6 ms·
Haha, funny. I wonder why US and UK publications publish this topic over and over. There is zero chance that Germany will go back to the Mark. Ireland and Gre
by lispm 16y ago
Haha, funny. I wonder why US and UK publications publish this topic over and over.
There is zero chance that Germany will go back to the Mark.
Ireland and Greece are tiny countries. Their problems are totally blown out of proportion. Germany has a GDP of around 2.5 Trillion Euro. The EU has a GDP of 12 Trillion Euro. Ireland has a GDP of around 160 Billion.
The Euro being under pressure? How is that bad news for Germany's export oriented economy? It is not.
Second, the countries like Greece and Ireland under pressure? That's also great for the greater EU. It makes everyone aware that changes in economic policy are needed. Up until now in many areas the EU and Eurozone countries have different economic policies that are not really adjusted to each other. There is now some chance that this will change.
The internal problems in Europe have been caused by a few factors:
* the banking system took a lot of risks and also invented fancy new products (aka ponzi schemes)
* bubbles in a few countries, especially the housing bubble in the UK, Ireland, ...
* budget deficits for example in Greece, UK, ...
The financial crisis has exposed these problems. Giving up the Euro does not solve any of these problems.
The single currency market of the Eurozone has been given such a boost to the economy that very few people would be willing to give that up. The only real question that is worth discussion is how to repair the broken parts.
All other speculation in this area is wishful thinking and market manipulation from people who want to profit from the manipulations.
- jscore 16y agoI understand your argument that "it makes everyone aware that changes in economic policy are needed. ", however isn't the Euro basically a straightjacket preventing each individual country from setting its own monetary policy? For example, the Central Bank of Ireland can't set its own interest rates, and basically needs to follow whatever Germany decides. Or Greece can't devalue its currency to attract more capital, etc. I'm far from the expert but this has been my understanding so far.
- anigbrowl 16y agoYes. Good thing too, because monetarism worked very badly and led to continual economic instability prior to the ERM. Multiple currencies are an expensive inconvenience and an impediment to trade. Comversion fees are also a stealth tax.
- chopsueyar 16y agoHow did we ever make it to 2010AD?
- anigbrowl 16y agoIt's not impossible, just expensive and annoying for business or frequent travelers. When I was younger European currencies used to go up and down like yo-yos.
- pyre 16y agoThrough numerous wars, periods of famine, and economic hardships? I didn't get the feeling that the parent to your post was suggesting that the EuroZone was the only way to possibly survive.
- dpatru 16y ago> isn't the Euro basically a straightjacket preventing each individual country from setting its own monetary policy? It's generally a Good Thing for the people in the Eurozone that their governments can't impoverish them by printing money.
- yequalsx 16y agoThese countries are facing cuts to government spending and wages while increasing taxes. This causes debt to be more of a burden. Devaluing the currency would make paying for these things easier. Devaluing too much would cause problems as well.
- dantheman 16y agoSo your advocating stealing from those who are responsible (savers) and giving money to those who are reckless (debtors). Also, when inflation happens it normally hurts the middle class and lower class much more than upper do the lower classes not owning assets - stock/land etc.
- Retric 16y agoPeople who hold cash != savers. Plenty of people with significant equity in their home still have negative cash positions for most of their lives regardless of the amount of money they save. On the other hand people that short stock can have significant cash holdings without saving anything.
- jquery 16y agoTo the extent that home has intrinsic value, the homeowner is saving. To the extent it gains value against the dollar it transfers wealth from non-homeowners. In fact this is the express goal of the current Fed policy.
- yequalsx 16y agoIreland faces a situation of genuine societal collapse. The unemployment, lack of social services, etc. affect everyone regardless of who is a saver or not. I'm advocating that in a dire situation the best course of action be taken. In Ireland's case that would be devaluing the currency. There is too much public debt and raising taxes, lowering pay are not viable solutions.
- lispm 16y agoThe monetary policy, yes. But taxes are different for example.
