10 ms·
Warren Has a Good Beginning for Ending Corporate-Tax Avoidance
- nordsieck 8y agoAll these sorts of schemes are doomed to fail for the very simple reason that corporations are more agile than the law making process. Here's an easy plan to end tax avoidance: 1. Any company that sells more than $X/year to people living in the US needs to be registered in the US. 2. Flat tax with no exemptions (all corporations would be taxed like C-corps). 3. No more rules. A plan that won't work is one that adds even more rules on top of the the enormous mound of rules currently in place.
- scottlegrand2 8y agoI would extend this sort of simplification to individuals as well. I'd give them a huge upfront deduction all the way up to the median income and then flat tax the remainder.
- malandrew 8y agoThis just creates a disincentive for those corporations and individuals that are being the most productive. People need to remember that the United States doesn't exist in a vacuum. We are in competition with all the other countries out there. Maximizing productivity matters at a national level. The more competitive we are, the better off Americans are on average. If we lose that lead position to other countries, we may achieve greater equality internally but we will be worse off relative to the rest of the world.
- maxerickson 8y agoI think you have to be careful with semantics. If the marginal effect is small, a higher tax rate might be better described as "slightly less motivating" or something, rather than as a disincentive. The idea that there's a substantial aggregate effect on behavior if you increase taxes from 40% to 41% probably needs a little more proof than just assumption.
- scottlegrand2 8y agoOh but there is an incentive here: the higher the median wage, the higher the deduction everyone gets. And for those below the median wage, they can just keep making all the money they want all the way up to that median wage and pay $0 in taxes. What exactly am I missing that's giving me all these downvotes? I just want a fair tax code all the way up and down the socioeconomic ladder and I want to wipe out all those incredible deductions given to the capital gains class so that we're all on the same page.
- malandrew 8y agodon't know why you're getting downvoted, but every time I hear someone say they want to be fair, my immediate reaction is to ask "what's your definition of fair?" My definition is that everyone has skin in the game and feels the same pain when it comes to raising or lowering existing taxes or creating new ones. Any thing else is a wealth transfer and theft from one to give to the other. Having everyone feel the pain proportionally, would have all taxpayers questioning the efficiency of how their money is used. When most taxpayers don't feel the pain is when government starts wasting money. Why pressure governments to provide more bang for the buck when you're not the one footing the bill. Furthermore, you're also distorting the cost of labor and distorting how taxes are handled. Those that don't pay any taxes end up providing artificially cheap labor. If a worker needs $10/hour for it to be worth their while and the taxes they pay are $0, businesses will pay $10/hour. If they need $10/hour for it to be worth their while and their taxes are $2, the business will have to pay $12. If the product/service the business provides sells for $20/hour, the business gets $10 in the first scenario and $8 in the second scenario. The business actually makes more in the scenario where the labor doesn't pay taxes and businesses are better at avoiding taxes through clever accounting so less money is likely to be raised than a flat percent that everyone pays with no loopholes. Having the rich pay all the taxes also gives them the most economic incentive to make modifications to the system in their favor, and it puts the most money in their pocket to spend on lobbying activities. In the example above, the business has up to $10/hour of profit to allocate to lobbying with when they are paying the taxes. At the end of the day, the market will adjust to all the distortions you bake into the system, hiding the true cost of inputs needed to produce goods and services, which reduces market efficiency. Overall, society is better off if things are priced as accurately as possible since people can make more accurate decision about the worth of providing goods and services. This also applies to making sure the costs of externalities are priced into the goods and services provided.
- int_19h 8y agoChange that deduction into a tax credit, and you're basically describing one way to implement UBI. I think it's not obvious to everybody that what you're suggesting is really a progressive income tax, BTW, since that flat rate is paid on different proportion of income, and with a high enough cut-off, it can easily be more progressive than our present arrangement for most middle class tax brackets and below.
