8 ms·
With Domain Name Seizures Increasing, It's Time For A Decentralized DNS System
- Mithrandir 16y agohttp://dot-p2p.org http://dot-p2p.org
- haberman 16y ago"We currently believe the best way to create a stable environment for TLDs is to enact a central authority. We know this will cause much argument within the community, but we have made the decision that we believe will be best for the continued development of this project." That is the answer to the question I was going to ask, namely "what does decentralized DNS even mean?" People throw around the word "decentralized" as a presumed solution to centralized control, but at the end of the day someone has to decide who wins if two different people both claim that microsoft.com points to their server. Also, "visit mybiz.yo after adding altdns.com as a DNS authority" doesn't exactly have the same ring to it as "visit mybiz.com". It also doesn't fit on the side of a truck, nor is it something that you will ever convince 99.9% of the population to do just to visit a website.
- jamii 16y agoCurrently the best non-centralized solution proposed on the mailing list is to flood domain subscriptions and cache them at each node, so whoever claims a domain first will own it. This is pretty vulnerable to a variety of attacks but it does give a rough idea how a p2p dns system would work. I suspect that if this goes anywhere it will end up much like tor, being used as a censorship circumvention tool rather being installed everywhere by the general public.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- mike-cardwell 16y agoI envisage a system where a few dozen independent organisations around the World run the root. They all have the same data. If any of them modify their local copy of the data or try to poison the distributed data, their trusted status is revoked. Child DNS resolvers should be able to detect new trusted organisations and remove untrusted organisations quickly. This could all be handled through public key encryption and automatic voting. DNSSEC or similar should be complete and enforced for all zones and lookups. You would need to compromise over half of the trusted organisations running the root in order to break this system.
- mike-cardwell 16y agoThere could even be a constitution and perhaps some sort of contractual obligation to not modify the data with agreed legal consequences...?
- rmc 16y agoI envisage a system where a few dozen independent organisations around the World run the root. They all have the same data. If any of them modify their local copy of the data or try to poison the distributed data, their trusted status is revoked. So what happens if someone attacks/compromises more than half of these trusted nodes at once with bad data? Is the bad data then the good data
- mike-cardwell 16y agoYes... Of course... But if something like that did happen, the organisations would be able to roll back the data as long as more than half of them agreed. If public key cryptography were used, then you could make it so that only change requests signed with the domain owners private key are accepted and distributed too.
- mike-cardwell 16y agoIf there are 35 trusted organisations and governments around the World colluded to take over the network by taking over 18 of these organisations and getting them to "untrust" the other 17, then this would splinter the network, and people around the World would need to manually repoint their resolvers at the other group of 17. This system relies on the fact that it is difficult to take down lots of independent organisations that are spread around the World at the same time easily.
- corin_ 16y agoHere's my problem. It's great that some censorship will be prevented, but what about stuff like child pornography. I'm worried that, if successful, this will turn into a "we don't like our government so let's go create our own country where there are no laws", without thinking about the laws that we actually do want enforced...
- jrockway 16y agowhat about stuff like child pornography What about people that make their own kids (I hear humans can do that) and then abuse them? Clearly we should have video cameras in every room to ensure that this doesn't happen. What if someone, right now, is doing something I don't approve of!? Something must me done!
- corin_ 16y agoBased on that logic we should leave any child porn that's available online up there to avoid governments over-reaching into our privacy?
- jrockway 16y agoYes, exactly. Censorship is censorship. Child porn is illegal because its creation damages the child. Its continued distribution is not the primary problem, the fact that it was created in the first place is. So the solution to child porn is to find it, use good-old-fashioned police work to find who made it, and use the legal system to remove that person's access to children. No need to break the Internet and restrict free speech for this very-special case. Let's spend the money we want to spend on censoring the Internet on more detectives, so that child abuse can be eliminated! The same goes for "counterfeit goods" or whatever the DHS used as rationale for seizing domain names. Don't break the Internet; just buy one of the fake watches, ask UPS where it was shipped from, get a warrant, and bust the guys! Right? (I fear that in the US, though, the problem with child porn is not that children were abused, but that people like something in a sexual way. Consider the person who was mailed a box of comic books that depicted "under-age" children in a sexual context. The government wanted to put him in prison for 15 years. For receiving a box of books. "Sexting" is another example. It's doubtful that one can abuse one's self, but the government still wants to put people in prison for it. What I find most amusing is that all people look pretty much alike when naked. I don't understand why naked pictures are such a hot-button political issue. It seems like the government just doesn't really want any depictions of sex [children, adults, tentacles, or otherwise] around at all. But I digress.)
