7 ms·
‘Our Lying Eyes’: Inaccurate eyewitness identifications and wrongful convictions
- kbos87 8y agoI was asked to provide an eyewitness identification for a crime I witnessed being committed and reported to the police. I had about a minute-long conversation with one of the perpetrators. When the detective came to my home with a black and white photo lineup, she had a series of photos of people who looked very similar to one another. She explained that lineups were intentionally set up with people who look alike, to ensure that I was dead sure of who I was identifying. Long story short, I declined to make an identification because even after talking to someone and looking straight at him for a full minute, I wasn’t sure enough to become an eyewitness and potentially be wrong about it.
- tcj_phx 8y agoI recently went to a presentation by the Arizona Justice Project [0], an organization that works to free the wrongfully convicted. They said something about how the best way to do a lineup is to present photos one at a time, with no prompting whatsoever. The Department of Justice has various pages about lineups, this one seems informative: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-announces-department-wide-procedures-eyewitness-identification https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-announces-... [0] http://www.azjusticeproject.org/ http://www.azjusticeproject.org/
- mncharity 8y agoPsychology videos of change blindness and inattention blindness are fun. For instance, Simons and Levin's "door" study swaps conversation partners in the midst of their getting directions. Swaps of similar people are less likely to be noticed, but sometimes even very dissimilar (different gender and race and height) swaps aren't. Though to be fair, there's often a misdirection task and/or object. This evening there was someone seemingly "stalking" around on the subway. Perhaps plainclothes, or crook, or artist, or just someone a bit unusual. Getting off, and pondering the ethics of mentioning it, I realized it was a non issue, as I couldn't give a useful description of someone I'd been puzzled by for several minutes. Later, walking down the street, looking at someone, looking away and generating a description, and then looking back to check it... it's clearly not a skill I've developed.
- SargeZT 8y agoIt's worth noting that almost all photo lineups include only the suspect and a bunch of photos they keep around. They generally aren't asking you to choose between a group of possible suspects; they're using the other photos to make sure that you're positive. You should try to make an effort, because even an incorrect identification provides some amount of deniability for the suspect.
- harry8 8y agoNo you absolutely should not. If you aren't sure, say so. Best guess is not the way to do this. Fingering their one suspect among a bunch of photos they keep around who looks maybe a bit like the person you saw? Happens all the time, innocent people go to jail. And yeah, especially if they're from a race with homogenous hair colour and that race is one you don't share. Every time they have the wrong suspect. There are 10 photos. 1 in 10 chance of fingering that wrong suspect and providing false evidence contributing to wrongful prosecution. I actually don't understand why you would even suggest that this is a good idea. Is there something here I'm missing?
- SargeZT 8y agoYou should say you're not sure obviously, but tell them that you think it might be person 3. Additionally, police almost always do a second and sometimes third lineup with other pictures if there's a positive identification.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y agoI think there is also a racial component to it. We focus on features that enable us to distinguish people in our social circle. For example, for some groups of people hair color and eye color are not really distinguishing (a majority of the group have black hair and brown eyes). It would be interesting to see how many of the inaccurate identifications were cross-racial.
- spodek 8y agoSex too. The Innocence Project has overturned hundreds of wrongful convictions, around 99% men.
- js2 8y ago> One other modest mitigating factor should be mentioned. For many everyday crimes, like robbery, the presence of surveillance cameras in stores and buildings has made the police somewhat less dependent on eyewitness identification. The broader use of such surveillance cameras should therefore be encouraged. Oy vey, the cure may be worse than the disease. We’ve know this for over a century[0]. Plane crash investigators mostly ignore eye witness testimony using it only at best to guide the investigation[1]. Maybe this should be the standard for the legal system too: allow eye witness testimony to guide police investigation but not be used as courtroom evidence. Also, this article doesn’t mention the cross or other race effect[2] which is yet another compounding factor. Aside: Rashomon is still an excellent movie. 0. http://historyforensicpsych.umwblogs.org/eye-witness-accounts/ http://historyforensicpsych.umwblogs.org/eye-witness-account... (The link above embeds a 60 minutes segment about the Ronald Cotton case mention in the submitted story.) 1. https://commons.erau.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1040&context=ijaaa https://commons.erau.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1040&co... 2. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/culture-conscious/201208/the-truth-about-they-all-look-alike-me https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/culture-conscious/20...
- mc32 8y agoEye witness evidence can be very deceptive but it can be very accurate as well. Many a time witnesses have provided key information to investigators. But, I agree, it cannot (should not) be used as primary evidence in criminal cases. Hippocampus or not, it’s not consistently reliable.
