12 ms·
Why was it so hard to take a picture of a black hole?
- loraa 8y agoHard to believe that it took 200 people to photograph that.
- oevi 8y agoA very good explanation on what we are looking at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zUyH3XhpLTo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zUyH3XhpLTo
- wizardforhire 8y agoUhhhh this statement in the article about halfway down is incredible! “You need to be able to tell the difference between one wave front and the next, and if the next wave front is 1.3 mm behind and traveling at the speed of light, then you need to reliably distinguishing between events 4 picoseconds apart (4 trillionths of a second). So, every telescope needs a shiny new atomic clock and a really fast camera. You begin to get a sense of why the data consolidation looks more like a cargo shipment than an email attachment; trillions of snapshots every second of not just the waves you’re looking for, but also the waves that will cancel out once all the data is processed. Add to that the challenge of figuring out (generally after the fact) where every detector is to within a fraction of a millimeter even as their orientation changes and the Earth rotates, and you’ve got a problem.” Just stupefyingly complex and amazing!
- 317070 8y agoAlso, you are looking at a piece of the sky the size of 5 atoms at armslength.
- benj111 8y agoOr the thickness of a human hair at 500km (from the article)
- 317070 8y agoYes, but I did not use that one as I don't like that visualization. My reptilian brain made that sound way bigger than it actually is. As the horizon is only 5-10km away, I cannot really estimate a distance of 500km. I can see the problem of measuring 5 atoms height at arms length though, even when I cannot imagine the size of an atom. Black holes are small things. They're just very heavy.
- Filligree 8y agoBlack holes are normally small things. The furthest one out of these is larger than our solar system, however.
- ben_w 8y agoMessier 87* has a Schwarzschild radius of ~17.784 light hours. The scale of the universe is enough that the mother of my ex had a panic attack when watching a YouTube video about things much smaller than that — hypergiant stars.
- irrational 8y agoWhat was the cause of the panic attack?
- dclowd9901 8y agoProbably the innate fear of infinity
- ben_w 8y agoFrom what I understood, the realisation that the Earth, that everything and everyone she’d ever known, was an invisible speck next to an invisible speck compared to the largest star.
- Izkata 8y agoAhh yes, the Total Perspective Vortex.
- mehrdadn 8y agoThanks for this analogy, it's far more enlightening than the human hair version.
- okcando 8y agoInteresting. I have precisely zero intuition for the scale of five atoms!
- rangibaby 8y agoHow many football fields is that?
- cjsawyer 8y agoLet’s just round to 0.
- anticensor 8y agoSmaller than kickoff dot.
- tim333 8y agoThe size of a football 27,000,000 football fields away.
- jkmcf 8y agoAmerican or European?
- bacon_waffle 8y agoThe specific mention of the box of hard drives in the press release, was because there are no flights in/out of South Pole (where the 10m South Pole Telescope is) for ~9 months in winter, and the Internet access there is very expensive and not very high bandwidth.
- leowoo91 8y agoAny similarities with an electron microscope?
- jcims 8y agoThis is why you aren't likely to be doing VLBI in the visible light spectrum any time soon. Your wavelength is three orders of magnitude smaller, so the equipment you use to capture phase information has to be three orders of magnitude faster and the correlation is likely to require at at least three orders of magnitude more capacity.
- RedOrGreen 8y agoYes, we're not going to do optical VLBI soon, but the reason is deeper... I just wrote out a long comment [1]. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19674563 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19674563
- afturner 8y agoIs there any information on the tech behind this? As a software developer this is horrifying and fascinating
- RedOrGreen 8y agoCalling it a "really fast camera" elides much of the actual difficulty. We're trying to tag individual wavefronts of light at different telescopes, record them, and then play them back at a central "correlator" with the appropriate delays so that the waves come to a focus. For a wavelength of 1.3 mm, we'd want the time tagging to be better than a quarter of the wavelength at least - say 0.3 mm. The speed of light is 300 mm/ns (a foot per nanosecond is the shorthand beloved of circuit and chip designers). So, for 0.3 mm, we're going to have to get down to a wavefront tagging accuracy of 0.001 ns. No clock is going to get there, but if we can get ~close enough, we can use a procedure called fringe fitting to determine the clock corrections by looking at the wavefronts. (Does it line up this way? How about this way? How about now? Yes, it's as laborious as it sounds, but computers, eh.) This is all in the calibration of data, before we do the Fourier inversion to create images - the magic of radio interferometry is that we can record the signal to disk while preserving phase. Optical photons can not be recorded and played back with phase preserved - optical interferometry has to split up the photon streams and send different parts to be correlated against streams from other telescopes, so you run out of signal quickly. Meanwhile, we can record radio waves at the 27 VLA dishes, say, and play them back for correlation on all 27*26/2 = 354 baselines, no problem. That's why radio VLBI is a thing, but not optical VLBI. Even as a professional radio astronomer, the underlying physics is deep and almost magical.
