5 ms·
"The initial tests completed successfully but the final test resulted in an anomaly on the test stand." I'm not saying this is spin, but it sounds like how you
by Waterluvian 8y ago
"The initial tests completed successfully but the final test resulted in an anomaly on the test stand."
I'm not saying this is spin, but it sounds like how you'd spin something like this. Basically, the tests worked until they didn't. And that one therefore became the final test.
- craftyguy 8y agoIt could also be that the last test they planned to execute resulted in the 'anomaly'.. Not every public communication is subterfuge even though the armchair detectives in the HN comment section always seems to think it is.
- colechristensen 8y ago"Anomaly" implies this is not the case.
- craftyguy 8y agoNo, anomaly means there was an outcome which was not expected. It says nothing about how many tests they were going to execute (if any), what the unexpected outcome was, or what the lead test engineer ate for breakfast that morning.
- usrusr 8y agoThat's the dictionary definition of "anomaly". But that's not the interesting part, what's tickling us armchair detectives is how it got into the press release: "anomaly" is a bit of an anomaly itself, most people would never use that term unless specifically to play something down. That surely is no proof, enough to inspire speculation.
- xattt 8y agoSpeaking of speculation, there could be quite a few speculators in this thread that are invested in SpaceX. The downplaying of the actual event could be their own way to shape the stock price.
- camjohnson26 8y agoIsn’t SpaceX private?
- bparsons 8y agoIt is not a publicly traded stock.
- angstrom 8y agoRight. It means exactly what it means. Actual test did not match expectation. Thus, there is an anomaly. Sometimes that means "boom" and sometimes that means bad sensor and sometimes it means the result was outside the margin and they need to do a thorough analysis before retest.
- arcticfox 8y agoIt sounds like a good thing: 'we passed so many tests successfully!' But it also sounds like kind of a bad thing that it's the last test: 'holy cow - that was close - thank god we had the last test in there.' Without knowing the specifics of what they were testing every time that might be irrelevant, but if it was multiple test fires of the same engine and only the last one caught the problem, that's scary.
- colechristensen 8y agoIt is how you talk about failure when it is another part of your engineering characteristics and not something that causes fear or shame. Another reminder is why you run tests. They don't scare away failure by existing, they are there to catch failure, doing their jobs exactly as intended. It will probably result in a delay of any human spaceflight by SpaceX until the source of the source of the problem is removed. (not the particular issue that caused the anomaly but the systematic issue which didn't find it before it happened on the pad)
- Dylan16807 8y ago> It is how you talk about failure when it is another part of your engineering characteristics and not something that causes fear or shame. That depends on whether this was supposed to be the final test. If it's a post-hoc "final", then that's an obfuscation done out of shame. If it was always supposed to be the final test, then the statement is fine.
- HeyLaughingBoy 8y agoIt really doesn't matter if it's the final test or not. Your QA (or dev, or whatever) group has a number of test cases to verify. They verify the ones that they can, and record failures against the ones that they couldn't not. Sometimes in hardware testing, a failed test results in destruction of the hardware and/or peripheral damage to the test environment. BTDT.
- Dylan16807 8y agoI'd expect riskier tests to go later, so the implications are worse the earlier in the sequence it breaks.
- HeyLaughingBoy 8y agoIME, riskier tests are run later, because you want as much test feedback as possible so the tests that aren't likely to break something are run first. However, you can't really draw any conclusions from that unless you know what the test plan was.
- anigbrowl 8y ago'Anomaly' is a polite way to say 'failure', no matter how fine the semantic wrapper. Failures are to be expected and OK and it's good that they happen during testing rather than operation, but there's no value in euphemism here.
- sargun 8y agoPerhaps I’m wrong, but referring to issues in such non specific terms is not useful. It’s very similar to a cloud provider saying “increased error rates” meaning total outage or 0.001% of users experiencing off-nominal behavior. Is there nomenclature that’s better?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- xattt 8y agoOne refers to the event as a statistic, the other captures the immediate aftermath and potential for danger relating to the event.
- jrockway 8y ago> Is there nomenclature that’s better? I prefer "rapid unplanned disassembly".
- rbanffy 8y agoIt seems nothing was disassembled here.
- azeotropic 8y agoYou must not have seen the video. Something turned the capsule into aluminum dust.
- rbanffy 8y agoThe orange cloud suggests the hydrazine was not released. I would expect a different color of the capsule was blown to pieces. What video are you referring to?
- tzs 8y agoIf they have a series of tests to perform, I'd expect them to order the tests so that the ones with the highest chances of anomalies that will make them abort testing come later in the series. It doesn't seem all that unreasonable given that for them to really have the spectacular failure occur on the last scheduled test of the series.
- iClaudiusX 8y agoThe use of such a vague and overloaded term as "anomaly" is deceptive. The purpose of communication is to inform the audience, and rather than clarify what happened, this statement obscures the truth to the public. The test capsule exploded. It means both SpaceX and Boeing have had test failures in the launch abort system for their respective human launch capsules. It will set back the timeline for the US to regain the ability to launch humans into space without paying for seats on the Soyuz. Instead of discussing the event and its implications, the longest thread is now dedicated to excessive pedantry and incorrecting each other over textbook definitions of the word "anomaly".
- Klathmon 8y agoIt's a vague term because they don't know what exactly happened yet and anomaly is a technical term that those in the industry know. Explosion has a technical meaning too, and many things that look like an explosion aren't. AMOS-6 for instance was not an explosion, even though it really looked like one to a bystander. This isn't excessive pedantry, it's jargon meant for an audience that will understand it and not take more away from a statement than they intend to say. Better to use the word that means "something bad happened" rather than a word which means something specific only to have to follow that up with "sorry, we were wrong, it wasn't that, it was..."