8 ms·
> Bohr postulated a distinction between the quantum world and the world of everyday objects. A “classical” object is an object of everyday experience. It has, f
by gus_massa 8y ago
> Bohr postulated a distinction between the quantum world and the world of everyday objects. A “classical” object is an object of everyday experience. It has, for example, a definite position and momentum, whether observed or not. A “quantum” object, such as an electron, has a different status; it’s an abstraction. Some properties, such as electrical charge, belong to the electron abstraction intrinsically, but others can be said to exist only when they are measured or observed.
This is a common error. Macroscopic "everyday" objects don't have a definite position and momentum. Macroscopic objects are quantum objects. But when the mass is big enough, the position and momentum can be defined simultaneously with an error that is so small that you can just ignore the uncertainty and approximate them as classical objects.
(Looking at them as classical objects is just a good approximation, like ignoring the gravity force of the Moon in most common situations.)
Anyway, the measurement problem is a real problem and nobody knows how to solve it. The current fade is to use decoherence to explain it. It is a promising idea, so I hope that in a few years/decades/centuries we can give a good explanation of the measurements that avoid anything that looks like magic.
- gchamonlive 8y agocan we measure that imprecision of momentum/position relation even though small?
- steve76 8y agoh/2pi ? That likely applies to not just light, but everything. Do we really need that much precision to get what we want? Can we flip it, and just say as long as we can do that, there's still hope to spark up another big bang when everything is cold and expanded? Are they doing something useful by asking these questions or just trying to make a name for themselves, or learn on your dime?
- anongraddebt 8y agoI believe gus_massa was just saying that we simply define out of existence this supposed problem with measurement (for macro objects). This is done because even though the 'furniture of the world'/everyday objects/macroscopic objects are still quantum entities, at this level, error rates are such that they can be treated in a classical manner.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoNo. It would take far more digits of accuracy than we can measure. For example, here's an object of 1 kg mass. The product of the uncertainty of its position and momentum is h-bar / 2, or h / 4 pi, which is about 5e-35 kg m^2/s. We're going to measure the position to one wavelength of visible light (say, 500 nm wavelength, so 5e-7 m). That means that we need to be able to measure the momentum to an accuracy of 1e-28 kg m/s, which for a mass of 1 kg means measuring the velocity to within an accuracy of 1e-28 m/s. Good luck with that...
- aj7 8y agoGood reply.
- spaced-out 8y agoOne of my homework assignments in a quantum mechanics class was to calculate the uncertainty of a cheetah that was running at 65 mph (and given its weight). You can in theory but the numbers get so small that they're clearly unmeasurable.
- philipov 8y agoI thought the current fad was to use holography to explain it. The problem is that to measure something in quantum mechanics requires separating the world into two systems. To make exact measurements, the observing system has to be infinitely large to avoid quantum fluctuation, and the experiment has to be repeated infinitely often because it is probabilistic. To deal with the infinite size, particle physicists push the observer systems out to infinity. This is fine for scattering experiments because collider detectors are so large and far away from a collision it might as well be infinity, but this poses a problem for quantum gravity and cosmology. It seems that the most popular approaches to dealing with it have been based on Juan Maldecena's AdS/CFT correspondance, which is a toy model that allows those observers off at infinity to live on the boundary of spacetime and to describe the behavior of the interior entirely in terms of the projection of that behavior onto the boundary. The challenge is that our universe doesn't look like Anti de Sitter space, but rather like (plain) de Sitter space, and so there is no natural boundary to project onto, which has led some physicists to question the legitimacy of dividing the quantum mechanics need to divide the world into 2 systems. The measurement problem seems like an artifact of that, and what's really happening is that measurement causes the two systems to become entangled. Wave function collapse would then be the subjective result of the two systems entering a mixed state, because the observed system can no longer be described independently of the system that just observed it.
- whatshisface 8y agoA route other than "dividing the world into two categories," has been available since the early days of quantum mechanics, if you believe in many worlds you don't have that problem. It is important to recognize that we are not talking about physics here, we are talking about philosophy. If anything, the greatest shock of quantum mechanics is how it shows that "questions we naturally want to ask about the natural world" and "totally unresolvable philosophical disputes" are not completely disjoint.
- philipov 8y agoAnd that is exactly why it isn't a paradox in quantum mechanics. Quantum mechanics is consistent for the domain of questions it was designed to ask: particle scattering experiments. It's when people push it into philosophy or other unintended domains that they run into problems.
- andbberger 8y agoCheck out https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghirardi%E2%80%93Rimini%E2%80%93Weber_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghirardi%E2%80%93Rimini%E2%80%...
- aj7 8y agoWell put.
