5 ms·
Gilliam's "Brazil" is still my favorite film of all time. If you haven't seen it, you should. Note that there are multiple versions of this film floating arou
by lisper 8y ago
Gilliam's "Brazil" is still my favorite film of all time. If you haven't seen it, you should. Note that there are multiple versions of this film floating around. Comparing them makes a very interesting study in film editing. The story of the making of "Brazil" is almost as interesting and fraught as Don Quixote.
When watching Brazil it's important to keep in mind that it was made in 1985, before 9-11, before the internet, before ubiquitous surveillance. It is one of the most prescient films ever made.
- hellllllllooo 8y agoIt's great. It's semi-adaptation of 1984 without directly taking the story it feels very similar in spirit. The soul crushing effects of malicious beurcracy, someone seeing past the facade and going though a lot of pain while trying to escape it. The movie equivalent of calling to cancel Comcast, where the feeling of knowing the experience is going to be so bad it puts you off doing it.
- ch_sm 8y agoI think the working title of the film even was 1984½
- willtim 8y agoIt's one of my all-time favourites too. The Criterion Collection edition I believe contains the final directors cut. The ending is superb, it beggars belief that Hollywood tried to butcher it.
- citizenkeen 8y agoThe Brazil CC is amazing, and also includes the "happy" version the studios forced to exist, so you can compare.
- Quekid5 8y agoNow I'm worried that I haven't seen the right version. Is there a breakdown of the different versions floating around somewhere?
- devindotcom 8y agoWell, without spoiling anything in particular, let me just say this. Do you feel it was a happy ending? If so, it is probably not the director's cut.
- Quekid5 8y agoAh. The reason I ask is that the ending I saw could be interpreted either way, but I saw the 'happy' ending as obvious satire/irony. I'm just worried that I saw the wrong ending and over-interpreted it.
- TipVFL 8y agoIt sounds like you saw the "Love Conquers All" version, but saw through the illusion. It's actually part of the original ending, but with all the framing of the scene removed. Definitely check out the director's cut.
- joshuak 8y agoThere was a release, perhaps the lazerdisk box set not sure, that had both the theatrical cut and a (I believe) BBC tv edit. Although the BBC tv version could be characterized as more up beat, the commentary and inclusion in the box showed it great respect. They discuss the editing choices that needed to be made to reframe the story as if it had been conceived that way from the beginning. It's one of the most educational discussions of cinematic storytelling and editorial technique. It is absolutely worth seeing both versions and listening to the commentary if you can find them.
- flavio81 8y ago>Gilliam's "Brazil" is still my favorite film of all time Mine too. I am also a Common Lisp programmer, although I haven't put Lisp on spaceships like you. Great Minds Think Alike!!
- joshschreuder 8y agoMy favourite of all time too. I think it holds up as a whole (including visually, where others might seem dated) extremely well.
- oknenavin 8y agoOne of the finest movies for me too. Perfectly depicts our society.
- Quekid5 8y agoFantastic and fantastical yet so so so bleak. I find the bleakness beautiful in a weird way, but I think it's a film that presupposes a certain mental fortitude.
- satori99 8y ago> It is one of the most prescient films ever made. "People think I am a prophet and that Brazil described the world we’re living in now a few years ago. But we were living in that world then; people just weren’t paying attention the way they do now." https://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/01/magazine/terry-gilliam-is-not-in-fact-dead.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/01/magazine/terry-gilliam-is...
- lisper 8y agoInteresting. I'm not sure I agree though. I was in my early 20s in 1985 and so I can tell you from personal experience that things were really very different back then than now. In 1985 it was possible to escape surveillance without to much difficulty. Nowadays it's nearly impossible. Also, in 1985 the stock villains weren't terrorists, they were Russians.
- satori99 8y agoI think that the plot devices involving terrorism were the most prescient. When I first saw the film as a young teenager in the 80s, I was fascinated that the terrorists philosophy or demands were never clearly defined beyond "anti-government". Terrorism was portrayed as a regrettable but normal part of life. Perhaps people who lived through actual terrorist bombing campaigns in British cities can relate to this more, but for me it was a crazy idea that this sort of thing could be normalized to any extent. And yet here we are.
- lisper 8y agoI thought this scene made it pretty clear that the terrorist attacks in the film were false-flag operations carried out by the government: JILL Who is this war against, Sam? SAM Well, terrorists of course. JILL How many terrorists have you met? Actual terrorists? SAM Actual. terrorists? Well... it's only my first day.
- tomohawk 8y agoGreat movie. When you watch it, you need to pay attention to every little thing. For example, the movie opens with an advertisement for government services. The dittie is hysterical, but its easy to miss. That theme gets expanded quite a bit in the film culminating in a fantastic scene with Robert De Niro as a rogue heating engineer.
- busyant 8y ago> That theme gets expanded quite a bit in the film culminating in a fantastic scene with Robert De Niro as a rogue heating engineer. so good! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VRfoIyx8KfU&t=2m10s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VRfoIyx8KfU&t=2m10s
- toyg 8y agoI think you forgot the quotes around "heating engineer".
- max_likelihood 8y agoIf you want the quotes added, you're going to need to fill out a 27b-6 ;)
- BuildTheRobots 8y agoCompletely missed that on previous watches of the film. 27b-6 is a reference to George Orwell's address; Apartment 6, 27B Canonbury Square, Islington London. It's also the website of David Thorne, who is always amusing if you're looking for some vicious sarcasm: http://www.27bslash6.com/missy.html http://www.27bslash6.com/missy.html
- fb03 8y agoAlso don't forget "Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas", another controversial classic directed by Terry.