- acqq 8y agoThanks! > the magic of radio interferometry is that we can record the signal to disk while preserving phase. Optical photons can not be recorded and played back with phase preserved Why is that for the optical photons, when it’s “deeper” than just a higher frequency as you answered elsewhere?
- ummonk 8y agoI can’t speak to any physical limitations that this poster seems to be speaking to (I only studied physics theory so I’m not too sharp on the details of lab / experimental devices / apparatuses) but I would guess intuitively that a fundamental limitation is that radio tends to be more coherent, so you aren’t relying on individual photons but rather aggregating a bunch of photons to measure a wave. In contrast, optical light tends to be incoherent (unless from a laser), so you have to measure individual photons and they aren’t really correlated with each other (so interferometry doesn’t work).
- hinkley 8y ago... and the tectonic plates move, and that fucking delivery truck for the people down the road keeps going past...
- enriquto 8y agoBouman's 2014 PhD thesis is refreshingly readable: https://people.csail.mit.edu/klbouman/pw/papers_and_presentations/thesis.pdf https://people.csail.mit.edu/klbouman/pw/papers_and_presenta... Everybody can understand, at least the introduction. The author treats two related problems. The first is the well-known (today) integration of data from several separate antennae. The second is the problem of recovering an image of an object from the light reflected on a white wall. They are formally quite close, and the underlying math is, at many points, the same.
- joshvm 8y agoPrevious HN discussion about seeing round corners: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17902177 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17902177
- SiempreViernes 8y agoBouman worked on image reconstruction from the reduced data, not the combination of the antennae data streams into the raw visibilities.
- JshWright 8y agoDid the GP comment get edited? I don't see how your comment is relevant.
- SiempreViernes 8y agoFor me it still says: "The author [did] integration of data from several separate antennae."
- JshWright 8y agoYou can't just elide the verb there... The comment says the author "treats two related problems" in the paper, one of them being the integration of data. Is that not true? The paper certainly covers that topic.
- PopePompus 8y agoIf you took the straw from a Big Gulp (1/4 inch in diameter) and made the straw 20,000 miles long, then looked at the sky through that straw, the patch of sky you'd see would be the size of the shadow of the M87 black hole.
- robin_reala 8y agoWhich is 6.5mm / 32,000km approximately.
- hanselot 8y agoBased on the commit history of the repository they created on Github, it would appear that the reason it was so difficult, was largely due to their lack of gender diversity. Only 2 months with a differently-genitaled member and they were able to achieve this marvel.
- benj111 8y agoSo its kind of touched on in the lensing part, but gravity acts on light. So the black hole is slowing down the light travelling towards us.... But the speed of light is a constant so... 'time' is slowed down? So does the mean that the light is 'older' than the 54 million years it took to reach us? I'm over 50% sure there's a flaw in my reasoning somewhere here...
- kl4m 8y agoThe light is redshifted when it "climbs out" of a strong gravity field but still moves through space at a constant speed. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravitational_redshift https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravitational_redshift
- benj111 8y agoOk that makes sense. 2nd stupid question: I though gravity acting on light was a 'light as particle' thing, rather than 'light as wave' thing? If that were the case gravity acting on light as particle manifesting in light as wave doesn't seem consistent.
- simonh 8y agoI think most of the time it's best to think in terms of waves, but every now and then they exhibit particle-like behaviour. Any such attempt at simplification hits problems though. I think the best approach is to be pragmatic and simply follow the observations and what the experiments tell us rather then force it into one paradigm or the other and complain when it doesn't make sense. This is sometimes referred to as the "Shut up and do the math" approach.
- SiempreViernes 8y agoA photon being a particle or wave is mainly about pedagogical convenience, it is neither but has properties of both.
- saalweachter 8y ago
- lordnacho 8y agoSo if it's a matter of increasing the effective aperture, does that mean we can launch some spaceships and do the same trick with an arbitrarily large interferometer?
