5 ms·
I'm a season ticket holder (for Berkeley). When all the CTE stuff started coming out, I felt a bit guilty but not enough to cancel the tickets. Now I'm not su
by jedberg 8y ago
I'm a season ticket holder (for Berkeley). When all the CTE stuff started coming out, I felt a bit guilty but not enough to cancel the tickets. Now I'm not sure how I feel. On the one hand, these kids are aware of the risks and choosing to play anyway. On the other hand, many of them are choosing to play because they come from depressed backgrounds with no other way of paying for or in some cases even getting into college, and football offers a chance to completely change their entire family's situation.
But then again, I was listening to a Freakonomics podcast where they interviewed someone who played football and then went on to get an MBA from Harvard and worked in the executive ranks of both the NFL and NBA.
He's well aware of the CTE risks, but when they asked him if he'd do it all again knowing what he knows now, he said he would still do it, because he grew up poor and now has multiple lifetimes of money. But he would never let his son play, because his son doesn't need to play to get out of a bad life situation like he did. He said it was a sacrifice he'd make again for the sake of his kids and his family. Do we want to deny people that chance to get out of poverty even though they have to knowingly risk their life? I honestly don't know because I didn't grow up poor.
- umanwizard 8y agoHe’s an outlier. The overwhelming majority of college football players will make no money from it.
- metalliqaz 8y agoWhat about a degree?
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoOften it’s essentially an on-paper degree in soft majors specifically designed to cater to athlete schedules and ensure minimal attendance or effort is needed to pass and stay eligible for sports. For the majority of D-1 student athletes, unless they go pro (a tiny percentage) or otherwise convert their college fame into a career, the degree does not open any doors. There are exceptions, but it’s rare. Even athletes who do make it pro are often fucked over by the teams they play for, agents, financial advisors, etc., and a lot of them still end up poor, especially if they are more of a roster player who only manage to stay in the league for a few seasons. For example, I’d guess a lot of people reading this article earn more than median salary for Major League Soccer. In 2016 the median was around $117,000 per year, with around 40 players (on senior rosters) earning the league minimum of about $55,000 [1]. Professional sports leagues are pretty brutal places for all but the biggest stars and of course managers and executives (unsurprisingly disproportionately white men as well...). [1]: https://www.forbes.com/sites/christinasettimi/2016/09/07/major-league-soccers-top-earning-players/#721f82831dee https://www.forbes.com/sites/christinasettimi/2016/09/07/maj...
- bruceb 8y ago>Even athletes who do make it pro are often fucked over by the teams they play for, agents, financial advisors, etc., and a lot of them still end up poor, especially if they are more of a roster player who only manage to stay in the league for a few seasons. Yes, but that is supposing they would not end up the same way had they not played. Also there are lots of people would love to earn 55K to play soccer. Lots of people actually pay for the privilege to play normal people in their same city...
- darkpuma 8y ago> "Yes, but that is supposing they would not end up the same way had they not played." That's supposing they would wind up with brain damage if they had not played. For most it seems likely to be a net loss, but try explaining that to a teenager who only wants to consider the moonshot of making it big.
- moftz 8y agoJust having a BA in anything is going to open more job opportunities than not having one. Even just having an Associates is going to open more than just a highschool diploma. A lot of athletes get degrees in things like biology and communications, not exceptionally hard majors but they still have that piece of paper if they graduate. Unless you want to work minimum wage or ruin your body working manual labor, a degree in anything is required. Could these kids have gone further in life going to a trade school? Could they have joined the military and went to college for a competitive degree under the GI Bill? Maybe, but at the time, a scholarship to play football at a university was a lot of kids only opportunity.
