9 ms·
France's Basque Region Creates Its Own Currency
- crunchiebones 8y agoI was kind of hoping this was about the entire basque region using it's own cryptocurrency ;)
- caprese 8y agoyeah, people have been flocking to them because many nations will jail centralized issuers I guess France doesn't care!
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> many nations will jail centralized issuers Central banks (and the related monetary presses) are “centralised issuers.” Nobody is jailing them. Moreover, creating a private currency is legal in most states. (It usually takes the form of IOUs.) People don’t do this because it’s unprofitable. You need additional motivations, like cultural preservation, to counterbalance the economic cost.
- caprese 8y agoand where banks get settlements for non-compliance, non-banks get jail. its not usually because of the private currency, its the compliance, the crowd that flocks to them, the contents of the server, with the sanctioning being almost exclusively on the issuer. permissionless distributed ones don't have this issue
- isoprophlex 8y agothe article mentions how monopoly-esque the notes feel. i assume they're easier to forge than euro notes. maybe some cryptographic signature on the notes would allow instantaneous verification of banknote authenticity, using eg. only a cell phone?
- johnchristopher 8y agoHow would that alone prevent copying ? Unless the actual note/id is linked to some user (and then it has become way more complicated and expensive) ?
- johnchristopher 8y agoNah, it's something people can actually use :). gentle /s
- xrd 8y agoNever use that word here or you will be automatically down voted by Luddites.
- patrickg_zill 8y agoI was wondering how they funded it, in this case with upfront fees. See the "miracle of Wor"gl" https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/W%C3%B6rgl https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/W%C3%B6rgl for a different way they addressed the problem.
- jknz 8y agoHow is VAT paid? How is it accounted for when a business pays it's tax? Are taxes on revenue in the local currency due in the national currency? The only article I could find (in French) suggests that payment in these local currencies bypass the French VAT. https://www.europe1.fr/economie/Les-monnaies-locales-c-est-l-avenir-936924 https://www.europe1.fr/economie/Les-monnaies-locales-c-est-l... It it lets local business circumvent VAT, it not surprising that they quickly become popular.
- johnchristopher 8y agoWhere I live they bound the local currency to the Euro and 1lc=1euro so you trade in whatever you want but pay your taxes in Euro. So it means you better have faith in the local currency because if somehow the experience fails it'll be people, artisans and reseller who'll pay the tab. Although here I think there's something like "the group that printed the money keep euros and will trade it for 1 loc anytime". Since you seem to speak french, here's the faq/doc for my city's local currency http://www.mpcliege.be/assets/2c762a54-5ea1-4417-8b8c-9cfb2048e6fc/le-valheureux-dossier-de-presentation-octobre-2017.docx http://www.mpcliege.be/assets/2c762a54-5ea1-4417-8b8c-9cfb20...
- sonnyblarney 8y agoIt's ridiculous that there are not clear and unambiguous financial artifacts on their site! I can gather from [1] (in French): + That is seems to be pegged 1:1 to the Euro And from [2] + That it may just be an 'alt format' - i.e. each 'Eusko' is backed by a Euro. Meaning this is really just about names and bill colours. It's de-facto just Euros. I don't gather there's a central bank or monetary policy persey, but I could be wrong, I would hope someone chimes in with answers. It might be 'liked' by the local business as a means to avoid transparency, would be a cynical take, but this is money, those are common money problems. There are all sorts of neat ramifications to this, but considerably more if it were truly it's own currency with central bank, policy and not pegged to the Euro. [1] http://www.euskalmoneta.org/comment_ca_marche/ http://www.euskalmoneta.org/comment_ca_marche/ [2] http://www.euskalmoneta.org/eusko_numerique/ http://www.euskalmoneta.org/eusko_numerique/
- 8y ago
- johnchristopher 8y agoThere are a lot of micro-currency in Western Europe. Personally I believe it's a step back because it reeks of protectionism but it's all the rage among my leftist friends (am a leftist too, but not pro micro-currency).
- benj111 8y agoInteresting, I'd have thought it would be a more conservative thing. Keeping money local, protecting local businesses. Maybe that's why they're moderately popular? They cross the political divide.
