5 ms·
Sure, in the case of a scan that isn't urgent. If you were in a car accident and have a piece of metal embedded in your kidney are you in a level, clear-minded
by munk-a 8y ago
Sure, in the case of a scan that isn't urgent. If you were in a car accident and have a piece of metal embedded in your kidney are you in a level, clear-minded state to price shop about which emergency room won't gouge you?
Health care is an inelastic good, we need it. So this is a market (much like having a military) that really benefits from the government stepping in and making things sane.
- krapht 8y agoNot that I disagree, but the majority of health care expenses are not time-critical emergencies. I saw a statistic somewhere where it's around 15%?
- munk-a 8y agoThe majority in terms of cost or volume? Also is this figure including oncology treatments - those drugs can run 1k/pill and while some are potentially cures many more are just pushing eventual death a bit further off. These drugs would quite possibly skew any statistic that isn't designed precisely to account for them. Also I think it's not really fair to take full lifetime costs into consideration at once. As you get older you'll be looking at those much more expensive treatments and covered by expensive insurance but the insurance tends to be of a higher quality when it comes to reducing sudden costs - I am more concerned about younger people who generally have terrible insurance and may get hit with 4 months of 20k physio due to a sudden injury but generally have low "normal" costs.
- arcticbull 8y agoIMO the biggest problem is that you're not really qualified to judge medical practitioners. How am I supposed to know if what they're recommending is actually necessary? The market price of an MRI? How do I know they're not skipping care I should have to offer a lower price? Or if they're offering unnecessary procedures? The reality is you need an M.D. to make a reasonable evaluation. This is why at an HMO we have primary care physicians. Or in any other country, GPs. They decide if you need specialized care. However, how am I supposed to pick one of them? It's Russian nesting doctors. It's probably the most complicated thing we have to deal with in our non-professional lives.
- antisthenes 8y ago> Or in any other country, GPs. They decide if you need specialized care. However, how am I supposed to pick one of them? It's Russian nesting doctors. Same way you would pick anything else? I shopped around for my GP and changed several. Some factors were: years of experience, user feedback, spoken languages, any red flags for the whole practice, how they respond to my concerns and questions in conversation, etc.
- munk-a 8y agoActually that raises an additional interesting point... if the market price is varying from doctor to doctor it could be for many factors - how am I supposed to judge the relative quality of an MRI that would be read by two different specialists. If the quality is different then how can I be informed as to the efficacy and truth of that difference? With a bank, Bank of America has terrible service - so I just don't use them, with a doctor though... what if I'm paying a premium price but receiving substandard care, given how complex human bodies are most illnesses compound over time and only in very select circumstances could you get a doctor to come in post defacto look at an X-Ray and say "This doctor was terrible, that's totally a tumor" maybe the real issue is that a tingling in your finger tips when you sit down that you asked your doctor about went unnoticed and twelve years later your heart gave out over totally preventable causes.
- krapht 8y agoSame way you evaluate developers. Say you are a manager at a company who needs to hire somebody to develop an application for you. You aren't technical. You have no idea if you need the thing the consultant is saying you need. So you check completed works, existing client testimonials, educational history, recommendations from coworkers or friends, etc.
- arcticbull 8y agoJust wait until you get a reference request on your last colonoscopy :P Seriously though in general managers have worked in and around technical people before, and their role in the process is to evaluate qualitatively. Are they a good communicator? Do they seem like awful people? They use feedback from the engineers to estimate if they're good engineers. I don't have a deep bench of M.D.s to lean on to figure this stuff out.
- Scoundreller 8y agoThat’s what an advanced directive is for. We just need to extend it beyond CPR/no CPR and heroic measures vs no heroic measures, etc. Kinda how like insurance companies negotiate prices for everything in advance of you showing up. Let users watch a series of videos and choose what kind of risk and benefit they tolerate/want and how much they’re willing to spend. It’s morbid, but we do such assessments constantly. Do I come to a complete stop and waste a few seconds and ml of gas, or roll through it and be really careful about it?
- ddingus 8y agoSeriously? The difference in your "every day" scenarios is recoverability. Your actual health put at risk means you die, unrecoverably. Then there is always people not being able to spend. So they just die? A poll on that policy would be instructive.
- Scoundreller 8y agoThe every day scenarios can result in permanent effects. Not everyone going through a stop sign is in a protective cage. Obviously the advanced directive solution is largely irrelevant in a 100% coverage/public system. The insurer then makes those decisions for you. But for as long as you have a system with uninsured, there’s value in having decisions made in advance as a “just in case”.
- ddingus 8y agoReal value is health care as human right. That we do not do it, and worse, can't even get a basic like water right is an embarrassment at the least, and rock solid cause for reform all day long. In simpler times, a city able to provide clean water was a city of note. Worthy destination. This has been true for ages. Flint fucked for how long now? Our national priorities are insane! Bat shit wrong and health care, food, water, housing are all right at the top of reform agendas for damn good reason. We can do better, and we need to. The uninsured are uninsured because they are unable to spend. Put whatever the fuck anyone wants on that paper and it does not matter one lick. Might as well write, "yeah, let me die, k?" Frankly, there is zero value in the idea, and a lot of harm potential in the norms being changed for the worse: "but they consented..." Anyone who wants to make a directive can do so today. Expecting people to do it because our system is fucked makes zero sense. It is long past time we get our priorities in order so conversations like this are laughable, not morbid.
- ummonk 8y agoIf you're in that dire an emergency you're going to max out your in-network limits anyway, so it doesn't really matter which emergency room you get taken to, you pay the same.