3 ms·
I'm not sure the password being crackable means it's someone else's fault because someone chose to use their identity to commit some serious crimes. Pretty sur
by duxup 8y ago
I'm not sure the password being crackable means it's someone else's fault because someone chose to use their identity to commit some serious crimes.
Pretty sure the fault also lies with the person who would have used their identity too.
- Dylan16807 8y agoIf you're punished for what someone did with your password, that's obviously unfair. Being punished for having a crackable password (on a reasonable hash) is fair. I adjusted the wording a little, is that clearer?
- jfk13 8y agoUsing an easily crackable password is unwise, yes. And it increases the risk that it may be cracked and misused - and therefore the risk of having to deal with the fallout of a crack. But I would suggest that even so, the only criminal in the picture is the person doing the cracking. The victim may have been foolish to have a weak password, but should that really be a punishable offence?
- Dylan16807 8y agoIf part of your job is security, and you don't secure something obvious, then it qualifies as a punishable offence. Not a criminal one, a workplace one. That doesn't mean you need to get punished, but failing to do your job is not nothing.
- duxup 8y ago>Being punished for having a crackable password (on a reasonable hash) is fair. What qualifies as punished to you? It's possible that this person's life career could have been ruined if Manning was able to hide behind this other account and the actual owner of the account was blamed... Is that fair?
- Dylan16807 8y agoIf they got scapegoated, that would not be fair. I don't think Manning using their account would have caused that.
- emaginniss 8y agoI don't know if that's scapegoating so much as it is framing
- Dylan16807 8y agoI don't think pivoting into a different account goes all the way to "framing". Not that it matters what we call it, since everyone seems to be in agreement that they shouldn't be punished for what the account was hypothetically used for.
- HeWhoLurksLate 8y agoIf the article and other information is correct, they tried to breach a user named: ftp To me, it would make sense that that's not an actual person's username, and instead for it to be used for managerial duties (such as for an FTP server), and would likely have been accessed by more than one person. As such, it would make it an especially juicy target, because it would make the hacker a lot harder to trace, and would also not endanger any one person either. (It might make the IT department's life harder, but that's pretty much always the case in these scenarios.)