9 ms·
How many holes does a straw have? [video]
- akvadrako 8y agoSaved you a click: one hole
- ahartmetz 8y agoWell, that was anticlimactic. Same as a coffee cup. Objects are topologically the same if they can be continuously transformed (no cuts basically) into each other.
- JshWright 8y agoA coffee cup doesn't have any holes...?
- chakkaveenu 8y agoThe handle is one
- JshWright 8y agoOh, I think that may be a language quirk. If it has a handle I would call it a "mug".
- golemotron 8y agoThank you. You're a genus.
- mrspeaker 8y agoSaved me a click, saved me from learning things: an analogy for today's convenient internet!
- JshWright 8y agoIsn't that the intuitive answer?
- ColinWright 8y agoI'd guess you're the kind of person who would pick up a murder mystery, read the first few pages to find out who was killed, the last few pages to find out who did it, then put it down and move on. Sometimes value lies in the journey, not in the destination. So you have an answer - one. Of what value is that? Not a lot. Those who watch the video will potentially learn a lot more than a glib and useless answer to an apparently pointless question, and for those who work in a technical area, perhaps knowing a little more about topology will come in useful one day.
- akvadrako 8y agoOne is the obvious expected answer, so the value is not wasting time with the video. It's like a murder mystery where the culprit is obvious from the beginning, but the whole book is spent talking about hypothetical angles. If the answer was 0, 1.5 or 2 in terms of topology, or anything else, then it would be interesting to hear.
- ColinWright 8y agoSo did you already know about persistent homology? Are you aware of its potential applications to machine learning? Did you already know why some people say the answer is 2? Consider all the people who (a) did not know about these things, and (b) didn't bother to watch the video because of your post. I'm sure you feel like you've done them a favour, but have you really?
- Udik 8y agoTopologists: the people who can't tell their mouth from their arse.
- paganel 8y agoI’m a Marxist on this and I’m saying that a “big enough quantitative change equals a qualitative one”, meaning that in the first example if you stretch that cup long enough in order to almost change it into a plate then the cup is actually not a cup anymore (because of the quantitative “long enough”) and trying to answer the question “does a cup have a hole?” by presenting as a counter-example a “long enough” stretched out cup (which is not a cup anymore) serves no purpose. The second example with the straw which can be seen at the limit as a doughnut is similar. Granted, I’m not a topologist, just an admirer of Hume and of his fascination for mathematical induction and of people’s blind faith in it (stretching a cup until it’s no longer a cup can be seen as similar to some mathematical induction operations).
- CPLX 8y agoThe Buddhists were on to this concept 3,000 years ago.
- ralusek 8y agoThe belief that quantity can have qualitative impact is being claimed under Marxism these days?
- mort96 8y agoHe was pretty clear that he's going to answer the question from a topological perspective though, not using any colloquial definition of "hole". "A big enough quantitative change equals a qualitative one" isn't really how topology operates (as illustrated by how, topologically, a doughnut is the same shape as a coffe cup).
- amelius 8y agoI was going to say "none, because the straw is made of a bunch of atoms", but he actually addresses this.
- frou_dh 8y agoA straw is a lanky donut (What did you just call me?)
- qorrect 8y agoA donut.
- dan-robertson 8y agoFrom a homotopy-equivalence point of view you can take a (solid) straw and make it shorter and shorter until it is two dimensional (an annulus). Note that this is a deformation retract (ie it is a “continuous deformation” but not the kind commonly used to try to explain a homeomorphism: a straw is like an annulus differently to how a donut is like a mug). The process can be done again, making the ring thinner and thinner until it is a circle. From here it seems reasonable to say that there is one hole in a circle so there is one hole in a straw.
- Grustaf 8y agoWhat do you mean by “until it is two-dimensional”? You can’t continuously change it’s dimension. It’s a two dimensional surface embedded in three dimensions, at least that’s how he modelled it in the beginning of the video.
- danharaj 8y agoHomotopy equivalence is even coarser than homeomorphism. A solid ball is homotopy equivalent to a point.