- umanwizard 8y agoIt's honestly very difficult for me to understand this mentality. Is a degree supposed to represent a certain level of education, or is it just an arbitrary way of sorting people into different social classes? There was another article on HN about how a masters' degree in physics increases earnings and is a great career move. Should we find a few thousand kids who are outliers in some bodily attribute every year, and arbitrarily give them physics masters' degrees? Wouldn't there be some serious drawbacks to this? How is this different from giving BAs with basically zero academic requirements to people because of their football skill? The system in the US is just so bizarre. In every single other country in the world[1], universities are one thing, and elite amateur or semi-pro sports leagues are another thing, and nobody would really imagine mixing them. [1]: This is literally true, as far as I know, but please correct me if I'm wrong. I actually get pretty annoyed when people talk about how the US is the "only country in the world" with various problems like violence or healthcare, because usually by "the world" they mean "highly developed Western and Northern Europe". But in this case I think there are actually literally zero other examples of countries with the dysfunctional fusion of academia and semi-pro sports that exists in the US.
- jedberg 8y agoNo but they will have a college degree. And in 26% of the cases they are the first person in their family to have a degree.
- umanwizard 8y agoThe correct way to solve this problem is to make it so that poor but intelligent people can get into college and afford it, not to give fake credentials to people based on football skill.
- JakeTheAndroid 8y agoThis has it's own inherent bias. Poorer families have less structure and can make it harder for kids in those households to succeed academically. Sports at least allows another avenue for children of lower income families to find their way to college. There should just also be more money for lower income academic students. But, that is far harder to monetize. Football programs generate tons of money, which then pays for the student to attend that school for free.
- zbentley 8y ago> Poorer families have less structure What? Citation needed. I totally grant your conclusion that there are big obstacles to academic success for kids growing up in poverty, but, if what you mean what I think you mean, that's a wrong basis for that conclusion.
- macintux 8y agoI’m neither the poster nor do I have any citations, but it does seem difficult to argue that a single parent household where the breadwinner is working two or three jobs won’t have less active supervision.
- JakeTheAndroid 8y ago[0] - http://www.ncsl.org/research/human-services/child-poverty-rates-and-family-structure.aspx http://www.ncsl.org/research/human-services/child-poverty-ra... [1] - https://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2015/12/17/parenting-in-america/ https://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2015/12/17/parenting-in-amer... I am not sure what you think I mean. But what I mean is poorer families have less support, and parents spend less time with their children. This can have cognitive and emotional impact on them impacting academic success and overall emotional maturity.
- majormajor 8y ago> Do we want to deny people that chance to get out of poverty even though they have to knowingly risk their life? I honestly don't know because I didn't grow up poor. I think this is unfortunately a specious question. It assumes that we can't give people other ways to get out of poverty, and hides that we the fans don't really give a shit about players getting out of poverty at all - we like the primal, violent aspects of the game. We don't just put up with them, they're what we've been optimizing for for decades. Even before we knew about the mental impacts we knew about the physical ones.
- jedberg 8y ago> we like the primal, violent aspects of the game Do we? I like the strategy. Honestly I'd get just as much enjoyment if they played touch football and replaced the line with counting to three banana.
- zrobotics 8y agoWhile some do, at least anecdotally IME people are more often fans of the more violent aspects of the game. So while it is possible to enjoy the game purely for the strategy involved, I suspect that isn't the majority opinion. I'm not a fan of the game, but I will freely admit that the violence is one of the main draws to me for hockey. There definitely is strategy & grace of motion involved in the game, but I can't deny that the visceral elements of the game are a big draw as a spectator. I would also feel fairly confident in stating that this is likely the majority opinion among fans of the sport.
- science4sail 8y agoThat does make me wonder what the market for actual gladiatorial games would be. I guess that the closest equivalent would be MMA?
- smileysteve 8y agoBased on "Hit Hit Hit" highlighted in the article, "we" seems accurate, otherwise, outplaying would be more important than physical.
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoThis sounds distrurbingly like gladiator / slave pit fighting. It’s basically a horrible lottery ticket for poor players, most of whom get brain damage and a meaningless college degree, but maybe 2% of whom get life-changing amounts of money (and then some of them get fucked up on drugs or involved in crime anyway...). It sure does not sound like a good way to distribute opportunity at life success to poor children..
- jedberg 8y agoI agree, it's a terrible way to distribute wealth. But it is a way that currently exists. Do we take it away without a replacement? Yes, long term I think football wouldn't exist if we had lots of wealth redistribution programs. But we don't.