- efsavage 16y ago"I wonder why US and UK publications publish this topic over and over." "Ireland and Greece are tiny countries. Their problems are totally blown out of proportion." I think you answered your own question, I bet if you asked a number of Americans which had the larger population of Ireland or Germany, a significant number would not know or would even guess Ireland. I also bet if you asked a number of Americans which had the larger population of Ireland or Massachusetts, a large majority would say Ireland, even residents of Massachusetts.
- jacobolus 16y ago> I also bet if you asked a number of Americans which had the larger population of Ireland or Massachusetts, a large majority would say Ireland I’ll take that bet.
- ximeng 16y agoTo save other people Googling, populations and GDP per capita (2009, USD) of the economies under discussion. All from Google apart from GSP (gross state product) per capita of Massachusetts, which is from Wikipedia. Ireland: 4,450,446 (51,049) Massachusetts: 6,593,587 (49,875) Germany: 81,879,976 (40,873) UK: 61,838,154 (35,165) Greece: 11,283,293 (29,240) The figure for GDP per capita in Ireland seems pretty high. Bailout is EUR 85bn which comes out to about 25,233 USD per capita.
- anigbrowl 16y agoThat high GDP # is the real estate bubble about to burst. Unfortunately most of my erstwhile countrymen (including the bankers) thought it meant spending power. I find it painful to read about, honestly.
- donalm 16y agoThat's because Ireland has low corporation tax (12.5%) so multinational companies export their profits there and artificially inflate the GDP.
- 16y ago
- Reality_Check 16y agoIreland has a GDP of around 160 Billion. Yeah this problem can easily be resolved by looking at Irelands GDP. After all, if Irelands economy collapses the UK won't be affected. Each individual Irish citizen only spends about £4k a year on British products & services. And hey, if the UK economy is severely affected then that won't affect the rest of Europe! Small population, small landmass, small GDP, the worlds second largest software exporter. Do you honestly believe GDP is a real indication of a countries ability to affect the economy of those it is surrounded by and nothing else should be considered? There is zero chance that Germany will go back to the Mark. The Germans have a history of spending silly money on contingency plans for things that will never happen. Oh wait, they don't. Grow up, look at the bigger picture and face facts. /rant
- lispm 16y agoYou can grow up yourself. Not the whole economy of Ireland is affected. It is just parts - banks, real estate, etc.. The companies are still there and their products and services are still valuable. When the EU keeps the banks from collapsing, makes credit available, then Ireland is still alive. To keep a tiny country like Ireland with 6 million people running should not be difficult for an EU of 500+ million people.
- ertyjhgvfdc 16y agoThe real parts of Ireland consisted of US companies tax havening there to avoid paying tax on their sales in the UK and Germany. And a housing boom that meant that more new houses were built than the country actually has people for! The traditional solution for Ireland will still work - every body between the ages of 20-40 simply leave the country. With EU passports they can work in other countries even if the US doesn't decide to let them all move there this time.
- JanezStupar 16y ago500 million people majority of which (except UK, Germany, France - to name only the big ones) are already living off EU welfare?
- 16y ago
- yequalsx 16y agoI think you should read about LTM and what it wrought. Look what Lehman's collapse did. When everyone is over leveraged then it doesn't take much to get a crisis rolling. If Ireland and Greece aren't propped up then Deutche Bank will suffer. It was German and French banks that lent to Greece and Ireland. Do you really think DB would survive if their Irish and Greek bond holdings become worthless?
- ig1 16y agoThe largest amount of Irish debt is actually held by the UK who aren't a member of the euro...
- yequalsx 16y agoYet, it is still true that DB holds a lot of Greek and Irish debt. If Ireland and Greece fail to pay this back then there will be severe problems for Germany even though they are small countries.
- lispm 16y agoSo what? The task is to keep the banks alive. Much of the rest of Ireland is still there. There are still people, buildings, companies, services, machines, ...
- jordanb 16y agoThe problem is that, early in the crisis, the Irish government took the bank debts onto its own books. So it's now in a situation where defaulting on the loans is no longer a matter of a large private institution failing (which is bad enough) but a sovereign government (and Eurozone member) repudiating its obligations.