- joshvm 8y agoYes, in theory. The challenges are likely to be dish size and getting accurate enough positioning. Not to mention the downlink capacity required (and also onboard storage).
- SiempreViernes 8y agoWhat I know of space VLBI is that it exists, and in the one first hand account it didn't give extra detail. Do you think star tracking doesn't give good enough pointing solutions?
- joshvm 8y agoIt's not just pointing (2D) but also getting the baseline between telescopes. This is also being investigated for the LISA system https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_Interferometer_Space_Antenna https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_Interferometer_Space_A...
- SiempreViernes 8y agoWell, each antenna needs to be sensitive enough to pick up the signals at all. You also need very high data rates for producing interference fringes with 1.3 mm waves, which is probably one of the reasons why a satellite like RadioAstron works at longer wavelengths.
- maxxxxx 8y agoThere is a gravity wave project that wants to detect gravity waves though satellites. Probably a similar idea. I think the name is “LISA”.
- almostarockstar 8y ago> Once we set up an array of space telescopes throughout cislunar space (the volume inside the Moon’s orbit) we’ll get pictures of the SMBs in the cores of every nearby galaxy and that’s when the science really gets started. This gave me goosebumps. That's the kind of stuff that justifies a permanently inhabited moon-base.
- posix_me_less 8y agoHow? It justifies telescopes on Moon, not people on Moon.
- vl 8y agoIt justifies telescopes on the really high orbit, but not on the Moon: unless telescope is manufactured on the Moon, logistics of flying large telescope there and safely landing it are so complex, that it’s way easier to leave in Earth’s orbit and get same results from there.
- hughes 8y agoStationkeeping within a fraction of a millimeter is much easier when your instrument is on solid ground. It might simplify the platform to the point where descent into the lunar gravity well is worthwhile.
- Armisael16 8y agoBuilding on the surface destroys the entire benefit of the project. The moon isn’t large enough to give you the effective ape rather size you need - if it was you’d be fine on earth.
- hughes 8y agoThe point would be to combine this with the earth-based telescopes to create a 400,000km aperture.
- mises 8y agoHonestly curious: why did Bouman get the credit she did? According to Github, she didn't commit nearly as much code, 2.5k LOC vs 850k lines. I understand she migut have had a greater role in management etc.; my point is more that it was a team effort (which she reiterated). Is this a case of the media trying to "celebrate diversity" by unfairly cutting out the whole team which accomplished something incredible? Or is she just the public face and responsible for their media presence?
- eloisant 8y agoBecause that's how the world works, project leaders get fame and line workers don't. Somehow people are OK when Elon Musk gets credit for Tesla and SpaceX, Steve Jobs for the iPhone but suddenly if it's a women people will dig the github accounts.
- mises 8y agoI looked because I saw discussion about it elsewhere; I wasn't just digging. https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2019/04/katie-bouman-black-hole/587137/ https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2019/04/katie-bo.... "Bouman stood out as a role model for young women and girls working in or aspiring to jobs in male-dominated science fields. A round of stories celebrated Bouman’s work on the algorithms that forged a mesmerizing photograph from a vat of telescope data. She was a symbol of female empowerment". This is why people started asking questions. She wasn't put out there as a scientist who was part of a team that did something really interesting, she was put out there as a "symbol of female empowerment". In other words, she was advertised not as a scientist who made a cool discovery and happened to be a woman but as a woman who did something that happened to be in science. I don't like that sort of thing.
- baq 8y agoIf this symbol of female empowerment makes girls pursue careers in science then I’m cool with a bit of women glorification.
- AdmiralAsshat 8y agoThe real story is that my childhood was filled with lies, and every "photo" of a black hole I saw in gradeschool science books were really artist renderings.
- dennisgorelik 8y agoThat story is still true today: we only have artist renderings of the black holes and do NOT have real pictures. The data manipulations that this EHT team did to process their raw data - is NOT acceptable from the perspective or a correct scientific experiment. They got their images only when they allowed themselves to creatively interpret data from their telescopes ~~~~~~~ https://youtu.be/UGL_OL3OrCE?t=1177 https://youtu.be/UGL_OL3OrCE?t=1177 19:37 What you can do is to use methods where you [have] do not need any calibration whatsoever and you can still can get pretty good results. So here on the bottom at the top is the truth image, and this is simulated data, as we are increasing the amount of amplitude error and you can see here ... it's hard to see ... but it breaks down once you add too much gain here. But if we use just closure quantities - we are invariant to that. So that really, actually, been a really huge step for the project, because we had such bad gains. ~~~~~~~ They also deleted multiple critical comments from that video presentation. E.g. "Pratik Maitra" posted multiple comments that later disappeared.