- AdamM12 8y agoJust a thought. How about abolishing corporate tax and then making every entity as pass through entity for tax purposes? At the EOD all entities are owned by someone and that income is taxed at a progressive rate. From what I've read the corporate tax is only 10% of the federal budget anyway. Edit: This wouldn't stop a company from doing what Amazon did and reinvest all the time but at least given a profit an entity would be pressured to pay out cash in order to cover tax liability of owners. Would help avoid hoarding of cash on balance sheets.
- reitzensteinm 8y agoWe have that in Australia & NZ, called Franking. When a corporation pays tax, it receives credits which can be distributed with the dividends it pays out. While strictly better than the alternative for business owners, I always felt the incentives were a bit weird; if you left profits in the company to expand, you'd pay tax on that up front which would slow growth. So it would bias you towards withdrawing profits (at least compared to the tax policies of other countries). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franking_credit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franking_credit In my opinion, corporate taxation should be tied to liability; essentially being the compensation to society for the risk that your company will go though bankruptcy. If you are willing to be personally liable for your business, you should be able to operate it as a simple pass-through vehicle. And this should apply even to something the size of Apple - investors willing. It's commonly argued that capital gains combined with corporate tax is double taxation, but limited liability has a huge amount of value; making the link between them explicit and optional would (I think) be the best of both worlds.
- AdamM12 8y agoI believe double taxation actually refers to paying the corporate tax rate as well as the shareholder paying their dividend tax rate. Not capital gains.
- reitzensteinm 8y agoI misspoke and meant to say corporate tax which would be more correct. But the tax rate also effectively applies to capital gains, since the value of a company is the NPV of its future distributions. If Apple were suddenly permanently excepted from income tax tomorrow through some bizarre legislation, its future dividends would be proportionally increased, and its market cap would (should) rise to match. The water is muddied due to a few factors such as inflation, uncertainty around future tax rates, potential tax holidays for overseas income etc. But they're in very general terms two sides of the same coin.
- dmm 8y ago> Flat tax with no exemptions The difficulty with taxation is not calculating tax rates, that's simple, the difficulty is determining what is taxable income/profit.
- 0_gravitas 8y agoSome sibling comment to oc seems pretty straightforward: the profit taxed is the profit reported to shareholders
- anchpop 8y agoWhat would prevent a company from telling the shareholders they made no profit? Is there a separate process that prevents them from lying and is more difficult to manipulate than the current tax code?
- guelo 8y agoPresumably they want the stock to go up so they would want to report a profit. And Wall Street gets pretty upset with any company trying to cheat on their GAAP reporting
- maxxxxx 8y ago"The difficulty with taxation is not calculating tax rates, that's simple, the difficulty is determining what is taxable income/profit." Exactly! Flat tax is just another trick to reduce top tax rates while not solving any problems.
- mamon 8y agoThen do not tax income, tax revenue. If company makes, say $10B in the US in sales, they should be required to pay at least 1% of that, i.e $100M in taxes. And before anyone starts complaining that some companies have very thin profit margins: if your profit margin is close to or less than 1% then your business model is unsustainable in the long run anyway.
- slg 8y agoThe government would and should never abdicate the potential to control economic incentives through taxes and subsidies.
- olliej 8y agoCan’t we just say “your profit for the purposes of taxation is the profit you report to shareholders?”
- rb808 8y agoYeah I think this is the real problem. Most people think Amazon makes a lot of money. They even say they made $12B, but they gave billions to of RSUs to employees so the IRS wisely says they didn't make much. The truth is they didn't make much/any money which is why their tax is low.
- olliej 8y agoThe problem I have is being able to report different profits to different groups - you should be required to have a single pretax profit number, and that is what you report. If you really don’t make money then you should be required to report that to your shareholders, and conversely if you tell your shareholders you’re making money, then you should be required to report that value to the irs. I don’t care which one you use (I mean I do, but in this case it’s not the specific point), what I’m saying is you don’t get to make money by having overvalued shares (by giving one profit number or the market), while not paying tax (by reporting a different number to irs)
- rb808 8y agoChoose the tax number. "Accounting for Growth" was a classic book written after the late 80's stock market bubble in the UK about how people were fooled by bad accounting and how to spot fraud. One of the main pieces of advice is that the tax number is usually more correct. If a company says it makes huge profit while paying little tax its likely not real profit.
