4 ms·
>Some cultures wouldn't recognize some things as a disorder if it wasn't difficult for those people. There are a few mental disorders like that, but it's impor
by whatshisface 8y ago
>Some cultures wouldn't recognize some things as a disorder if it wasn't difficult for those people.
There are a few mental disorders like that, but it's important to bear in mind that most of them (major depression, mid to low functioning autism, anxiety, schizophrenia, and so on) lead to objectively reduced functioning independent of society and a lot of suffering in whoever has them. It's not something to be romanticized.
- izzydata 8y agoWould you happen to know if there is some classification difference between a mental disorder that may involve some kind of chemical imbalance and a personality disorder which would be more like having a personality that makes daily life difficult? I feel like they get lumped together, but maybe I'm just ignorant about how these terms are used.
- whatshisface 8y agoHere is a link describing the categories. They are divided up into AMI (any mental illness) and SMI (serious mental illness). Illnesses categorized in AMI may even involve no impariment, those are probably what people are referring to when they talk about fresh air and a walk being the best medicine. https://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/statistics/mental-illness.shtml https://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/statistics/mental-illness.sh...
- DanBC 8y ago> that may involve some kind of chemical imbalance This mostly doesn't exist. > a personality disorder which would be more like having a personality that makes daily life difficult? Go careful with that. People with the dx have usually been harmed by early childhood abuse (although there's some difference between UK and US diagnosing) and many people with the dx feel it's an entirely unhelpful construct.
- 50656E6973 8y agoThe "chemical imbalance" theory is a Big Pharma marketing slogan, not a real scientific fact.
- coldtea 8y agoThere's no "chemical imbalance" per se. People can and do have "serious mental issue" with no specific chemical markers to tell... It's mostly a marketing slogan for drugs, and a gross over-simplification.
- Nasrudith 8y agoThere is also the converse - what is accepted as "normal" or even praised as a virtue is harmful and destructive. To give real examples smoking was normal, as was pedestray and ironically the Roman gladiatoral combat which is considered peak decadence was intended to combat decadence! Normal is a pretty shitty heuristic for being good.
- admax88q 8y ago> Normal is a pretty shitty heuristic for being good. A few counter examples doesn't mean that the heuristic is bad. Heuristics will always have counter examples, that's why they're heuristics, not rules.
- 50656E6973 8y agoHow many counter examples do you need before determining if a heuristic is bad, in your opinion?
- SirLuxuryYacht 8y agoIMO, probably when the counterexamples outnumber the examples by which the heuristic is defined.
- coldtea 8y agoAnd maybe even not then: the negatives from the counterexamples should also outweigh the positives from the heuristic. If a heuristic has 100 majorly good applications, and 1000s of counter-examples of minor or no real consequence, it will still be good to use...
- shkkmo 8y agoI would argue that inherent discrimination against minority traits is what makes that heuristic bad. Given a single counter example, the burden of proof should be on the users of the heuristic to show why the use of that heuristic is an improvement over the alternatives (which have no counter examples).
- LifeLiverTransp 8y agoAlmost like biological determined scoutships for a group, arent they? Imagine a bunch of hunte/gatherers, who just entered a new continent (like north-america)- having those loonies orbiting the group, reporting new ressources, scouting ahead- sounds well adapted.
- chubot 8y agoYeah I agree with this. I thought I read that scientists claim there's no such thing as "group selection" in evolution, i.e. where one individual in a group will do something bad for himself but good for the group (reproductively speaking). Yeah it looks like wikipedia has a page on this controversy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Group_selection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Group_selection Richard Dawkins apparently doesn't believe in it, and neither does Steven Pinker. But just based on casual observation I think group selection is real (yes I know that's not scientific). Humans are like ants in many ways... some of us are "programmed" to perform specific roles.
- koverstreet 8y agoIf group selection wasn't a thing, multicellular organisms wouldn't exist.
- jadyoyster 8y agoDon't ants in a colony all share the same genes and have the queen do all reproducing? (From the sperm of a single male possibly? I'm not super familiar.)
- chubot 8y agoYeah I'm not sure. I think ants are an extreme case, but I do think groups of humans have similar sorts of "mechanisms". The book Sapiens repeats this over and over and I tend to agree. Religion, government, corporations, etc. are ways in which we cooperate with thousands or millions of others. We don't have to have the exact same genome, and it's not perfect cooperation, but there's something there.
- 8y ago