- mercacona 8y agoLooking forward to a sustainable economy requires some protectionism against globalism. That's how the left became protectionist in many European countries.
- lumberjack 8y agoWhen were leftists NOT protectionists? Protectionism is anti-liberal and anti-free-market? It was always left-wing.
- riffraff 8y agoactual communism and socialism was internationalist at its core.
- lumberjack 8y agoInternationalist yes, but not pro-free-trade. And in practice it was always almost always the opposite of that. In Europe all the hard-left parties were anti-EU precisely because they were opposed to free trade and wanted to protect the local markets.
- labster 8y agoCurrently in the United States the liberal party is the party of free trade while the right-wing president calls himself the Tarriff Man.
- Rexxar 8y ago"creates" => "has created 6 years ago" It's perfectly legal and there is a lot of them : https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liste_des_monnaies_locales_compl%C3%A9mentaires_en_France https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liste_des_monnaies_locales_com... Personally I found this useless but it makes some people happy so why not ?
- msla 8y agoHey, we have a few of them in the US, too: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_community_currencies_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_community_currencies_i... The best-known might be Ithaca HOURS: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ithaca_Hours https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ithaca_Hours
- HeavenFox 8y agoFunny thing, I read about Ithaca Hours before I went to college and found it fascinating. Then I went to Cornell, and I have never, ever seen them in my four years there. Although as a teaching assistant I did get paid approximately $10 an hour.
- gboudrias 8y agoThis is as useless as art, which is to say it appeals to a need not readily apparent to people not familiar with the culture.
- neximo64 8y agoThis is ignorant of the difference that The Basques want their own state. A currency and a language are part of what it takes to hold the idea through time.
- ekianjo 8y agoSeems like the Basques are kind of dropping their language for French instead, based on this article.
- 8y ago
- ape4 8y agoInstead of brexit, Basque-it
- jacquesm 8y agoSome fraction of the Basque population has been aiming for an independent state for a very long time, neither France nor Spain are in love with the idea.
- apo 8y ago> ... Their aim was to reinvigorate enthusiasm for their cultural and linguistic roots and keep money within the French-Basque region by supporting local businesses. ... Adding friction to financial transactions for the sake of cultural reinvigoration seems like a desperate move. Anyone passionate enough about the cause will want to spend locally anyway, so it's not clear that this experiment is the best way to achieve the goal.
- devoply 8y agoIn fact it's extremely effective. Just look at what the French have been able to do in Quebec with all their various laws. This appeal to liberty and choice never actually works, it's just a rhetorical technique to quell dissent. People can't buy themselves out of bad corporate behavior. People can't choose their preferred language. People are lazy and do what is convenient. If you make anything less convenient they will prefer the convenient. For instance take K-cups, marginal benefit and marginal convenience... massive adoption.
- tokai 8y agoConsidering the historical political violence associated with Basque nationalism, it seems far from a desperate move to me.
- effnorwood 8y agoBasquexit
- dontbenebby 8y ago>There are several security features, including fluorescent orange ink, a metal strip and, like government-printed currencies, a measure that is kept secret from the public to further thwart forgery. I suspect they won't be as successful at stopping forgery if for no other reason than the fact that if someone is unfamiliar with this "currency" they won't know it's security properties. (Especially one that's kept secret)
- Proven 8y ago> the eusko can be traded back to euro at a 5% fee, which incentivises holders to keep No shit. Despite thousands of local micro-currencies, not one of them seems based on gold or silver despite the fact that these two are most likely to succeed at replacing fiat. If it's not illegal or doesn't piss of the central bank, you know you're doing it wrong.
- xrd 8y agoI'm curious about how this is legal in the EU. Is this because regions like the Basque have that autonomy financially? This kind of thing is not an option in the US, right? Is there a good write up anywhere that specifies when and where this kind of thing could happen?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- justinclift 8y agoHmmm, the "notes" shown in those pictures look very reproducible without much effort. Wonder if they have a counterfeiting problem? :/
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]