12 ms·
I stayed in Guangzhou and was struck by how differently they'd handled housing compared to London or SF. Basically there were a lot of approx 35 story similar t
by tim333 8y ago
I stayed in Guangzhou and was struck by how differently they'd handled housing compared to London or SF. Basically there were a lot of approx 35 story similar tower blocks and most people used public transport/taxis rather than having cars. There's really no reason why London/SF couldn't do that apart from government policy. I live in London and like it but wonder if having all the property being some silly multiple of wages is the best way to do things.
This kind of stuff https://www.scmp.com/magazines/post-magazine/article/1761639/guangzhous-changing-face-city-its-people-cant-recognise-any https://www.scmp.com/magazines/post-magazine/article/1761639...
You'd want to put them in kind of nondescript areas to avoid taking out the historic stuff as mentioned in the article and maybe pay out 50% above market to existing buildings in the way so they are not too pissed off but it could be doable.
- lazyjones 8y ago> You'd want to put them in kind of nondescript areas to avoid taking out the historic stuff as mentioned in the article and maybe pay out 50% above market to existing buildings in the way so they are not too pissed off but it could be doable. And, presumably, they'd be as cheap as possible, leading to higher probability of hazards like at Grenfell Tower?
- baybal2 8y agoRead the backstory. Isocyanate foam maker lobbied cheaper rockwool makers out of the country in UK, with all blessings from the "elites"
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoThe council spent quite a lot of money on Grenfell tower, I seem to remember it worked out at £66K per flat.
- tim333 8y agoI was thinking more medium quality. A lot of London stuff seems to either be bad council construction or £1m+ extra lux.
- sgt101 8y ago24 floors (like Grenfell) will not happen again in London - at least in our lifetimes, foam or no foam, bad redesign or no redesign or one staircase or two. High residential is gone. On the other hand 8 to 12 floors is pretty dense and requires less surrounding space and infrastructure so works out quite well. What's needed in London is a change in the development law that mandates 3 good sized bedrooms, two baths and one large living / cooking area. This would provide liveable accommodation for families and would chop out the drivers for a house at any cost.
- holoduke 8y agoNo a law is needed that prevent foreign individuals or other entities owning lots of property for the sole purpose of renting it out. Half of London is currently owned by them. And the normale working class is barely capable of paying the rent
- sgt101 8y agoI agree about that law, Private Eye [1] has done a great job in making the facts about property ownership in the UK more transparent, I find it particularly abhorrent that property is being used for money laundering and tax evasion draining money away from some of the most needy in the world and then as a secondary effect making life difficult for average people in London and SE England. Actually buying to rent, while bad, isn't the biggest issue. Buying to speculate and drive up prices to flip for a cheap buck while driving others with less capital into penury is. The only good thing that Osbourne got through was the new taxes on property transactions, I think we need more - especially a tax on transactions done in quick succession. If there was a premium on a property being sold (say 5% of the transaction price) less than 24mths after it had previously been sold I think that would kill speculation stone dead. [1] http://www.private-eye.co.uk/registry http://www.private-eye.co.uk/registry
- icebraining 8y agoSo they'll need to create a bunch of shell companies?
- madengr 8y agoSoviet bloc housing; no thanks. That is the end result of government policy.
- kzcqt 8y agoThis is very classist. Everybody should have the opportunity of living in a big city, especially given that that's where the jobs are (and it's only going to get worse every year).
- Cerium 8y agoI have spent some time living in one of these tall thin Chinese towers. They have benefits that are not at apparent at first glance. Since they are thin every room can have a window and they have good airflow. Since they are high density public transport can be very close, and catching a taxi is easy.
- badpun 8y agoAlso, if someone 15 floors below or above you is using a jackhammer, your day is screwed. Or, if there's a child who is bouncing a ball against the wall in some appartment. The noises travel pretty well across the structure, that's why I prefer to live in a building which has as few units within a single structure as possible. Mine curently has 25, which is livable, previous one was over a hundred and was much worse in this regard.
- mikeash 8y agoThe difference is that nobody would be forcing you to live in one. Note that sprawling suburbs with identical single family houses and lawns controlled to the inch by HOAs are also the end result of government policy.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- reaperducer 8y agoHOA's are, quite literally, not government. They're an association of home owners. They sometimes act like government, but are still very limited in scope and power. And a good HOA or condo association (there are some) is even better than a government.
- rayiner 8y ago> You'd want to put them in kind of nondescript areas to avoid taking out the historic stuff as mentioned in the article It’s amusing to suggest there is “historic stuff” in SF, as there is in China. I saw a “historic” building with a plaque in Palo Alto. It was constructed in the 1900s! Like, after my grandfather was born. Historical preservation is stealing from the future. If I had my druthers, the opportunity cost of designating buildings or areas as historic would come directly out of the pockets of the preservationists.