- michaelt 8y agoMaybe this should be the standard for the legal system too: allow eye witness testimony to guide police investigation but not be used as courtroom evidence. I used to think this, until I had to sit on a jury. I ended up trying a case where the accused had allegedly gone to the victim's home, knocked on the door, then barged in and punched the victim a few times when he answered the door. Hospital records and photos meant no-one disputed the victim had been punched. But what evidence was there that the accused was the attacker? Only the eyewitness testimony of the accused and his wife. I struggle to see how such a case could be prosecuted without eyewitness testimony? Unless perhaps people put CCTV cameras all around in their own homes, and to me that doesn't sound like an improvement in civil liberties. (After we found the guy guilty, the judge revealed the accused was awaiting trial for two other very similar offences with different victims)
- HillaryBriss 8y agoThere's some debate about the accuracy of "flashbulb memories". One side thinks that such traumatic events create durable, accurate memories. The other thinks that such events merely create a strong feeling of confidence that the memories are durable and accurate. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1111/1467-9280.02453 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1111/1467-9280.02453
- mirimir 8y ago> Finally, in 1993 [nine years later], DNA analysis of the semen extracted from the girl’s underwear showed that the culprit was not Bloodsworth but someone else, who eventually confessed. Thankfully, Bloodsworth had not been executed, and he was set free that year. > Over a decade later, DNA testing of the semen taken from her vagina right after the crime proved to be that of another man, who was then charged, and Cotton was set free. > Finally, however, after Bain obtained assistance from a lawyer and the Innocence Project of Florida, DNA testing was granted—and it completely exonerated him. He was released in 2009, having served thirty-five years for a crime he did not commit. There ought to be a federal standard for compensating people who have been wrongly imprisoned. > For example, Texas compensates the wrongfully convicted $80,000 per year of incarceration and an annuity set at the same amount ... That is, you get $80K per year for the rest of your life. That seems pretty fair. But there also ought to be something like a life insurance payout for families of prisoners who were wrongly executed.
- lostlogin 8y ago> But there also ought to be something like a life insurance payout for families of prisoners who were wrongly executed. Or alternatively, have the state stop killing people.
- mirimir 8y agoWell, yes. That too.
- appleflaxen 8y agopretty fair? you would trade your youth for $80k a year? i think that's an egregiously low amount for the way a person in prison spends that time.
- RyJones 8y agoI've experienced this; my impressions of what other drivers were doing is rarely borne by the dashcam video.
- macintux 8y agoI thought about this problem recently when I was listening to To Kill a Mockingbird. Quoting Atticus: > “...but in the absence of eyewitnesses there’s always a doubt, sometimes only the shadow of a doubt.”
- bookofjoe 8y ago"I was certain, but I was wrong"(2000) https://www.nytimes.com/2000/06/18/opinion/i-was-certain-but-i-was-wrong.html https://www.nytimes.com/2000/06/18/opinion/i-was-certain-but...
- alexnewman 8y agoI have been talking to some chinese researchers working on facial recognition who claim that 3d infrared video is already more accurate than eyewitness identification, for chinese people, in china.
- drdeadringer 8y agoI am reminded of a particular "Olde Time Radio" episode of 'The Shadow' which involves a trial; a person of [political? judicial?] importance is accused of receiving or at least being approached with blackmail//bribery. Fatal evidence was reel-to-reel film video with accompanying reel-to-reel audio played in tandem ["high-tech" at the time, remember]. Lamont Cranston & Margo Lane are in the courtroom audience for plot reasons and Lamont has issue with how the voice audio [doesn't quite] sync up with the lips on the video despite potential technology sync issues. "Believe only half of what you see," Lamont paraphrases//declares to Margo, "and nothing you hear." I'll let folks enjoy the episode to the end and I realize that the quoted paraphrase is likely a paraphrased quote in and of itself, but many decades after both I've still remembered the phrasing. -/-/- I've encountered this myself personally when trying to be a personal witness to someone escaping bounty hunters through a hotel bathroom window. In trying to be A Good Citizen, literally being voluntarily in the face of a cigar-chewing dude with sunglasses, and intellectually knowing what "tricks" might be played on me [e.g. "tall, blond hair?" -- "no, short and curly black!"] I still made rookie mistakes in basic reality-telling. And this was live-and-in-person shortly after the event. "Eye witnesses are unreliable" as sometimes reported, indeed.
- tus87 8y agoOne word: corroboration.