5 ms·
My view of aircraft engineering has certainly changed since the 737 stuff came out. You always get told software engineers are a bunch of cowboys compared to ai
by lordnacho 8y ago
My view of aircraft engineering has certainly changed since the 737 stuff came out. You always get told software engineers are a bunch of cowboys compared to aircraft people, because they have to put everything through a bunch of rigourous tests.
I asked a friend who trains commercial pilots about it, and to my surprise he told me the processes to get things certified are political and hand-wavy.
- carlmr 8y ago>the processes to get things certified are political and hand-wavy The big processes that make everything less cowboy inevitably lead to the build-up of people that only do politics and processes and are far removed from actually desigining code.
- gmueckl 8y agoI haven't worked for aviation yet, but from what I have seen in other areas that need certification processes, the system is setup in a way that invites gaming it. In Europe, most certifications are performed by competing private companies. That cannot possibly go wrong and erode standards, right?
- seren 8y agoDieselgate happened in spite of having tests executed by "independent" bodies, even if it certainly looks better, it is not fail safe either. But it is harder to plead ignorance, incompetence or bad luck when you have purposely implemented a code that run only in test settings.
- dfox 8y agoDieselgate has nothing to do with who performs the testing but is an clear example that if you as an regulator want X, but test for Y, manufacturers will optimize for Y and ignore X.
- atemerev 8y agoThe problem is not “cowboy attitude” or “bureaucratic swamp”; these are two sides of the same coin, process inefficiency promotes corner-cutting. The problem is lack of care. They don’t even seem to care about the money, judging from their current stock prices.
- lawlessone 8y agoI know software is bad. But using the same airframe from the 60's and just strapping bigger engines to it until you have to move the nacelle and alter flight characteristics seems like a cowboy move also.
- jefftk 8y ago"Cowboy" is one person taking shortcuts to get things done but in a risky way. This was Boeing optimizing very hard at "how do we get better fuel economy while keeping the same type rating". In general, I'm totally in favor of them doing this sort of optimization, since pilot training is legitimately a big expense. (In this case it clearly went wrong, both in that MCAS was an unsafe design and that the FAA should not have allowed it to keep the same type rating.)
- philpem 8y agoThere's a point where shortcuts are appropriate, and there's a point where the shortcuts actually cost you time. You can spend ten weeks messing around with "quick fixes" when it'd take two weeks to redesign the unstable or broken part. Too much of engineering is obsessed with "get the thing out there and we'll fix it in version two".
- TheCondor 8y agoI think there were some stories about this from Challenger. The cost, be it financial, political, or other was so great to get a part “space rated” that they’d use redundant bad parts to cope with errors in some cases. I vaguely remember this being used to describe a temperature sensor that was wrong like 1% of the time, they used a group of them and some algorithm to filter out error. Can you think of a more geek sexy project than working on a rocket, space craft or jet? Then the reality is that it has to be about the least satisfying engineering job around, it looks like you have to make a titanic effort just to do something
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]