4 ms·
> with an error that is so small that you can just ignore the uncertainty and approximate them as classical objects. I’d say that’s the gist of it, that we can
by paganel 8y ago
> with an error that is so small that you can just ignore the uncertainty and approximate them as classical objects.
I’d say that’s the gist of it, that we cannot “just ignore” the uncertainty because it’s too small, because if you do that then your model and the real world are indeed different. Also, at the end of it all what does “too small” mean? “Too small” compared to what? To a galaxy? To a super-nova? To a planet? To a cat? To the things we try to “discover” at CERN? To things smaller than them? To say nothing of the fact that comparing a number to physical stuff will eventually bring you head on against Zeno’s paradox, one way or the other.
I agree though that using the “too small” trick does generally allow us to do great things, like send stuff to the confines of the solar system or to build nuclear bombs, i.e. it allows us to be efficient, but that does not mean that by being efficient our models are also identical representations of what reality really is, so to speak.
What I’m saying is that maybe the “mathematization” of the physical world is a leaking abstraction, and that maybe we’d be better off by saying “we’ll never really know what the world is made up of”. But the problem is that they haven’t awarded science Nobel prizes to people saying “there’s really no way for us to learn how the Universe really works”, at least not that I know of, at best you’re seen as a mysticist when saying that, at worst as a know-nothing or a cynic.
- philipov 8y ago"Too small" means either it can not be detected experimentally, or even in principle, depending on whether you are allowing gedankenexperiments. I don't think it is reasonable to expect our models to be identical to reality. Otherwise, they wouldn't be models, they would be reality. A theory is correct if it produces experimentally verified predictions.
- throwawaymath 8y ago> To say nothing of the fact that comparing a number to physical stuff will eventually bring you head on against Zeno’s paradox, one way or the other. Zeno's paradoxes are soluble by basic calculus. Once you distinguish between countable and uncountable infinities, the problem of crossing a bounded interval in finite time ceases to be paradoxical. This is basically to say I don't think this is a particular problem for the resolution of outstanding inconsistencies in theoretical physics.
- foldr 8y ago>Zeno's paradoxes are soluble by basic calculus. Once you distinguish between countable and uncountable infinities, the problem of crossing a bounded interval in finite time ceases to be paradoxical. They're not mathematically paradoxical, but that doesn't necessarily mean that the paradoxes are solved, because there's more than just math going on. A lot of the paradoxes hinge on the question of whether it is in fact possible to traverse an infinite series of positions in space or moments in time. I have no idea whether it is or it isn't, but the issue isn't settled by calculus. Calculus allows you to figure out what the result would be if such a traversal were to occur.
- throwawaymath 8y agoNo, calculus does in fact resolve them. More specifically, formalizing continuity and completeness obviates the issue. Like I said, if you distinguish between countable and uncountable infinities, there is no longer a paradox. The only reason it appears to be paradoxical is because you're mandating someone move from a real coordinate (a, b, c) to another real coordinate (a', b', c') on the interval [x, y] while also passing through the set of all real points between them, without first defining a notion of distance of time. That's not possible for the same reason you can't ask someone to count all reals on an interval, because continuity implies uncountability. Between any pair of real numbers is another real number, and it takes an equal amount of effort (and time) to count any given number. To a first glance, this seems like a paradox because we can clearly move from (a, b, c) to (a', b', c), yet we shouldn't be capable of any movement whatsoever. Calculus solves this problem by formalizing Zeno's demand as a geometric series with a notion of distance. The requirement is that you move from one position to another position while passing through every halfway position between them. Equip the vector space ℝ^3 with the Euclidean metric so you have a metric space (defined distance). Then we have the sequence of steps (a, b, c) -> |(a, b, c) - (a', b', c')|/2 -> ... -> (a', b', c') which corresponds to the geometric series (1/2)^1 + (1/2)^2 + (1/2)^3 + ... that series converges to 1: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=(1%2F2)%5E1+%2B+(1%2F2)%5E2+%2B+(1%2F2)%5E3+%2B+.. https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=(1%2F2)%5E1+%2B+(1%2F2.... More concretely: an infinite expansion such as 0.99999999... is equal to 1. Each half step will take only half as long to traverse as the half step preceding it to it once you've defined Euclidean distance on a continuous space. The first step to formalizing sequences and series like this is by constructing the real numbers as a continuous set and distinguishing between different types of infinities. Then you can define limits, and from there you're essentially done. Note that at no point am I talking about what happens when you reach 1, or (a', b', c'), or anywhere else. I'm just explaining how you reach it in finite time. If you can get arbitrarily close to a point, you can get to the point itself. I guess I should be more technical and say that real analysis solves this problem, because what's really doing the heavy lifting here is the topology induced by defining a metric on ℝ^3 in combination with the notion of limits.
- gus_massa 8y ago[For a technical answer, it's interesting to read the comment by AnimalMuppet https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19700979 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19700979 ] What??? Every Physicist believes that the uncertainty principle apply to any object from galaxies to elementary particles. So if you try to not apply the uncertainly principle in a particle collision in the CERN, they will think that you are crazy. But if you try to add the uncertainty principle to the simulation of the movement of the objects in a galaxy, they will think that you are crazy too because the difference is very small and the calculations are much more complicated. There are some application of the uncertainly principle to neutron stars, and IIRC to the background radiation. Nobody thinks that the uncertainly principle doesn't apply to big objects, it just that in most cases the difference is ridiculously small. Perhaps the “mathematization” of the physical world is a leaking abstraction, perhaps no. We don't know. If you can prove that “we’ll never really know what the world is made up of” you will get a Nobel prize. But you will need a real proof, not handwaving.
- frolig 8y agoMaybe "the physical world" is a leaky abstraction!