- pmiller2 8y ago> Macroscopic objects are quantum objects. But when the mass is big enough, the position and momentum can be defined simultaneously with an error that is so small that you can just ignore the uncertainty and approximate them as classical objects. Exactly. And, due to quantum tunnelling, there's a teeny tiny chance I could walk through a wall, but because there are a lot of particles in me that all have to tunnel a relatively large distance, and the probability of even one of my particles tunnelling that far is so tiny, it won't happen. Intuitively, the difference between quantum and classical objects is a lot like the central limit theorem. Add up a bunch of uncertainties, all of which have similar distributions, and you're going to get something with a very small variance (uncertainty).
- Sylos 8y ago> This is a common error. Macroscopic "everyday" objects don't have a definite position and momentum. Macroscopic objects are quantum objects. But when the mass is big enough, the position and momentum can be defined simultaneously with an error that is so small that you can just ignore the uncertainty and approximate them as classical objects. To put this into simpler terms: Whenever we measure something, we need to throw something at it and then have that something rebound and hit us again. In most experiments, we throw photons and have them rebound into our eyes. Throwing a photon against a "classical object" - a chair, a ladder, bacteria - is like throwing a tennis ball against a skyscraper. You throwing that does not have no effect at all, but it's very much negligible. But when trying to measure quanta, you're now throwing your tennis ball at a football, or at another tennis ball. You're gonna be lucky, if it rebounds at all, instead of just pushing the object that you're trying to measure out of the way. (You also don't have any smaller balls to throw.) That's why when you measure something in quantum physics, you only know that it has this exact value in the moment that you measure it. It's going to be pushed away because you threw something at it, so after your measurement it has a different value. You also can't observe it over a longer period, so there's no way to know whether it was only in that moment at your measured position or a long time beforehand.
- david927 8y agoThat's a nice explanation but doesn't it give the impression that if we could find a better way to do that experiment, we could find a way around the problem, when instead it's a fundamental limit on what we can know about a quantum system?
- gus_massa 8y agoI agree with both. This explanation is easier to understand, but it makes it look like a technological problem that can be solved, instead of a fundamental property of the universe.
- atomack 8y agoI think david927's intuition is more correct here. The uncertainty in the position and momentum is intrinsic to quantum mechanics - it's built into the 'wave function'. The suggestion that if one pushes away something by throwing something else builds on a purely classical intuition and wouldn't require quantum mechanics to explain if this was all we observed. The uncertainty in quantum mechanics is fundamental (to quantum mechanics) and emerges through a different, as yet unknown, mechanism.
- Gibbon1 8y agoI skimmed a paper about twenty years ago that pretty much explains the deference to me. Macroscopic objects are subject to quantum mechanical cascades. The end result is the probability constraints for an object composed of an enormous number of interacting particles rapidly goes to zero. The example was a playing card stood on a knife edge. The probability cascade causes it to fall one direction or the other. We can't predict which side it will fall over on. But it will fall.
- paganel 8y ago> with an error that is so small that you can just ignore the uncertainty and approximate them as classical objects. I’d say that’s the gist of it, that we cannot “just ignore” the uncertainty because it’s too small, because if you do that then your model and the real world are indeed different. Also, at the end of it all what does “too small” mean? “Too small” compared to what? To a galaxy? To a super-nova? To a planet? To a cat? To the things we try to “discover” at CERN? To things smaller than them? To say nothing of the fact that comparing a number to physical stuff will eventually bring you head on against Zeno’s paradox, one way or the other. I agree though that using the “too small” trick does generally allow us to do great things, like send stuff to the confines of the solar system or to build nuclear bombs, i.e. it allows us to be efficient, but that does not mean that by being efficient our models are also identical representations of what reality really is, so to speak. What I’m saying is that maybe the “mathematization” of the physical world is a leaking abstraction, and that maybe we’d be better off by saying “we’ll never really know what the world is made up of”. But the problem is that they haven’t awarded science Nobel prizes to people saying “there’s really no way for us to learn how the Universe really works”, at least not that I know of, at best you’re seen as a mysticist when saying that, at worst as a know-nothing or a cynic.
- philipov 8y ago"Too small" means either it can not be detected experimentally, or even in principle, depending on whether you are allowing gedankenexperiments. I don't think it is reasonable to expect our models to be identical to reality. Otherwise, they wouldn't be models, they would be reality. A theory is correct if it produces experimentally verified predictions.
- throwawaymath 8y ago> To say nothing of the fact that comparing a number to physical stuff will eventually bring you head on against Zeno’s paradox, one way or the other. Zeno's paradoxes are soluble by basic calculus. Once you distinguish between countable and uncountable infinities, the problem of crossing a bounded interval in finite time ceases to be paradoxical. This is basically to say I don't think this is a particular problem for the resolution of outstanding inconsistencies in theoretical physics.