4 ms·
> So, by that interpretation, we don't have much of a right to privacy. Not in terms of DNA, no. We leave traces of our DNA wherever we go, and if someone take
by Wowfunhappy 8y ago
> So, by that interpretation, we don't have much of a right to privacy.
Not in terms of DNA, no. We leave traces of our DNA wherever we go, and if someone takes the time to read it, they'll learn what they learn.
What is the alternative? Outlaw DNA sequencing? Only allow it if you know the owner? Even if it's on my property?
> I'm not saying you're with them.
Then how would you know every other place the person went that day? Either they told you (not a privacy violation, they told you), or you were with them. Or you installed a hidden camera, in which case the data was clearly stolen and wholly unlike when someone knowingly shares contact information (which was how this analogy originated).
We're in agreement about memory recording, so no comment on those points! :)
- cbsmith 8y ago> Not in terms of DNA, no. We leave traces of our DNA wherever we go, and if someone takes the time to read it, they'll learn what they learn. Which also means you don't have a way of preventing all your movements from being followed, much of your health information being public knowledge, etc. > What is the alternative? Outlaw DNA sequencing? Only allow it if you know the owner? Even if it's on my property? The alternative is to establish rules and restrictions for circumstances for when DNA sequencing can be done... In fact, we already have some rules about that. You might think legal restrictions are ridiculous or impractical, but are they any more ridiculous or impractical than say copyright protections in an era when the copying & distribution of data is so frictionless and legitimately necessary? > Then how would you know every other place the person went that day? So many different ways... Tracking their DNA trail. Having a drone follow them as they move. Hacking their phone over bluetooth (hey, it's just emitting low power radio signals, are you going to ban that? ;-). Touching them with some radioactive tracer and then following its trail. Tracking radio transmissions from their phone. Planting a GPS tracker on them. Running a retargeting ad campaign and collecting the logs. Track their mass & its movements by analyzing how it alters the flow of neutrinos. :-)
- GrinningFool 8y ago> Or you installed a hidden camera, in which case the data was clearly stolen I think this is more analogous to the present situation. Facebook has a public 'camera' - they record you every time you're on their site. It's up to them if they want to share what you did on their site - that data belongs to both of you. But their camera is also on every site that you visit that pulls in FB resources - I would consider this a hidden camera. When FB shares this data, they're sharing the composite recording of their one public and many, many hidden cameras.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoSure, and this is a legitimate problem. But it's not what was being discussed in this thread. We got here by talking about Facebook collecting contact info that someone else uploaded to them. This, to me, is not analogous to a hidden camera. If I give my contact info to a friend, and that friend uploads contact information to Facebook, nothing was stolen from me.
- stevenicr 8y agoThis could be true and false in some circumstances I think. For example if I give a phone number to someone and specifically ask them not to share it, and in another situation where I allow a photo to be taken with the express terms that it is not shared online or with any other person... and then someone installs an app like messenger and that app sucks in all contact info and starts uploading photos in the background - sure you could say that they gave permission to share all that data, but I think a majority of people are not understanding what all those permissions mean. I believe there are a lot of people who have expectations in the way that apps would use data and they are being duped partially by group trust trust / ignorance. I have spoken to many people who do not understand the terms of use for instagram, and after discussions about such they start to question if they are going to allow their children to continue to use it. I think this is common with many apps and web sites - people have an expectation that video of them taken at target is going to used in certain ways that maintain privacy - not that target it going to be taking images and videos of their kids and selling it off to people behind their back. These are just a few examples where I think you could say technically it's true, but actually being are being defrauded or some other term, which is essentially stealing from people based on their ignorance.