3 ms·
I think it is pretty well understood that they weren't successful. At least to me as far as if he deserves protection as a journalist, I don't think it matters
by duxup 8y ago
I think it is pretty well understood that they weren't successful.
At least to me as far as if he deserves protection as a journalist, I don't think it matters if he was successful. You can help someone try to commit a crime and even if they're not successful, that can be a crime.
If a journalist is given information that is one thing, offering or even helping someone commit a crime and their role has changed dramatically IMO.
I also wonder what might have happened to that other user whose account they tried to access had hey been successful. What would have come of that person's life / career had they used that as cover for Manning?
- Dylan16807 8y ago> You can help someone try to commit a crime and even if they're not successful, that can be a crime. Sure, but in this case it seems like he didn't even help. He decided on his own to back out of that. If you promise to help, then don't, it should not count as "furthering" the conspiracy. > I also wonder what might have happened to that other user whose account they tried to access had hey been successful. Not sure, but it would presumably be their fault that the password was crackable. [edit: reworded slightly]
- duxup 8y agoI'm not sure the password being crackable means it's someone else's fault because someone chose to use their identity to commit some serious crimes. Pretty sure the fault also lies with the person who would have used their identity too.
- Dylan16807 8y agoIf you're punished for what someone did with your password, that's obviously unfair. Being punished for having a crackable password (on a reasonable hash) is fair. I adjusted the wording a little, is that clearer?
- jfk13 8y agoUsing an easily crackable password is unwise, yes. And it increases the risk that it may be cracked and misused - and therefore the risk of having to deal with the fallout of a crack. But I would suggest that even so, the only criminal in the picture is the person doing the cracking. The victim may have been foolish to have a weak password, but should that really be a punishable offence?
- Dylan16807 8y agoIf part of your job is security, and you don't secure something obvious, then it qualifies as a punishable offence. Not a criminal one, a workplace one. That doesn't mean you need to get punished, but failing to do your job is not nothing.
- duxup 8y ago>Being punished for having a crackable password (on a reasonable hash) is fair. What qualifies as punished to you? It's possible that this person's life career could have been ruined if Manning was able to hide behind this other account and the actual owner of the account was blamed... Is that fair?
- Dylan16807 8y agoIf they got scapegoated, that would not be fair. I don't think Manning using their account would have caused that.
- emaginniss 8y agoI don't know if that's scapegoating so much as it is framing
- Dylan16807 8y agoI don't think pivoting into a different account goes all the way to "framing". Not that it matters what we call it, since everyone seems to be in agreement that they shouldn't be punished for what the account was hypothetically used for.
- cjensen 8y agoYep. There are ethical rules for Journalism, which are enshrined in law in many places. One of the rules is that a Journalist may receive stolen information and publish it. But a Journalist may not themselves steal the information, or participate or aid in obtaining private information. Right now, it looks to me like Assange lied that he was going to help hack anything. I don't see how this is a crime under US law. It's a very weak case, and they cannot lawfully charge him with anything not mentioned in the extradition request. This all changes if they have actual proof he did try to hack a password though.
- duxup 8y agoIt will be interesting to see how / if this plays out in court. I don't really trust Assange to tell his own story honestly as it is so I kinda want to see what anyone can prove when the rubber hits the road.
- rurban 8y agoYou don't need to trust Assange or the Government. Manning already stated that the allegation is categorally wrong. And there's no proof that they did it. But they still went with it, just to get him extradited. A common tactic.
- Fjolsvith 8y agoPeople get sent to jail all the time for conspiring to commit a crime yet never following through with it. I spent 10 years in federal prison and met lots of those people. Do not verbally agree to any illegal act. Doing so is a crime, 1st amendment rights notwithstanding, and regardless of your intent of whether or not you will carry through with the act.
- HeWhoLurksLate 8y agoWould you be willing to share a bit of what happened, so that others know what not to do / why not to do it?
- boomboomsubban 8y ago>I also wonder what might have happened to that other user whose account they tried to access had hey been successful. What would have come of that person's life / career had they used that as cover for Manning? From the affidavit, the password they tried to crack was for the Windows user "ftp," not attributable to any person. I don't understand how people can claim Assange is somehow at fault for attempting to save Manning from the terrible treatment she is still receiving for her deed.
- GVIrish 8y agoTrying to help someone evade detection whilst committing a crime is not really 'attempting to save someone from terrible treatment'. To save Manning from being punished Assange could've guided her to only expose documents related to specific wrongdoing. That would've at least given Manning a plausible whistleblower defense. That defense may not have succeeded, but it probably would've led to a much, much shorter sentence if it failed than what she originally got. But by trying to help her gain illegal access to an account for the purpose of enabling her to steal more classified information, Assange now has to content with conspiracy to commit hacking charges himself.
- boomboomsubban 8y ago>But by trying to help her gain illegal access to an account for the purpose of enabling her to steal more classified information, This is not what happened. Access to the account provided no additional information, it just would have protected her identity somewhat. >To save Manning from being punished Assange could've guided her to only expose documents related to specific wrongdoing. That would've at least given Manning a plausible whistleblower defense. That defense may not have succeeded, but it probably would've led to a much, much shorter sentence if it failed than what she originally got. This already happened. For example, only 75,000 of the 91,000 Afghanistan war documents have ever been released. The defense used this in her trial.
- ausecpro 8y ago>This is not what happened. Access to the account provided no additional information, it just would have protected her identity somewhat. doesnt matter; it's still a CFAA violation. if the facts as they have been presented are correct, assange is guilty of conspiracy.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoThis is not about the minor charges against this individual that helped expose some actual crimes against humanity. It's about spreading the message that whistle blowers face a life time of harassment and should fear for their freedom. It's vengeful and it is being orchestrated by the very people that got exposed. The UN, excluding basically the US and not many others organized an international court of justice specifically to prosecute the severe type of crimes exposed by wikileaks. There are quite a few political and military (ex) leaders in the US that would have to fear for extradition to The Hague for these crimes if it wasn't for the fact that the US does not support this court and refuses to extradite US citizens for the severe types of crimes under the jurisdiction of this court. This will of course never happen. The remarkable thing is actually how openly incompetent the whole thing is being conducted. Wouldn't it be embarrassing if the whole extradition thing collapses based on the notion that there is no good case that Assange actually did anything to make extradition possible. Years of effort and preparation and all they came up with is this. It's certainly putting the UK on the spot for basically very openly having to go through the motions of extraditing Assange on obviously BS charges to please a key ally. I imagine this might drag out for quite some time in the British courts so this has a lot of potential to get quite embarrassing for them.