6 ms·
This surprises me... not one bit. I have yet to find the first multibillion outsourcing company that was any good. All the great people are immediately hired
by Aeolun 8y ago
This surprises me... not one bit.
I have yet to find the first multibillion outsourcing company that was any good.
All the great people are immediately hired by the company they’re actually working for, so they’re always left with the mediocre and terrible.
- Bombthecat 8y agoMaybe, they could pay market price than? Oh, the only target is to be cheap.. Okay then
- mikekchar 8y agoTo be fair, the OP was referring to all large outsourcing companies. There are a lot of outsourcing companies that charge well over the rate for a full time hire (they don't necessarily pay their employees that, but...) I worked briefly for one such "body shop" and I found that the company billed my time at a rate of about twice what they paid me. As far as I can tell, it tends to slot in between a full time employee and an independent consultant/contractor in terms of price. Why do companies pay this premium? For one, it may be because they have a budget for a "6 month project" (wink, wink, nudge, nudge) but not for a full time hire. Sometimes it's because they think that they'll be able to pick and choose the best developers from inside a large organisation (and sometimes it works out that way... almost never, but sometimes...) But really it's just a matter of being naive, I think. The company I used to work for (as an independent contractor... ahem...) went through a phase where the CEO was absolutely convinced that it didn't pay to hire developers -- they were a PITA (always demanding weird things, never showing up before 10:30 am, never dressing properly for work, etc, etc). They always wanted raises and you have to track progress and negotiate with them on price every year. You have to pay benefits and if a person is on disability on maternity, you've got to do something about it. You constantly need to be reviewing CVs, interviewing and hiring. If you get someone really bad, you can't actually reasonably fire them for a long time. Etc, etc, etc. So he tried a few experiments with hiring from outsourcing companies (all of which were charging considerably more than any of us were getting paid, I will add)... and it wasn't a disaster, but it wasn't really any better. But the cherry on the cake was, as soon as the project was done, they fled and no amount of pleading could get those developers back again (as you can imagine). So the CEO realised that having a crack development team was definitely worth the effort and the company really transformed as a result. However, a lot of companies are still stuck in the mindset where it's best to have as few full time developers as possible.
- peteradio 8y agoSorry I'm dense but what is the 6 month contract wink wink nudge nudge?
- blihp 8y agoIt's a 6 month engagement that renews in perpetuity. Mainly as a way to avoid having employer obligations.
- protomyth 8y agoAfter the Microsoft lawsuit, those perpetual renewals pretty much dried up. Any company that still does it is taking a risk.
- Foobar8568 8y agoTake a tour in Europe, France or Switzerland, I know some contractors who have been in the same client, if not team (through various reorg) for more than two decades. Myself,5y same client over a 7years period, each time in a different team or close to.
- madeofpalk 8y agoI've been doing this (not quite on the 5 year scale) in both UK and Australia.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoWonder how long it'll last. Current government in Poland recently announced they're planning a crackdown on "permalancers", with a recent interview calling people regularly billing just one client "not true entrepreneurs", and therefore not entitled to privileges of sole proprietorship.
- alteria 8y agoNow Microsoft only allows contractors for 18 months in a given 24 month period (i.e. mandatory 6 month cooling-off period).
- m1sta_ 8y agoI'm not going to debate whether any "companies" are good, but there are more than a few "deals" that have worked very well for the client. Good deals require a lot factors to get right.
- 1024core 8y agoI have some friends who were in an Indian outsourcing company which shall remain nameless. One of them described how they had an "A Team" which was made up of smart, sharp individuals. When they wanted a contract, they'd send this A-team to really impress the clients. Once they had the contract in hand, this A-team would be tasked to get the next contract, and replaced with run-of-the-mill average (or even below average) talent to save on the cost. Rinse, lather repeat.
- duxup 8y agoI worked for a company who outsourced a few times and found that the cost was actually higher in some cases and as you describe there would often be immediate turnover to folks who were far worse, and at worst a liability.... and even those guys would turn over all the time. They'd try another company, same result. Most confusing was when things were straight horrible ... there was nothing anyone can do. I don't know if the contracts say "you give us your money and just deal with whatever we give you" but that's how people would act. The outsourced company could do all sorts of absurd things that would have serious consequences had it occurred with domestic support / new procedures and etc. But when the outsource company did it and it was as plain as day "nothing we can do about it".
- happywolf 8y agoI worked with some other outsourcing companies from other part of the world, and seen exactly this pattern: The initial team was sharp and smart, to gain stakeholder confidence, they stayed for a few months, setting up demo and prototype. Later they would slowly bring in other team members and started to withdraw themselves from the project. Eventually, those A-team was gone. Those late-joiners had absolutely no clue on what was going on, and also didn't have the competency at all to hold the helm. Result? A much mediocre rewrite of the whole platform which never fulfilled the requirements.
- cosmie 8y agoI don't think that's an Indian outsourcing issue, so much as an artifact of the dynamics of the consulting environment. Your above average talent gets trusted with high stakes, client-visible scenarios like new business development, RFP pitches, and high-visibility fire fighting. The roles tend to be a combination of subject matter expertise, solutions architect, client management, and sales. Once you have a contract in hand, theoretically the engagement is structured at that point. It no longer needs the independent competence of members of your A Team, but rather competent project/program management, client/engagement management, and execution resources. That's the stage where a lot of problems get introduced, and it's not always a result of cost cutting or profitability measures. A lot of it comes down to operational competency (both for the agency and the client), as well as the structure of the contract itself. The biggest thing I've learned in my time consulting is what to do (and not do) when structuring a contract for a consulting/outsourcing engagement. Everything else cascades from there.
- jen729w 8y agoIt happens to every company. And – so my pet theory goes – this is inevitable. Any company over size x is, by definition, staffed by average people. That’s the very definition of average. What, then, would lead anyone to believe that a sufficiently large company could possibly be full of geniuses? It just can’t happen. (FWIW this is why I find the companies that do seem to break the mould – Apple, for example – so interesting.)
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoApple surely has plenty of average people too. Arguably the key to operating a large business is to figure out how to optimize the placement and tasking of your geniuses/motivated people with vision/whatever for the greatest gains whilst using the average staff effectively to keep the general workload off of said individuals.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> Any company over size x is, by definition, staffed by average people. Average for that company, not average across profession. > What, then, would lead anyone to believe that a sufficiently large company could possibly be full of geniuses? It just can’t happen. It absolutely can and should (though it's another question why it rarely does). It requires expending continuous effort though - effort to bring in above-average people, to raise the level of people on-board so they stay above average, and to get rid of people that are below average. This is actually what life itself does. The default, lowest-energy state of matter is a mixed and utterly uninteresting soup of everything. Living things continuously expend energy to maintain an organized, higher-energy state against the threat of average. They continuously pump entropy out.
- msiyer 8y agoGoogle, Facebook, CIA, Pentagon... all have been hacked. > All the great people are immediately hired by the company they’re actually working for, so they’re always left with the mediocre and terrible. By "great people" I assume you mean the best talent. I assume you also mean that corporate politics (bootlicking, backstabbing, parasitic behaviour...) has no role to play in these hirings.
- a3s 8y agoI always wondered why, and I came to following conclusion: 1. Orgs outsourcing projects are optimising on costs. 2. Outsourcing IT companies are optimising on margins(nearly the same thing). If orgs outsourcing projects start optimising on quality of deliverables or security, or speed of delivery, we will see drastic change in behaviour of these IT companies. IT companies will be better incentivised to hire smart graduates, invest in trainings etc.