6 ms·
996 is fine if you're a founder of a company. It's not okay for ill-compensated workers that will never become billionaires. We don't have much time on this pl
by echelon 8y ago
996 is fine if you're a founder of a company. It's not okay for ill-compensated workers that will never become billionaires.
We don't have much time on this planet. Why should he expect others to be droning slaves for him? People should enjoy what little life they have, not spend most of their time as cogs in a machine.
- BurningFrog 8y ago> It's not okay for ill-compensated workers that will never become billionaires. What if everyone who does it will become millionaires? What if everyone who does it understands the tradeoffs involved and makes an informed decision that you disagree with?
- m0zg 8y agoThat's like if you said "what if everyone won a lottery". You know full well this sweatshop bullshit produces very few millionaires, and millions of burn-outs.
- learc83 8y agoNeither of things are true, so what's your point?
- BurningFrog 8y agoAli Baba is the Amazon of China. It is enormously profitable. I assume that in return for working so hard, the employees are paid quite well, or else they would find better jobs. I guess the unsupported claim that they're "ill-compensated" out of the blue was what annoyed me.
- learc83 8y agoIt looks like the average senior software engineer salary at Alibaba is around $30k. That's well above the average annual salary in China, but it's about average for a software developer, and no one is going going to become a millionaire working for those wages. Also long hours are normal in China. If your choice is to work for one of 50 companies that all have insane schedules, it's hardly informed consent.
- BurningFrog 8y agoThis Fortune article speculates in much higher numbers for their stock compensation: http://fortune.com/2016/02/05/alibaba-stock-pay-disturbing/ http://fortune.com/2016/02/05/alibaba-stock-pay-disturbing/ If long hours is the industry standard, to me that is exactly informed consent. I mean, no one will be surprised by the standard workplace arrangement.
- learc83 8y agoThere's no way Alibaba is giving away 15% of their revenue in stock grants, so I'd take that with a huge grain of salt. Regardless the vast majority of their employees aren't going to become millionaires working there. >If long hours is the industry standard, to me that is exactly informed consent. I mean, no one will be surprised by the standard workplace arrangement. That's not what informed consent means--informed consent has to be voluntary or it's not consent. If 72 hour weeks are standard and your choice is long hours or being unemployed, it's not informed consent. The logical conclusion to this argument is that there is literally no limit on how bad you make your working conditions so long as everyone else is doing it. A century ago it was common to pay employees in company scrip and to not pay them enough to live so that they ended up permanently indebted to the company. It was the standard work environment in many places so by your argument all the employees freely consented to it.
- BurningFrog 8y agoYour consent argument makes no sense to me. We're probably too far apart to communicate, but I'll make an attempt: I agree that "informed consent has to be voluntary or it's not consent". But this is absurd: "If 72 hour weeks are standard and your choice is long hours or being unemployed, it's not informed consent." Note that you can replace "72 hour weeks" with "40 hour weeks" or "10 hour work weeks" without changing the argument. I'm guessing your silent assumption is that anything worse than your current middle class American expectations are by definition inhumane. This implies that poor people across the world can't consent to anything. To me, as long as you can freely walk away from something, you are there by consent. No other definition makes logical sense.
- stuffedBelly 8y agoThese two assumptions don't really contribute to the whole 996 discussion. Plus for many people, at certain stage, family/relationship/life/health becomes much more important than making millions.
- acct1771 8y agoWhat if everyone who used chemo was cured of cancer?
- afarrell 8y ago>996 is fine if you’re a founder Is it? You have production access to the company’s most important relationships. If you’re falling asleep in meetings or just unable to exercise emotional intelligence, that seems pretty bad for the company. EDIT: falling asleep in meetings is bad, not good.
- cbsks 8y agoIt is. Because then the overtime is completely self-imposed.
- afarrell 8y agoIf a sysadmin comes to work drunk, that would also be self-imposed. Would that be acceptable for the company? If not, why is it okay to come to work drunk-with-fatigue?
- Kirth 8y agoI always wonder about cases where a person's work depresses them as such that they start self-medicating (for example, with alcohol). Would that still be self-imposed, or a result of the circumstances?
- acct1771 8y agoWe always have a choice. It's just how easy the choice is that defines how good our conditions are.
- sgt101 8y agoI'm not an investor, but if I were an investor I would want my stewards of capital to be awake and aware and full on. Airline pilots and professional drivers (truckers) have mandated rest, for a reason.
- lazyjones 8y agoI'm an investor and former VC-backed founder and I'd like my stewards of capital, who are typically the best work force in the early days of startups, to work more than 40 hours. I'm sure that they do in the overwhelming majority of successful startups.