- andrewcooke 16y agoHere's a quick, dirty, temporary hack I threw together today. It's a script that manages entries in your hosts file (it can do things like merge, pull from web pages, etc). https://github.com/ghettonet/GhettoNet https://github.com/ghettonet/GhettoNet Feel free to fork and improve.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- andrewcooke 16y agoI just posted an update so that you can add and remove entries directly (instead of from a file). If anyone feels like testing it on something other than Linux any bug reports would be appreciated. But now I'm going to hit the sack...
- aw3c2 16y agoHow does the system like it if you actually have ~200 million entries in that file? Or make it just one million for a start.
- wazoox 16y agoI run dnsmasq (both a dns cache and a dns server) on all my machines. Works great.
- andrewcooke 16y agoSure, but sometimes worse is better - a small step in a pragmatic direction can do some good now and be a stepping stone to something better in the future.
- vog 16y agoThat still doesn't solve the core of the problem: How to ensure that the lists are trustworthy?
- andrewcooke 16y agoNo, it doesn't. But you're implying that a small step in the right direction is pointless because we have no idea how to engineer a complete solution. I don't agree - trust is a known, hard problem and the best solutions (think about ssh) are very pragmatic about it.
- wibblenut 16y agoKneejerkitis. 1) ICANN has nothing to do with ICE seizing domains. 2) wikileaks.org was NOT seized by ICE, in case you didn't know (their nameserver operator, everydns, terminated service due to alleged AUP breach). They should probably just run their own nameservers if it's too much for a free provider to handle. 3) DNS is hierarchical in structure, but very decentralised from a technical point of view. In fact, you might call it "P2P", since anybody can join the network and run their own resolver. 4) #dnsissexy - the average user doesn't even know it exists. 5) Not happy with something? ICANN is a community. (I'm not saying it's perfect - nothing is!). 6) Really really pissed about something? Free speech, courts, democracy. 7) Really pissed AND lazy? Use a ccTLD. I hear .ly is cool. What are people like Sunde proposing? The PR is sensationalist and contradictory, with talk of an alternative root (where would it be located? who would control it?), and a new bittorrent-like protocol (no idea how this could even work). Anyway, I'm standing up for the status quo. It works phenomenally well.
- jhaglund 16y ago4) #dnsissexy - the average user doesn't even know it exists. it's amazing how many people i see who use google as their primary resolver, by only using the search function even if they're entering a url.
- spinlocked 16y agoThe goal is to build a naming system that is decentralized and therefore free and hard to take down. > You might call DNS "P2P", since anybody can join the network and run their own resolver. Single point of attack. They shut down your custom resolver, and they shut down your custom naming system. Also this proposal fails in terms of availability and resilience. Also it's hierarchical P2P, so if you control the root servers, you control the naming system. It is decentralized only to aid availability and resilience. > the average user doesn't even know it exists. Those who do, understand that it can be controlled. > Not happy with something? ICANN is a community. I want free names for 10 websites. ICANN't get that without paying $7 * 10 per year. Some things are not worth lobbying for, because they are obviously not going to happen. > Really really pissed about something? Free speech, courts, democracy. Such a naming system would be outside the immediate control of governments, therefore democracy has nothing to do with it. Indeed, the idea is that you could use this in China and Chechnya too. > Use a ccTLD. I hear .ly is cool. This still uses DNS, and does not solve anything.
- jimmyjazz14 16y agoI'm not sure if a decentralized DNS system could ever be secure, instead the current management of the top level domain space should be taken out of the hands of ICANN and placed under the control of a internationally governed body.