- peteretep 8y ago> It’s amusing to suggest there is “historic stuff” in SF, as there is in China It’s amusing to suggest there’s historic stuff in China, as there is in Europe. I saw a “historic” building in China. It was constructed in 1600s! Like, 400 years after the bar I used to work in started. It’s amusing to suggest there’s historic stuff in Europe, as there is in Egypt. I saw a “historic” building in the UK. It was constructed in the 900s! Like, 4,000 years after the pyramids were built! etc etc etc That there’s older shit elsewhere doesn’t remove the historicity of anywhere else
- baybal2 8y agoBefore the revolution, Chinese used to count years in eras. Very few Chinese indeed knew how old the country was, except on a level like "Yellow emperor and co." lived a horrificly long time ago. To most, that was making the impression that "time is not actually going," and that people lived exactly like it was today for millennia. There was little regard for "historical things" outside of microscopically small class of educated elites.
- 0815test 8y agoThey still do that kind of thing in Japan. Indeed, the Japanese "era" is due to switch over when the reigning emperor's abdication becomes effective in May 2019.
- 8y ago
- crdb 8y ago> You'd want to put them in kind of nondescript areas to avoid taking out the historic stuff as mentioned in the article and maybe pay out 50% above market to existing buildings in the way so they are not too pissed off but it could be doable. Already exists, see e.g. Croydon. Yes, not in Zone 1, but 14 minutes to London Bridge by Thameslink, about the same time it took me to go from South Kensington to Westminster/St James in the early 2000s and probably without having to wait out a couple trains at rush hour due to lack of space within.
- microcolonel 8y agoOf course, if you had to deal with the incredibly poor quality of this housing for much time, you'd probably change your mind.
- reaperducer 8y agoI'm not sure why you're being downvoted. The construction quality in mainland China is terrible. I've witnessed a lot of it, myself, but this video was posted on HN a couple of days ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XopSDJq6w8E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XopSDJq6w8E As bad as that is, it only scratches the surface because they didn't actually go inside any of the buildings. It would be unimaginable for a building outside of the Chinese bubble to literally start collapsing upon itself after standing on its own for only three years.
- ubercow13 8y agoThe quality of housing many people can afford in London can be pretty terrible too, in its own way
- microcolonel 8y agoThe typical quality of newly constructed housing in these regions of mainland China is illegal in London, and increasingly alien to even the most wretched Londoner. It was international news when there was a serious fire in a tower recently in London, it's not news at all in some places.
- ubercow13 8y agoYes, of course safety is not comparable and is paramount in importance. However just in terms of the day-to-day experience of living in these places - I'm not so sure London has an obvious advantage.
- reaperducer 8y agoThere's really no reason why London/SF couldn't do that apart from government policy. Well, that "government policy" is the will of the taxpayers and voters who want to decide what happens to the city they live in and not just accept that living conditions imposed upon them by some bureaucrat. People in Guangzhou may be accustomed to living in Sim City, but that's not how it works in a democracy. Personally, I've been to all three cities, and I wouldn't want to live in Guangzhou, compared to London or San Francisco. People aren't robots to be warehoused.
- TACIXAT 8y agoYou frame nimbyism and protectionist housing policies as the will of the people, but I'd take a Chinese city with clean air over 3400 / month in a second. SF housing is broken, I would not put it on a pedestal of being some grand embodyment of democracy.
- reaperducer 8y agoI'd take a Chinese city with clean air over 3400 / month in a second. So go ahead. No one is stopping you. SF housing is broken I don't disagree, and that's also the case in most large cities these days. I would not put it on a pedestal of being some grand embodyment of democracy. I don't think it's grand, but I think there's more value to it than current generations understand.
- ComputerGuru 8y ago> that's also the case in most large cities these days. Chicago, as always, begs to differ. But no one notices it, it always flies under the radar which probably contributes to it's success in this regard.
- nitrogen 8y agoI've only visited Chicago once and really enjoyed it, but I suspect its reputation, whether vaild or not, for crime, cold, and corruption serves as a rate limiter on migration to the city.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> There's really no reason why London/SF couldn't do that apart from government policy. I live in London and like it but wonder if having all the property being some silly multiple of wages is the best way to do things. But Guangzhou has a much higher property price to income ratio than either London or SF. So, the policy you suggest doesn't fix the problem you raise. https://www.numbeo.com/property-investment/in/Guangzhou https://www.numbeo.com/property-investment/in/Guangzhou https://www.numbeo.com/property-investment/in/San-Francisco https://www.numbeo.com/property-investment/in/San-Francisco https://www.numbeo.com/property-investment/in/London https://www.numbeo.com/property-investment/in/London
- evancox100 8y agoBut the higher prices in Guangzhou could be due to a much higher "maximal use" value from allowing denser development. If the property is 2x as expensive but holds 6x as many units (30 story tower in article vs typical 5 story American midrise), then that's a win. That type of cookie cutter high rise is very common in many Chinese cities. They will plop down several of these towers in the same area, typically 10+ stories, with few burdensome restrictions on parking and elevators. Can't speak to London, but I was blown away when visiting SF just how little dense development there was in most of the city, and how little new construction there was even of midrise buildings.