- dan-robertson 8y agoLet the straw be the following set: X = { (x,y,z) in R3 : |z| < 1, 1 < x^2 + y^2 < 2 } Change the numbers until this is straw-like enough for you. Define the deformation retract f : I * X -> X, (where I is the unit interval [0,1]): f_t(x,y,z) = (x,y,z*(1-t)) This is continuous and well-defined and retracts the straw onto the space f_1(X) = { (x,y,0) : 1<x^2+y^2<2 } Which is two dimensional. Now do something similar to make the annulus a circle. Now what it actually means for two spaces, X, Y to be homotopy equivalent is that there are continuous f : X -> Y and g : Y -> X such that fg is homotopic to the identity on Y and gf is homotopic to the identity on X. Now for maps a,b : A -> B to be homotopic, there must be some (continuous) map H : I * A -> B such that H_0 = and H_1 = b. So why does a deformation retract lead to a homotopy equivalence? Let R : I * X -> X be a deformation retract and r = R_1, Y = r(X) so r : X -> Y. Then we get a homotopy equivalence between X and Y by the functions r : X -> Y and i: Y -> X the inclusion function (ie the identity function). ri = id (definition of a retract) so done here ir is the same as R_1 : X -> X so just use the homotopy H_t = R_{1-t} to get the equivalence to id (R_0=id by definition of deformation retract)
- panic 8y agoI like how this video focuses on the question of how to model the world. People often hold mathematical results up as truth when they're really just the consequences of taking particular definitions. It's possible to reject any mathematical conclusion -- a straw obviously doesn't have one hole, it has two! -- and then work backward to find new ways of modeling that make your conclusion true. Of course, you'll probably find strange new consequences, like the fact that a plate now has a hole. But then you can go back and tweak your definitions some more, or even the entire premise. Maybe "being a hole" isn't a binary yes-or-no thing, for example, but a continuum from cup-like (very holey) to plate-like (barely holey). This process of finding strange consequences, fixing the model to avoid them (or include them!), finding new strange consequences, and so on, is really what math is about, I think.
- PopeDotNinja 8y agoI think it's valuable to understand that most of what we're taught is an abstraction for describing something. Using negative integers as an example, it wasn't until I was introduced to unsigned integers in C that it even occurred to me to wonder about what the heck a negative number is. It was then I realized how cool it was to know that I could make up my own version of numbers where there are no negatives. From now on, numbers all have a length and direction! Instead of +3 and -3, now we was 3 in-that-direction, and 3 in-the-exact-opposite-direction! I decided it was easier to keep using regular negative integers, but it was cool to realize someone just made them up many moons ago. Then I felt smarter and/or less dumb, and I started having fewer "I could never do..." thoughts after that.
- dwaltrip 8y agoGreat comment. I'll share a potential practical "definition" that popped into my head that is clearly different from the topological approach. If one starts with the idea of a hole as: "something that an entity can fall into or through", then it becomes very clear that a cup has a hole and a plate doesn't. An ant can fall into a cup from one side, but there is no way for an ant to fall into or through a plate. For falling "into" something, clearly some conception of "height" is important for this definition. Perhaps its related to being able to draw certain lines -- ones that are nearly parallel and of a relatively large length -- from one boundary to another surface of the object. For falling "through" something, I'm drawing a bit of blank right now, but I think there is some fairly simple definition that can clearly express this idea. I would argue the above is pretty close to what humans naturally consider as holes. --- EDIT: Thinking about this a bit more... I think we can simplify the above by viewing holes as "openings". This covers both cases of "falling into" or "through", and removes the distracting reference to gravity. It should be possible to come up with some sort of fairly practical definition of "opening". I think it has do with relatively sizing and geometry of the "cavern" that the hole leads to. However... inherently, there is no sharp line we can draw here, as the difference between a small scratch or dent and an actual cavernous hole is just a matter of degree. It seems, like many things in life, the distinction will remain a bit fuzzy and is not perfectly resolvable.
- lisper 8y agoThe problem with being topologically pedantic about this is that it is at odds with the actual English definition of the word "hole", which includes both toplogical holes, like a hole in your sock, and non-topolotical holes, like a hole in the ground. A straw has one sock-like hole and, locally, two ground-like holes, one at each end.
- ColinWright 8y agoThe problem with the actual English definition of the word "hole" is that there isn't one. As soon as you start to pin people down about what they mean you find that their intuitions are inconsistent and non-communicable. Part of the value of these sorts of studies is to see what the fundamental characteristics of things might be, and then look for mappings back to "natural language concepts". So what you're saying is a problem is actually an opportunity.
- lisper 8y ago> there isn't one Of course there is. It might not be mathematically precise, but it certainly exists, and it includes things that topologists don't consider holes. Henry Segerman uses a cup as his "straw-man" (pun intended) example of an object that may or may not have a hole. But what he should have used was a hole, as in a hole in the ground, the kind you dig with a shovel. That too is a continuum and not a dichotomy, but what you end up with at some point when you dig is, beyond any question to any competent speaker of English, a hole.