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoI am not sure I follow you on this. For example state lotteries are widely known to function like a tax on poor people. Even though some people win the lottery, it’s fairly uncontroversial that most people would be better off if the lottery was simply disallowed, and nobody wins. We don’t need a replacement for the lottery, just to remove it. I don’t see why it’s different for college football.
- LeifCarrotson 8y ago> Even though some people win the lottery, it’s fairly uncontroversial that most people would be better off if the lottery was simply disallowed, and nobody wins. We don’t need a replacement for the lottery, just to remove it. There's a big difference between "disallowed" and "does not exist". The lottery as it stands distributes its poor tax proceeds to the state, often to education. It's heavily regulated, and advertisements contain warnings on the dangers of gambling, and I'd say it's common knowledge that it's a tax on the poor. If it was removed, however, it would leave a vacuum. People are irrational, and the idea that they could get lucky and win is extremely tempting. I don't think you can say with confidence that whatever gambling would take its place would be less harmful than the lottery.
- madhadron 8y ago> Do we want to deny people that chance to get out of poverty even though they have to knowingly risk their life? What if we provided free higher education and stipends rather than making it a carrot to induce those with the right physique to be gladiators? It might get hard to recruit football players, mind you...kind of like how if we actually addressed the systemic problems of poverty in the USA it would be way harder to find volunteers for the military.
- adventured 8y agoYou're advocating for taxpayer funded education, aka shifting the cost from one person to another. The free part you're referring to in other countries, is merely paid for by taxpayers anyway. When trillions of dollars are ultimately involved, it's rather important to never call some of the most expensive welfare services on earth "free." Who would you say the cost should be shifted from and to? What limits would there be on who benefits from the cost shifting? Shifting cost doesn't change the cost. US education, much like US healthcare, is wildly expensive due to universities bloating their systems and dramatically over expanding admin. Those costs are not retreating rapidly no matter what we do. What's your strategy for how much the US can afford to raise taxes to simultaneously pay for hundreds of billions of dollars a year in higher education cost shifting and to meet the epic financial demand for increased socialized healthcare? And I mean in a real scenario, not the one where the US cuts the military budget by hundreds of billions of dollars, because that will never happen.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- scott_s 8y agoI don't think we can argue that any 18-year-old is ever fully "aware" of long-term risks, no matter what they are told. > Do we want to deny people that chance to get out of poverty even though they have to knowingly risk their life? Turn athletic scholarships into academic scholarships. Also, keep in mind that people who get football scholarships for college are outliers.
- sigstoat 8y ago> I don't think we can argue that any 18-year-old is ever fully "aware" of long-term risks, no matter what they are told. hmm, what's that say about letting them vote and enter contracts?
- bliblah 8y agoThe thing is there are already a huge number of sports that he could partificpate in and make a living, especially in the US. American Football just has deep pockets and is willing to hush anyone who provides evidence of CTE. Soccer, Hockey, Basketball, Tennis, Golf, could have all offered the same opportunities for this athlete without the brain damage that is pretty much guaranteed from playing at a competitive level.
- walshemj 8y agoThe PFA in the UK is looking at brain damage due to heading the ball.
- stevenwoo 8y agoSoccer and hockey are not that safe for CTE, hockey is a full contact sport, the younger one is, the easier it is to get concussed and the impact from heading a soccer ball is enough that those under 14 or so should never be allowed to head the ball. contact sports increases risks for CTE signficantly for kids who only played in childhood: https://www.webmd.com/brain/news/20151203/playing-contact-sports-in-youth-may-raise-risk-for-degenerative-brain-disease#1 https://www.webmd.com/brain/news/20151203/playing-contact-sp...
- marcus_holmes 8y agowhat if he had the opportunity, just in a different sport that didn't damage people? Soccer players the world over come from poor backgrounds to earn riches playing sport. Soccer has its flaws, but its not on the same level of dangerous. A fairly simple switch from American Football to What-the-rest-of-the-world-calls Football. You could buy a different season ticket and be part of that change...
- bilbo0s 8y agoReports cite soccer as a major source of CTE injuries as well. (Also, men's and women's hockey.)
- marcus_holmes 8y agofair enough. Chess then? ;)