- geodel 8y agoI believe it is per unit price not the whole building. It would be like family with 30 grand/year going for million dollar home. In China's case if would be an apartment accommodating 3-4 whereas in US it would be a large home in 99% of areas which are at max 20 miles from a city. I lived in city of Mumbai, India where median income is about $3K per annum and median apartment price is would be about $200K.
- alexandercrohde 8y agoWell, London and SF are historic and beautiful cities (at least architecturally). Part of the reason people WANT to live there is because they aren't full of skyscrapers and megacorporations. In fact, one of the defining traits of San Francisco is that it disallows chain restaurants, walmarts, etc. It also has many parks. When I see a stone church that has stood for 200 years in a city, I think it's priceless. If you don't, well there's plenty of cities that don't give a crap about aesthetics at all, and so they're cheap, and so they're full of poor people, and so they're full of crime.
- wbl 8y agoAnd SF isn't?
- woah 8y agoYour argument is that affordable market rate housing allows poor people to live in a city, which you don’t want? I think we’ve found the world’s most honest NIMBYist!
- ema 8y agoWouldn't it be much more efficient to require a minimum income/wealth of would be residents and so lower the demand for housing enough that all these rich people can invest into something more productive than real estate?
- thaumasiotes 8y agoYes; laws like that can get into trouble with US laws against segregated neighborhoods.
- justforyou 8y agoMegacorporations are actually the reason SF has become the real estate nightmare that it is -- but hey, no poor people. When a city makes decisions that don't favor its residents, it becomes an unaffordable haven for transplants, speculators and people who value the facade of the 200 year old stone church as opposed to the poor people the church was created to serve/bilk.
- didibus 8y ago> You'd want to put them in kind of nondescript areas to avoid taking out the historic stuff as mentioned in the article You mean like the Projects? I feel like that's been done before and failed.
- dmoy 8y agoProjects failed for a lot of reasons, not simply because they were high density housing.
- drugme 8y agoIt isn't a simple matter of "paying people" to get them out of their homes. You have to force them out via eminent domain. And not only that, rewrite your laws to extend the powers of eminent domain well beyond their current scope -- which in most jurisdictions almost certainly do not cover the scale of forced redevelopment and mass evictions you are imagining. You'd want to put them in kind of nondescript areas These neighborhoods aren't "nondescript" to people who have been living there for generations. And your apparent obliviousness to this central fact goes to the heart of the matter of why redevelopment politics are so contentious in many cities.
- BurningFrog 8y ago> It isn't a simple matter of "paying people" to get them out of their homes. You have to force them out via eminent domain. Nonsense. If zoning was changed so large housing buildings became legal, existing home owners in prime locations could become very rich selling to skyscraper developers. Or even build tall buildings of their own. All experience indicates that people with a chance to become very rich will take that chance.
- chillacy 8y agoI think it's everyone around who complains when the new skyscraper blocks their ocean view they paid $200k for in extra home equity.
- drugme 8y agoNonsense. You can say it's "nonsense" if you want. But the simple fact is, this idea you apparently have -- that a developer can deterministically "buy people" out of their property (or rental status), even assuming that that it had adequate capital on hand -- is just not how this stuff works.
- sologoub 8y agoTo make these liveable, you have to have very strong central planning. Many former/currently communist cities look like this with varying height. In Moscow for example, new apartments tend to be 25-40 stories high. However, they have large offsets from the street, are not built “shoulder to shoulder” with neighbors and generally developments from inner courtyards that are big enough to have parking and a soccer field. There’s also a phenomenon of what locals call “pinpoint development”, where some unscrupulous developer will try to stick a tower in these courtyards and ruin the setup for everyone. Contrast that with SF or NYC - you hardly have open plots of lands and everything is one giant wall of buildings.
- writeslowly 8y agoNYC does this through zoning regulations. Older buildings were typically designed with setbacks [1]. After zoning code changes in the 1960s most buildings became tall boxes attached to open plazas or low rise buildings instead. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1916_Zoning_Resolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1916_Zoning_Resolution
- sologoub 8y agoNYC doesn’t really accomplish this. Take a look at Google maps satellite view and you’ll see a huge difference.
- nine_k 8y agoMoscow did a very similar thing in 1990s and 2000s, allowing to build huge swathes of 25-32 story buildings. It allowed for quite accessible mortgages, with the cost of the buildings being moderate. It did allow for significant growth. It also put a lot of strain on public transportation.
- branchless 8y ago> wonder if having all the property being some silly multiple of wages is the best way to do things. You wonder? It's a disaster.
- mr_toad 8y agoHow many of your politicians national and local own multiple residential properties? If England is like New Zealand guess it’s close to 100%