- ColinWright 8y agoThe argument on the interwebs about how many holes a straw has shows that there is no generally accepted usable definition of "hole". You can have lots of examples, and describe each, but the fact that I give a well-known, common object to a bunch of people and ask "How many holes are there in this?" and proceed to get a range of answers shows that there really isn't a working, usable, generally accepted definition. I suspect we've got different definitions of the word "definition".
- qorrect 8y agoWhat real-world types of problems can Persistent Homology solve ?
- ColinWright 8y agoIn private communications, some of the topologists I know have said that it might lead to new ways of working with machine learning. Most machine learning is to do with classification, and separation of collections in high-dimensional spaces. Persistent Homology talks about structures that emerge at different scales, and that includes aggregation and separation of collections. Early days.
- jameshart 8y agoOne perspective that might be useful is to think about the functional definition of a straw. The job of a straw is to enclose part of the two-dimensional surface of a liquid, then connect the enclosed region to an enclosed container with a lower air pressure than the surroundings. It kind of absolutely follows from those requirements, that a straw has to be some sort of shape with a boundary and a single hole. If it has no boundary, you can't connect it to the low-pressure reservoir; if it has no hole, it can't enclose liquid surface; if it has more holes, it doesn't separate space above the liquid into areas which can have different pressures (hence why a pinhole in a straw stops it from working). There are other forms that could function as a straw - you could have a straw that splits in two and then joins back up (topologically equivalent to a torus pierced by two circles - where a normal straw is a sphere pierced by two circles). Essentially you can take any surface which has an inside and an outside, pierce it twice, and use it as a straw (so you can't do it, for example, with a klein bottle - but you could do it with a trefoil knot). Put your mouth round one piercing, stick the other against the surface of the liquid, and your topologically advanced straw should work. This also kind of points to why it's confusing to talk about how many holes there are in a straw - because if you start with a closed 2D surface (like a sphere), you have to pierce it twice to make a straw. But in topology, the first 'hole' you add isn't a 'hole' at all (you can't loop a string through it, as the video says) - it just opens the closed surface.
- ColinWright 8y ago> ... if you start with a closed 2D surface (like a sphere), you have to pierce it twice to make a straw. But in topology, the first 'hole' you add isn't a 'hole' at all ... That's from one point of view, as the video says. From another point of view it is a hole. From that point of view, making a "straw" from a sphere requires two holes. The question the video then goes on to ask is whether that point of view is "the best" one. The conclusion is that it probably isn't the most useful - in this context. But in other contexts, if I have a sphere - genuinely a two dimensional object, all the points (x,y,z) in R^3 satisfying x^2+y^2+z^2=1, when I then punch a hole in it, it has a hole. It's now homeomorphically a disk, but it's a sphere with a hole in it. In this context, for this purpose. So I think you are overly-condensing the video and removing important points.
- 8y ago
- tedunangst 8y agoCan you make a straw from a Möbius strip?
- wazoox 8y agoIf you rotate it and make it a Klein bottle, yes :)
- ColinWright 8y agoAssuming you're using your "straw" to transport liquid, the liquid will be in contact with some part of the surface of the Möbius strip. But you can get from any part of the surface to any other part of the surface by "walking around" without crossing an edge, so there is no sense in which the liquid can be contained. There being only one side, I'd say no.
- sopooneo 8y agoRegarding his example with the scissors, I would think there are three distinct ways to loop the string through: each of the two he showed, plus a loop that goes through both handles. And I think by mushing the volume of the scissors a bit, you could show that all three of those are exactly equivalent. And then we might say that the number of ways you can loop a string is actually equal to how many distinct pairs of a holes an object has. It just happens to turn out that three distinct things allow three distinct pairings, whereas two distinct things (ie the two "holes" in a straw) allow only one distinct pairing. Working backward one step further, this does lead to the slightly unsettling idea that a simple solid object like a ball may have one hole in it. But I can actually get behind that. All the rest of the space not part of the ball is the hole in the ball.
- peterburkimsher 8y agoThe theory is interesting, but the engineering question is simple. How many times do I have to drill a hole? By redefining "hole" as the use of a drill, surface-mount components don't use any holes. Cups and plates have no holes. Filled doughnuts have one hole, where the jam is injected. Doughnuts with a less-fattening centre were made without a hole, whatever Tim Hortons would have you think by selling you "doughnut holes".