers. Obviously there is a controversy on this issue, between experts on the matter, and I am not equipped to resolve it, or even to know who is representing some kind of consensus opinion. Basically, I know a couple of things about computers. I don't feel I have the knowledge to weigh in on any other scientific subjects. That said, I have to observe that if the matter was settled the way Cahill claims it is, Nature wouldn't be publishing dithyrambs for Ripon's book, and Cahill wouldn't be publishing his own article on Quillete. It would rather be the other way. It's Quillette that's know to court controversy and Nature that's know to be as controversial as a pot of instant noodles.
- lliamander 8y ago> Because the differences between male and female "bodies", meaning anatomical differences like sex characteristics, are obvious and self-evident, while differences in brain structure are not and therefore require careful study. The categorical denial of neurological sex differences of the sort that was published by Nature does not encourage careful study. In fact, it does rather the opposite by turning the subject into a political football. This distracts from the more important issue that arguably women have been under-served by the medical community precisely due to the denial of such differences.
- belorn 8y agoPeople see explicit bias in society and conclude that any time they see a difference between gender it must be because of implicit bias. This is what practically all discussion is centered around. One camp defaulting to bias, the other camp disagreeing. Bias is a terrible default as it require the other camp to prove a negative.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- esarbe 8y agoI think for anyone who has worked with children it is obvious and self-evident that girl's and boy's brains work differently.