- andrewstuart 8y agoSeems logical, but in the USA there always seem to be convoluted reasons why seemingly simple things can't happen, usually the result of vested interests pushing their agenda and getting their way for a very long time.
- malandrew 8y agoSo much of the tax avoidance tactics ends up as more investment and propels our economy forward. Amazon is a prime example. The government taxes profits. Amazon instead of making a profit, reinvests the money into its business. Even when corporations do stock buy backs, it's not like most of the money goes to the investors to spend frivolously. Instead most of it just gets reinvested in different businesses that have a better plan for the money than the company that did the stock buyback. Any way you slice it, Warren's plans just reduces reinvestment and puts the brakes on economic growth. You can't tax your way to prosperity unless the taxes are used strictly for things that are an investment in the economic future of the country such as education and infrastructure. Taking the money from those investing it and blowing it on entitlements is a terrible idea. At the end of the day, all this reinvestment creates jobs and allows individuals to provide for themselves instead of being dependent on sucking at the teat of the state.
- moosey 8y agoThere are things that Amazon needs done to continue to run it's business effectively. Roads need repaired, crime needs to be kept down to acceptable rates, trash needs to be removed, they need to be defended from foreign nations, etc. The need of the corporations of our nation means that everyone, including these companies that don't build their own roads and militaries are on "the government teat". The idea that money is better in private hands than in the collective hands of government is a story that is oft repeated, but is far from proven. Arguably, studies I've seen of late show loss of efficiency and increased cost when privatized. This is a requirement for profit anyways. Further, money spent by government has had massive effect on economic growth. Hoover dam made the much of the West livable, nasa still had massive scientific output, and welfare programs are incredibly effective.
- aeternus 8y agoI'd be interested to know which studies? While I agree that Amazon should pay their fair share, I find it hard to believe that there is a general loss of efficiency when privatized. Companies have strong incentives to reduce costs, whereas government projects often have negative incentives to reduce costs. (Cost-plus contracting and use-it-or-lose-it budgets). NASA is a great example, that organization made some amazing breakthroughs early on, but has arguably stagnated. It is now being surpassed by private companies due to ballooning bureaucracy and cost-prohibitive mission proposals. Something that many thought impossible. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/space-exploration-sticker-shock/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/space-exploration...
- Eridrus 8y agoWhy should I care about the corporate tax burden? Taxes come out of people's pockets, not corporations. There's an argument to be made that we can get foreign shareholders to pay taxes they otherwise wouldn't, but that's a much different argument than "corporations aren't paying their fare share".
- andrewstuart 8y ago>> Taxes come out of people's pockets, not corporations. That's not correct - corporations are meant to be paying significant tax.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 8y agoIt is correct. People own corporations. So if you're taxing a corporation, you're actually just taxing the people that own it. (And/or its customers or employees.) The only point in taxing corporations vs. people directly is if you're trying to target a set that's difficult to tax otherwise, such as rich people who own big corps but don't realize a lot of income on their own balance sheet. Which IMO is a fair group to target. But that's the point. Corporations are just things that are owned by people. People, ultimately, pay the taxes. So the question ought to be, which people do we want to pay more taxes, and what's the best mechanism to get them to pay those taxes?
- Terr_ 8y ago> The only point in taxing corporations vs. people directly is I disagree, you're skipping a huge governmental benefit that almost all the biggest corporations request/receive: "Limited Liability." If Nuclear Asbestos Infant Toys goes bankrupt, everybody else is picking up the tab for land-cleanup and tumor-removal. In other words, those owners have chosen to socialize their company's risks, so it's only natural and fair for some of the company's profits to be socialized at the same junction.
- thrill 8y agoThe smallest corporation receives that same benefit.
- jonknee 8y agoCorporations are owned by people, start by taxing them simply. Income should be taxed the same whether it comes from a dividend, capital gain or as wages.