- antimatter15 16y agoI'm still not sure how a decentralized DNS would handle registration, if domains were free-for-all, what's to prevent squatters from ruining everything. What if someone's domain is totally abandoned? Is there any way for someone else to take it? From what I understand from the dotp2p wiki, there's still going to be a registration party, OpenNIC (which is an existing alternative DNS root that runs .geek, .free, etc. I'm guessing it's a DHT but it would use some public key crypto so that each entry needs to be signed by OpenNIC. But this still leaves OpenNIC as a central point. It wouldn't be a point of failure, but it would prevent scaling if it was taken over.
- Kadin 16y agoI'm not sure what they're up to these days, but I remember when they got started (by some guys from K5, IIRC). It was an alternative root, and not any more decentralized in the technical sense than "regular" DNS. More responsive to users and democratic, but the structure was exactly the same. There were a bunch of other alternative roots that have taken on ICANN at one point or another, although it's been a long time since I've tried any of them. It strikes me as a doomed effort unless you can get some ISPs somewhere to buy in and point users towards your root rather than ICANN's. Most users aren't going to change their DNS settings (most probably don't know how), so it seems difficult to achieve any sort of critical mass of users.
- cosmicray 16y agoA decentralized DNS has nothing to do with solving the (presumed) problem. The solution is a registrar (and DNS) that is not answerable to any nation state. The corollary to this demands an answer: are nation states that afraid of information (and the truth that may lurk within) ?
- runjake 16y agoI can't wait for all the new logistical & security issues that come from a decentralized system. It will make the old DNS system seem like Fort Meade.
- swixmix 16y agoIt's time for IPV6.
- NHQ 16y agoI think another big problem with ICAAN and our DNS is the TLD. The fact that somebody who wants to represent their self on the internet might not be able to do so in a manner of their choosing because the domain they want is "owned" across all major and minor TLDs is very anti-internet-philosophy. Top-Level is anti-web, because the web is not meant to be a top-down system. To me, this is a fundamentally flawed implementation. And why not? In terms of mass web, it was the first. When are first iterations ever correct? Destinations are IP addresses. We all have em. What you want to call yours should be up to you. Ever since there was a postal service, people could be reached at the address they had. Even phone numbers weren't top-down (area codes), so that you could reach a local address, even it was the same as one in another county, without pre-(or post-) fix. I don't have the solution, but it wouldn't hurt for the public to learn and understand their IP address same as they do their home one. Google alone, or with the help of other major "linkers", could go a long way in changing our DNS structure, by indexing different systems. Decentralization is every nerd's dream, aint it? Eventually the serving capacity of consumer devices should be adequate to resolve standardized requests. I think this holds promise: telehash.org
- pak 16y agoIP address blocks are allocated by IANA, which is managed by, you guessed it, ICANN. Just sayin'. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_Assigned_Numbers_Authority#Oversight http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_Assigned_Numbers_Autho... It all is top-down at the core. (And it kind of has to be, because as much as we think of the Internet as "decentralized", it is a communication network, and so centralized administration is often the most efficient and sane way of doing things.)
- mike-cardwell 16y agoA distributed DNS platform wont stop censorship. Governments will just find a different method of censorship. Null routing IPs would cause collateral damage, but to block illegal content that the hosts refuse to take down? They might go ahead and do it anyway... I would still love to see a distributed DNS platform. The issue that needs resolving for a distributed platform is trust. We will always need a trusted authority. That could be split over 50 hosts over 50 countries, but we still need one.
- 16s 16y agoVerizon and AT&T will do what they are told as will other large ISPs, if they want to keep doing business as usual.
- watt 16y agoPlease do not propose technological solutions to political problem, one that needs political solution. Meaning, centralized DNS system will work just fine, we only need a law prohibiting government blocking or removing domain entries. That is, we need similar prohibition that limits government actions like first amendment.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- treitnauer 16y agoWhy the P2P DNS project will not work: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1972834 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1972834