7 ms·
In a way this is great but in another way it's the worst. It's nice to have a practical way to use Bitcoin (or other cryptocurrencies) to buy things in the vas
by ilaksh 8y ago
In a way this is great but in another way it's the worst. It's nice to have a practical way to use Bitcoin (or other cryptocurrencies) to buy things in the vast majority of places that don't take Bitcoin.
On the other hand, I have always considered one of the main concepts with cryptocurrency to be the potential ability to avoid third parties taking a cut of all of your digital transactions. This turns it into just another way for big companies like Visa or Coinbase to get rich just on the basis that people need to exchange money.
The basic idea for me with cryptocurrency is that since it's our money we shouldn't have to give control of it to third parties just for basic usage. We have math, the internet, and plenty of computers. We should not need Visa or Coinbase.
- greenleafjacob 8y ago> the potential ability to avoid third parties taking a cut of all of your digital transactions Other than mining fees?
- sekai 8y agoMining fees are needed for securing the network, pretty reasonable.
- kristianc 8y agoBy providing KYC and regulation, Visa/Coinbase also secure the network.
- Karunamon 8y agoYou know better than that. He was referring to information security, not legislative compliance.
- kristianc 8y agoThey're one and the same thing. Compliance is a way of demonstrating that you have met certain data and information security standards.
- Karunamon 8y agoKYC has zero to do with information security, and there's a legitimate argument that much of the regulation is anti-competitive regulatory capture with the primary goal of preventing new entrants in the market, with "security" being a secondary concern.
- kristianc 8y agoKYC isn't some conspiracy to keep Bitcoin firms out - it's a vital protection against money laundering, terrorist financing and checking for identity theft. There are very real consequences in the real world when these checks get skipped or overlooked.
- Karunamon 8y agoNobody said anything about it being a conspiracy. It's not a conspiracy that entrenched actors advocate for rules they can trivially follow that just happen to kneecap upstarts. It's an expected and recognized behavior of large entities. That goes double when "terrorism" is brought up, which is a metasituational justification for nearly any conceivable rule.
- kristianc 8y agoThey aren’t trivial to follow - Standard Chartered were fined $1.1bn for AML non compliance, Swedbank and Danske have lost their CEOs. KYC is vital for the integrity of the economic system precisely because ML is as prevalent as it is.
- BenMorganIO 8y agoThat's not true. KYC is for preventing money laundering and terrorist financing. You do NOT want the RCMP/FBI asking why you permitted terrorists to use your platform.
- PeterisP 8y agoIt's as much fraud control as legislative compliance. From the perspective of consumers, considering a payment network as 'secure' requires fraud control - by ability to reverse fraudulent transactions and/or making it hard or expensive for fraudulent recipients to sustain operations.
- deevolution 8y agoIn terms of fraud protection, the bitcoin network is only responsible for ensuring a double spend will not happen. I don't think it should be the 1st layer protocol's responsibility to also handle chargebacks and fraud claims... these issues need to be settled by intermediaries who are willing and able to deal with these customer issues.
- tim333 8y agoWell, you can transfer cryptocurrency direct from buyer to seller with no middlemen but it's kind of clunky and requires both buyer and seller to be familiar with the same cryptocurrency. And then I was thinking of making a simple transfer app for direct crypto but then you think people are going to use it for illegal stuff and you'll get in trouble for facilitating drug dealing etc. Or you have the Coinbase/Visa route where it's all KYCed and regulated but not much advantage over regular Visa. Dunno.
- m-i-l 8y agoI don't see what is in this for the consumer either. If you are not already a holder, why would anyone want the hassle of becoming one, just to pay high fees for each and every transaction (e.g. the 2.49% "crypto liquidation fee" for this card) when you can get a cashback card (e.g. mine gives me up to 10% cashback on some purchases), and why would you not want your assets working for you until as late as possible (not until point of purchase as in this case but up to 5-6 weeks later when a conventional monthly credit card bill become due)? And if you are a crypto holder, why would you want to transfer custody of your crypto to Coinbase and make your tax return a nightmare (i.e. with a potentially large number of small disposals)?
- basch 8y agowhat card do you have and what do you get 10% back on?
- imustbeevil 8y agoNot him but the Discover It card gives rotating 5% cash back and a cashback match for the first year, making it 10%.
- bogomipz 8y agoWow, that's a pretty good deal. How widely accepted is Discover these days? I'm curious what has your experience been? Cheers.
- notyourwork 8y agoI’ve had this card for a few years, I rarely encounter someone who doesn’t accept it. (United States) I carry this card, the citi cash back master card and the amazon prime visa. Figure at least one works and I prioritize best reward. Also the categories they offer 5% on (amazon, gas, restaurants, grocery) are likely to take discover.
- 8y ago
- edpichler 8y agoSure, but a good strategy to mass adoption is bitcoin being compatible with global payment systems.
- jrjrjrjr 8y agodebit card, no protections against fraud by 3rd parties against your account. run away, run away.
- jqueryin 8y agoMy two major gripes are that it's first hitting the UK market and it has liquidation fees associated. I agree with the premise that we shouldn't need to convert to fiat but unfortunately we have to follow the pace of adoption. You could create a POS device tied to a service that accepts crypto-only via chip and pin or magnetic for the business. I'm doubtful many businesses are hearing from their customers that they want crypto only payments, however. I lead the development of a crypto debit card in the US. If anyone has questions, shoot me a message.
- dwild 8y ago> The basic idea for me with cryptocurrency is that since it's our money we shouldn't have to give control of it to third parties just for basic usage. We have math, the internet, and plenty of computers. We should not need Visa or Coinbase. How does this give them control? As long as it still use/depends on the Bitcoin network, you still have control. If anything, this show how cryptocurrency are amazing. Both the little guys and the big guys can use it, even you. Cryptocurrencies has the potential to solve 2 things I believe is extremely essential this day in age. - Everyone can use them - Every amount can be used I simply can't do a Visa transaction of 1 cent... simply can't... A child can't use Visa either. Both situations will happens more and more with the internet.
- zepolen 8y agoYou can't do a 1 cent transaction with Bitcoin either. The future is fee less cryptocurrencies.
- mhluongo 8y agoOf course you can- Lightning works today. If you don't believe me, our team hacked together https://ln.pizza https://ln.pizza as a demo of the tech.
- zepolen 8y agoIsn't there a Bitcoin fee to open/close a channel and then the fees involved sending via lightning nodes? Also the routing problem is starting to become an issue with the network at just ~5000 nodes - How will it scale to millions? Of course these are just the technical issues, there are others concerning centralization which always seems to end up in a monopolistic end game that end up with consumers having no choice but to pay.
- dwild 8y agoThis is exactly why I used "cryptocurrencies" instead of Bitcoin. Cryptocurrencies has the potential to solve it, it doesn't means that they all do.
- antpls 8y ago> We should not need Visa or Coinbase. We need them because of legal limitations, not technical ones IMHO, at the end of the day the biggest challenge is not technical, but rather it's to change the laws which were made to support the current system, to protect established actors, and to protect their interests