3 ms·
I believe ANYONE facing a US court gets US constitutional rights. Otherwise we could run roughshod over any foreigners we wanted. (Yeah yeah, extraordinary re
by MBCook 8y ago
I believe ANYONE facing a US court gets US constitutional rights.
Otherwise we could run roughshod over any foreigners we wanted.
(Yeah yeah, extraordinary rendition, etc. I know.)
- krapp 8y ago>Otherwise we could run roughshod over any foreigners we wanted. That's the justification for (and purpose of) Guantanamo Bay, that the US can get around respecting (foreign and domestic) prisoners' Constitutional rights and obeying laws against indefinite detainment without trial and torture because it's not "technically" American, but Cuban.
- jcranmer 8y agoThat was what the Bush administration tried to do, but they were unsuccessful. The Supreme Court ruled that it was still unconstitutional, and the prisoners had the same rights under the US Constitution.
- JetSpiegel 8y agoAnd yet they are still there...
- chasd00 8y agoi think that's important but how exactly is that specified? Does the US Constitution to apply to anyone on US soil?
- roywiggins 8y agoIn the 50 states + DC + incorporated territories, the entire US Constitution applies to everyone. There are unincorporated territories, where things are a bit fuzzier. Certain rights apply differently depending on what citizenship you hold. You can be held and deported if you're not a citizen; you have more due process if you have a green card than if you are on a tourist visa. But all of those gradations of rights are in the context of the Constitution.