- ajkjk 8y agoYou just sound like a loon if you take your stance against them in every thread on a random tech forum.
- dennisgorelik 8y ago"Every thread" is an obvious exaggeration. But anyway, what alternative do you suggest if I disagree with the evaluation of that "discovery"? Open public discussion is the way to go, isn't it?
- ajkjk 8y agoWrite a paper or blog post that convincingly makes your case and shows that you deeply understand their approach so are qualified to criticize its flaws. If you actually believe their result is fake, then it's not like the people you need to convince are hacker news readers; you need to convince other physicists who are in a position to agree with you and do something about it. Anyway if you go around pointing out things like "comments were deleted! they must be covering something up" you are just (rightly) written off as a conspiracy theorist.
- perfmode 8y agodoes anyone have a link to the original, full-size image of the black hole? i can only find 800x600 versions laying around. I want to know how large the original is. =)
- swebs 8y agohttps://www.nsf.gov/news/mmg/media/images/A-Consensus.jpg https://www.nsf.gov/news/mmg/media/images/A-Consensus.jpg
- tardq 8y agoWell, the thing about a black hole - its main distinguishing feature - is it's black. And the thing about space, the colour of space, your basic space colour, is black. So how are you supposed to see them?
- dclowd9901 8y agoIt seems like the main issue here was that it was very far away and comparatively small to other intergalactic features like, say, galaxies themselves.
- mamon 8y agoForgive my ignorance, but black holes are quite common in the Universe, right? Why couldn't we simply take a photo of one that's closer to us?
- Synaesthesia 8y agoThey’re not that common actually and hard to spot since space is mostly empty. This was pretty much the easiest one to detect.
- hombre_fatal 8y agoOne reason is that the closer holes were so much less massive that they were no easier to snap. Just compare it, Messier 87, to ours, Sagittarius A*: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_massive_black_holes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_massive_black_hol...
- Scouthound 8y agoThat blurry shot could be anything. I don’t buy it.
- frogpelt 8y agoHe makes an interesting statement: "Science advances when we’re wrong or surprised or both."
- dredmorbius 8y agoTheoretical advances require failures of existing worldviews. They either don't make accurate predictions or explanations, or they fail to account for phenomena. Science is the internalisation of expecting, admitting, and embracing error.
- dclowd9901 8y agoI’ll admit: I wasn’t a person who was wowed by the picture of a black hole. For all intents and purposes, it isn’t a very good picture. Reading this write up gave me a much better appreciation for the difficulty of actually just capturing that image, which is, I'm sure, what people wanted me to focus on when seeing the photo, but that sort of context requires a write up like this, and can’t be relayed through a blurry small picture.
- nailer 8y agoIf you'd like to skip the very lengthy introduction, search for "The reason this hasn’t be done before".
- dennisgorelik 8y ago"The new black hole picture isn’t really a discovery, but it is a stunning accomplishment." That "picture" is a stunning accomplishment in deception -- following the steps of Elizabeth Holmes and Bernie Madoff. This EHT team took white noise from their telescopes, then creatively converted that white noise into one of theoretical pictures of a black hole. ============== https://youtu.be/UGL_OL3OrCE?t=2242 https://youtu.be/UGL_OL3OrCE?t=2242 37:22 And you can notice like at the bottom we get really terrible reconstruction, just cause if it fits the data very well, because you know it maybe wants to smooth out the flux as much as possible and we don't select things like that in the true data. ============== They simply delete image interpretation because it does not fit the theoretical image that they want to see. How convenient. They call it "Calibration Free Imaging": https://youtu.be/UGL_OL3OrCE?t=1179 https://youtu.be/UGL_OL3OrCE?t=1179
- lisper 8y agoHere is Katie Bouman, one of the EHT team members, explaining it in excruciating detail: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UGL_OL3OrCE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UGL_OL3OrCE And an interesting side note: https://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2019/4/16/18311194/black-hole-katie-bouman-trolls https://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2019/4/16/18311194/bl...