3 ms·
I think that Kurzweil has already answered arguments such as this. My rendition of that argument would be that... <argument> Scientists who study these things
by joe_the_user 16y ago
I think that Kurzweil has already answered arguments such as this. My rendition of that argument would be that...
<argument> Scientists who study these things are absolutely correct in saying that we won't achieve quick progress with walls they can see and the tools that they have. Yes, the thing is that we won't see notable progress in the experimental biological realm but rather we will first see super-quick progress from something like a very crude, biologically inspired AI that indeed doesn't require us to understand the brain but works well-enough at the exe-scale. From that, we'll have far more powerful tools to actually start to understand the brain. </argument>
I'm not qualified to say whether Kurzweil's answer here is correct. However, I don't think anyone is going to be able to make final judgment until a "singularity" happens or until computing progress definitively hits a wall we can't go around.
The living-forever question, of course, is a whole, other discussion.
The world is changing very rapidly. Given this, any extrapolation thirty years into the future is fantasy. Things may be very much nicer, very much more unpleasant or in-between. My argument is for uncertainty, not certainty. The idea that things will remain about the same seems like at least as much of a "fantasy" as the idea that the singularity will come and solve all of our problems.