8 ms·
Stonehenge: DNA Reveals Origin of Builders
- vectorEQ 8y agoseems like they found some stuff nearby and attribute the build based on proximity / estimated time-line? how hard is such evidence to suggest it was really them who built it? any comments?
- whenchamenia 8y agoApparently not even that. Tfa says they just analyzed remains from what they estimate is a similar time period as what they estimate stonehenge to be. Not even local to the site. While some inferences can be drawn, this is mostly puff.
- singularity2001 8y agoI think the article was written in a bigger archeological context in which relative genetic homogeneity was established for within the Mesolithic,Neolithic and Chalcolithic periods.
- 75dvtwin 8y agoExactly. There is no proof that the people whose remains are found, were the builders. Putting into the title '.. origin of the builders' appears to be a fabrication by BBC. The abstract of the referenced article in the scientific journal does not support the BBC's fabrication. "... We find overwhelming support for agriculture being introduced to Britain by incoming continental farmers, with small, geographically structured levels of hunter-gatherer ancestry. Unlike other European Neolithic populations, we detect no resurgence of hunter-gatherer ancestry at any time during the Neolithic in Britain. Genetic affinities with Iberian Neolithic individuals indicate that British Neolithic people were mostly descended from Aegean farmers who followed the Mediterranean route of dispersal. We also infer considerable variation in pigmentation levels in Europe by circa 6000 bc.... "
- arethuza 8y agoWhat is amusing is that Scots myths claim that we came from Scythia - from the Declaration of Arbroath (1320): "we know and from the chronicles and books of the ancients wefind that among other famous nations our own, the Scots, has been graced with widespread renown. It journeyed from Greater Scythia by way of the Tyrrhenian Sea and the Pillars of Hercules, and dwelt for a long course of time in Spain among the most savage peoples, but nowhere could it be subdued by any people, however barbarous. Thence it came, twelve hundred years after the people of Israel crossed the Red Sea, to its home in the west where it still lives today." NB Yes, I know Stonehenge isn't in Scotland but some of the earliest Stone Circles are apparently in Orkney.
- jajag 8y agoThe Irish Book of Conquests (Lebor Gabála Érenn) tells a similar story - in fact I'd guess that's where the Scotch origin myth comes from: [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lebor_Gab%C3%A1la_%C3%89renn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lebor_Gab%C3%A1la_%C3%89renn
- arethuza 8y agoThe original Scots (who went on to subsumed the other parts of what is now Scotland) were from Ireland: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/D%C3%A1l_Riata https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/D%C3%A1l_Riata Their 'capital' at Dunadd is quite cool - I've stood with my boot in the famous footprint - alhough I don't think that's enough to be King of Scots: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunadd https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunadd
- memsom 8y agoThe original Inhabitants of Scotland pre-date the Irish Gaelic speakers who now live on the fringe of Scotland and are so called Highlanders
- talideon 8y agoWell, the same thing can actually be said of Ireland itself. The cohort of Q-Celtic speakers who brought their language and culture weren't all that big. Lebor Gabála Érenn might be a pseudo-history, but it's surprising how closely it jives to the history we _do_ know.
- dalbasal 8y agoIt's fascinating that various Irish, Scottish and (I think, but not sure) Welsh legends make a similar eastern origin claim. Over the last generation, we've had a bunch of what was assumed to be fiction confirmed. Eric the red's voyage and viking visits to North America. All sorts of very old biblical narratives are being confirmed, the existence of early iron age kings and conflicts, for example, are being confirmed by archeology. Troy, and the possible historical conflict with the Greek aegeans... Also from the bronze)iron age transition period. It's like a swing. Modern historians worked hard to get rid of all the bible-based histories. A few generations later, the Bible (and lots of other old books and oral traditions) is a surprisingly reliable source... as are folk legends. Noah's flood is as legitimate as it has been for 100 years. Searching for Atlantis is as non-crazy as it has been for even longer. Some aboriginal Australian oral histories are now thought (by some) to be incomprehensibly, mind boggingly old... I'm still hoping for confirmation of at Brendan the voyager.
- luckydata 8y agoC'mon, the Bible is the book of grossly exaggerated stories for moralistic purposes to be charitable. Yeah the authors referred to things that might have happened but they are as reliable as my 4yo retelling his day.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y ago> Modern historians worked hard to get rid of all the bible-based histories. A few generations later, the Bible (and lots of other old books and oral traditions) is a surprisingly reliable source... as are folk legends. Do you have a source for that? My undergrad education is in history, and I am not aware of any attempt to get rid of bible-based histories. Are there attempts to look at the actual historicity of the events and to place them in their appropriate context? Absolutely, but there's no attempt to simply get rid of the histories.
- gpvos 8y agoI recently watched a video[0] that tried to make the case that the neolithic invasion into Britain around 4,000 BC came from Doggerland. It seemed somewhat speculative (and its author is honest about that), but not a complete crackpot theory either. I wonder what the current scholarship is on the neolithic invasion in Britain (and in Europe in general), and also on who lived in Doggerland. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dvOcK4wfIHo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dvOcK4wfIHo
- foxhop 8y agoNew England (United States) has miles and miles of ancient and undocumented rock walls which rival the ancient walls of Ireland and are largely ignored by scientist.
- e40 8y agoWould love to read more about this, if you have references...
- foxhop 8y agoMost of the literature attributes the walls to early settlers and colonists. The vast amount of walls especially in places that were never settled makes this hypothesis wrong and outright misleading. Some walls were created by colonists but you would need millions and millions to make all the walls in this region. The early colonists were substitance farmers and there are no journals or diaries or documents which talk about building walls. They do have diaries of farming and painting and all other topics but not building walls up mountains and sprawling over legde and landscapes.
- jshevek 8y agoI'm also interested in learning more if you have references/links you'd like to recommend.
- foxhop 8y agoAdditionally the Native Americans never laid claim to making any of the rock walls in this region. Search up liDAR and New England. The region is still being scanned but each time they scan more and more walls are illuminated. https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/crowdsourcing-to-map-the-stone-walls-of-new-hampshire https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/crowdsourcing-to-map-t... https://nhdes.maps.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?id=f4d57ec1a6b8414190ca0662456dffb0 https://nhdes.maps.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?i...
- igouy 8y ago
- kaycebasques 8y agoIs there a big database of ancient DNA that all researchers have access to?
- andromeduck 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_HapMap_Project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_HapMap_Project