- skybrian 8y agoIt's a nice idea, but tricky to do. The difference is that wages and dividends get taxed in the year they happened and capital gains can't even be calculated until you sell an asset, because you don't know the price it's sold at. And capital gains taxes can sometimes be delayed forever (by not selling). You could mark to market, but it's tricky for investments that aren't liquid. Do you want to pay capital gains tax on your house every year because the market price is supposedly higher? Do you get it back if the market goes down again?
- int_19h 8y agoCapital gains are taxed when they're realized, and I don't think OP proposed changing that - only adjusting the rate so that it's not less than tax on regular income.
- andrewstuart 8y agoTaxes are a good thing. They pay, or should pay, for education, health, military, roads and infrastructure and a wide variety of other stuff that is good for everyone. It puzzles me that people hate taxes so much.
- programmertote 8y agoI consider myself a fairly progressive person. But I think at least some of the people, who don't like paying so much taxes, don't like the fact that the government is allocating the tax money collected, and it could, according to their belief, cause inefficiency. I agree with that notion to a certain degree. For example, I wish there is a way to allocate the tax that I pay yearly to the programs that I want to fund. Specifically speaking, say if I pay $100 in tax, I should have a say to paying at least $50 of that to programs that I think are important for me (e.g., dept. of transportation; dept. of education; EPA...)
- chii 8y ago> programs that I think are important for me Which is the whole reason why individuals should not be making such choices. Small, marginalised causes or departments should still get funding. If we followed your method of fund allocation, some aspects of Govt would not get any funding at all. You may also end up funding departments which don't need as much funding. This misallocation is worse than today's imo.
- p1necone 8y agoAnd things where the negative effects of lower funding won't be seen for maybe decades down the track might not get enough funding either because their necessity wouldn't be obvious to the average person. Although we have that problem currently too so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯.
- seanwilson 8y ago> I wish there is a way to allocate the tax that I pay yearly to the programs that I want to fund Isn't that what voting for representatives that represent your general viewpoints is meant to do? You delegate decisions to representatives because it wouldn't be practical to keep up with everything you need to make a large number of informed decisions.
- calibas 8y agoDon't elect wealthy politicians who are in bed with industry lobbyists and watch things change overnight.
- qmanjamz 8y agoCorporate taxes shouldn't exist in the first place. They're just a sneaky way of double-taxing people. Corporations are really just groups of people. Those people already have to pay taxes on the income they receive from the corporation. They shouldn't have to pay taxes on it again when the corporation reports it as income.
- tomhoward 8y agoI'm sympathetic to the argument in principle, but it hinges on the system for assessing income of/collecting taxes from individuals being adequately rigorous and efficient. The presence of loopholes, tax havens and other mechanisms (including corporations themselves) for hiding personal income means the bucket is very leaky. Given that corporations have to maintain complete records of their cashflows and disclose them to investors and authorities anyway, using this data for intermediate tax collection seems reasonable.
- gnicholas 8y agoThe Bloomberg article links to a blog post by Warren, which is headlined by a graphic that says: You probably pay more in federal income taxes than America's biggest, most profitable corporations. This strikes me as an inflammatory — and generally untrue — statement. Even if you assume that all of these corporations pay zero federal income tax (they don't), then roughly half of Americans don't pay more (recall Mitt Romney's impolitic-but-true statement about 47% of Americans not paying any federal income tax). But of course, most companies do actually pay federal income taxes, and when they don't it's often because of loss carryforwards. This particular aspect of tax law is not a "loophole", and lumping it in with lobbied-for tax credits/deductions doesn't help move the discourse forward. The scope of the proposed tax hasn't been fully fleshed out, and I won't comment in-depth on it (as a former tax lawyer) at this point. But when I click through to see the original proposal and am greeted by this inflammatory and untrue statement, I am reminded that even the wonkiest of policy wonks will spin things pretty hard when it's election season.
