4 ms·
The courage to stand up against your own ingroup is the highest form of courage and morals. It requires independence of thought and high principles.
by nabla9 8y ago
The courage to stand up against your own ingroup is the highest form of courage and morals.
It requires independence of thought and high principles.
- ppod 8y agoI agree with independence of thought, courage, and high principles, but is it moral? An militant anti-semite in present-day Germany is might be just as independent, principled, and courageous.
- yifanl 8y ago(In some views) morals are relative and personal, not absolute.
- staticautomatic 8y agoThey don't have to be objective or subjective. I've never understood the argument that morals are individually subjective. If individual people freely did anything all the time then where would morals come from?
- fit2rule 8y agoMorals are for the individual, ethics is for the group. The level and state of each realm, defines the state of the other.
- staticautomatic 8y agoEven if that's true, which I'm not sure it is, it doesn't necessarily mean that morals emerge from individual choice. Personally I think morals are emergent from groups.
- fit2rule 8y agoMorals are an individual personal choice - derived from the word 'morales', which means 'custom'. Individuals adopt customs - both learned individually, and mores adopted from a group. Ethics are a group choice - a set of morals, in the plural, derived from "ethike" - the 'science of morals'. They're interlocked, sure, but it is an individual who makes a moral decision for themselves, but an ethical decision for their group... EDIT: I mean, all you have to do is look at the definition of both words in a few dictionaries. Its pretty clearly stated that ethics are a group of morals formulated around the purposes of a group, where morals are derived from and based on an individual decision. Can't have one without the other. Of course, you are within your rights to disagree - such is the nature of the ethics of philosophical discussions.
- staticautomatic 8y agoYou've obviously defined it that way but I don't see why it's true. Your argument is essentially that morals emerge from individuals because of the etymology of the world moral. I don't find that very convincing.
- FabHK 8y agoNot sure that's an accepted definition. Others consider ethics the study of morality.
- yifanl 8y agoI don't agree with the relativistic point of view either, but it's a common enough viewpoint that I can forgive the GP's casual usage of the term :)
- joe_the_user 8y ago(In some views) morals are relative and personal, not absolute. But that too is a moral view, is it not? It may be "meta-relative" to other moral views but doesn't keep it from being statement of values.
- yifanl 8y agoThat's a good counterpoint to relativism, and that's why I accept moral realism, relative morals are self-contradicting (or you can accept that everything is morally right and wrong simultaneously, which is bordering on nihilism)
- srean 8y agoThe other one is to acknowledge and believe deeply that your acts were wrong. I cannot think of another country that breathes these values so sincerely and profoundly. I am sure everyone knows that Germany is in no way unique in its killing of millions. I have no German ties whatsoever but I am in deep admiration of their capacity to accept, correct and be vigilant of repetition. I know neo-nazism exists. I hope it continues to be an aberration.
- fit2rule 8y agoI moved to Germany from America precisely because of Germans' lack of hubris about their ability to take responsibility for the crimes of their nations' past - while America is, without doubt, not ready to confront its own heinous crimes, being committed in present time, as yet. Neo-nazism doesn't scare me as much as the average American patriot, whose political cover allows many, many crimes to be committed in their name with, seemingly, no repercussion. However, as a believer in karma, participating in such a society is not on - thus, I moved. My only concern now is that the Germany of the future will have what it needs to address America - because it doesn't look like Americans are going to be roping in their criminal death cult any time soon ... and all signs point to an America, in the future, which will have to deal with the crimes being committed in its name, today.
- imrelaxed 8y agoWhen making serious accusations be sure to detail them in order to expose your inner logic to the scrutiny of others, else you’re just another idiot making unfounded claims on the internet.
- mixmastamyk 8y agoThe subject is well known to those who are interested.
- hn23 8y agoLike Snowden...