- refurb 8y agoThe other thing that i see a lot is cherry picking of data. “Company X paid no tax this year”. It’s often because of some event where they had a big loss, conveniently ignoring all the past years where they paid hundreds of millions in taxes.
- tschwimmer 8y agoMitt Romney's statement was not primarily in character a factual observation that 47% of people pay no income tax. It was something far more opinionated and in my opinion, deeply inhumane and unethical. The full quote: "There are 47 percent of the people who will vote for the president no matter what. All right, there are 47 percent who are with him, who are dependent upon government, who believe that they are victims, who believe the government has a responsibility to care for them, who believe that they are entitled to health care, to food, to housing, to you-name-it. That that's an entitlement. And the government should give it to them. And they will vote for this president no matter what…These are people who pay no income tax." This is Protestant work ethic taken to a corrosive extreme. This is Romney playing to an audience that believes those who take government assistance are conniving malingerers looking to squeeze every penny they can out of hard working taxpayers. It is an indictment of people who had the audacity to be born without the ability to fully support themselves. It begrudges them for daring to ask for a home, food, healthcare and maybe even a few spare moments of happiness. In my opinion, this type of thinking is the greatest moral failing of the 21th century. It frees the thinker of any social responsibility by demonizing those least equipped to defend themselves. I do not agree with many of Elizabeth Warren's policy proposals. Her thinking on technology is dangerously benighted. I will not vote for her. But the essence of Warren's argument is that we need to rethink the relationship between the most successful members of society and the least. Tax loss carryforward is a standard accounting practice that makes rational sense. Nevertheless, it's the type of policy that helps those who need help the least, and I think we need to start to rethink these kinds of policies. We as a society can continue to pass legislation that favors the strong and punishes the weak. What we can't do is look at ourselves in the mirror afterwards and continue to believe that we live in a humane, compassionate, egalitarian society.
- comnetxr 8y agoAccording to the model in this proposal, corporations report their "true" profits to shareholders, and artificial "profits" to tax authorities using corporate accounting tricks (i.e. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement) to lower tax liability. This proposal assumes that, when the tax rate is based on the value of reported shareholder profits, corporations will continue to report their "true" profits to shareholders, rather than just reporting the values returned by corporate accounting tricks to shareholders. I doubt that would be the case. The best argument for it I've seen is "Presumably they want the stock to go up so they will report a profit", i.e. investors will move to companies that are on paper more profitable. But actually, investors do their research and can update their profit models of companies; a higher reported profit number will be seen as (and will actually be) a liability to the company. Companies that forgo accounting tricks will be seen as forgoing potential profit by paying taxes that they don't need to. (The same is true today; if Google announced today that they were voluntarily giving up tax accounting tricks and paying full rate, their share prices would go down.) The one caveat is whether the SEC enforces that the reported profits really are the true profits. But that model of enforcement (self reporting, cheaters rarely get caught and if they do settle the cases for amounts less than their profits) is silly. If we want taxes paid on true profits, we should implement tax law that precisely defines what those are and instruct the IRS to determine those exactly and send them a bill. Reporting requirements to the IRS should be set up with incentive structures that make cheating unprofitable or impossible.
- rland 8y agoTax for revenue's sake (as opposed as one legislated to change behavior, like a carbon or environment tax) should be 0% on businesses. The rhetoric I see coming from the left is very worrying. "We will pay for this by just taxing 'corporations.'" What happens under high corporate taxes is that executives of the corporation manage to extract their share, while using the share of those not in control (the workers) to pay the tax. The end result is that the government does not decide who must pay; instead, those with power in the corporation decide. This outcome is always unfair to the worker: a line cook at McDonalds cannot decide whether McDonald's should cut wages or decrease dividends to pay for the corporate tax this year. That doesn't even describe the case where a business cannot operate under a heavy tax burden and ceases doing business, which is a loss for everyone in the economy. Taxes on corporations should be reserved for those situations where we need to control behavior at the corporate level, where a tax at the individual level cannot efficiently be used. For example; a carbon tax levied on a corporation to effect the corporation's behavior re: carbon. This is not an argument for lower taxes.