6 ms·
I have no idea why people don't call BS on news orgs that run 'exposes' on Facebook's ad targeting, when they target, track and follow their readers in exactly
by reaperducer 8y ago
I have no idea why people don't call BS on news orgs that run 'exposes' on Facebook's ad targeting, when they target, track and follow their readers in exactly the same way.
Three reasons:
1. In most responsible news organizations, there is a significant firewall between advertising and news. In two places I worked, the sales people weren't even allowed to go into the newsroom.
2. News organizations are not IT departments. A reporter is not involved in how a web site is built, or what goes on behind the scenes. There are different people in different departments for that.
3. Just because a newspaper does something bad with its web site does not make what happens at Facebook/Google/etc... any less bad. SV needs to get over the whole "But Bobby jumped off the bridge, too!" mentality.
- SpicyLemonZest 8y ago> Just because a newspaper does something bad with its web site does not make what happens at Facebook/Google/etc... any less bad. Absolutely it does. The prevailing narrative is that SV tech companies are innovators in this space, invading your privacy in ways that normal companies would never dream of. "Facebook engages in industry standard data collection" is a very different story, even if the industry standard is still bad.
- stingraycharles 8y agoIndeed. The minimum they can do is properly disclose their own position in this, because it makes them appear very hypocritical.
- big_onion 8y agoI think this is an example of Tu Quoque[1] logical fallacy. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_quoque https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_quoque
- o10449366 8y agoAre you just making an observation or do you think that disqualifies the parent's point somehow? If so, your comment is probably an example of the argument from fallacy fallacy. [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_fallacy
- chillacy 8y agoIf the parent had made the claim that it wasn't wrong at all because BF does it, then this would be relevant. However the parent's claim is subtly different: it states that the industry practice of data collection is not unusual, not that it's not wrong.
- keepper 8y agoThe even sadder part about this article... Buzzfeed does this worse. So it's not only the "pot calling the kettle black", it's someone calling someone out on things they do better than themselves. Reality is, that both Google and Facebook have cleaned up the AD industry ( but not enough, of course ). Data brokers continue to be the worst actors in the Ad industry.
- JohnFen 8y ago> Absolutely it does. How do you figure? It seems to me that even if the news organization does everything Facebook/Google/etc. does, that doesn't make Facebook/Google/etc. less bad. It only makes the news organization equally bad.
- psoy 8y ago"Less bad" and "equally bad" are incompatible statements, you're claiming both are true
- JohnFen 8y agoBy "less bad", I thought the comment was saying that Google/etc. actions are less objectionable. That's what I don't think is true. If I have misunderstood, then I apologize.
- aasasd 8y ago‘Less bad’ here compares one valuation of Facebook's actions to a previous one, whereas ‘equally bad’ compares Facebook's actions to those of Buzzfeed. So they can be both true (regardless of whether they actually are).
- SpicyLemonZest 8y agoOne of the concerns people raise is that Facebook, Google, etc. are lowering the bar. That they're uniquely bad at privacy, or uniquely brazen about violating it, and user privacy is becoming harder to achieve because of their actions. If everyone else also violates privacy in the same ways, this aspect of the narrative isn't true.
- djohnston 8y agoyes it does. you don't get to criticize someone for an action while performing the exact same action and expect your argument to have a shred of credibility
- clucas 8y agoNo it doesn't. The argument speaks for itself. If I murder someone in cold blood, then get up the next morning and call a press conference saying "Murder is wrong! We need to put a stop to murder!" no one would chime in and say "No way, murder is perfectly fine, you just did it last night!" Call the news orgs out for doing the same reprehensible activity, yes. But let's judge the arguments about which activities are reprehensible on their own merits.
- kostogher 8y agoYour analogy only makes sense if Buzzfeed stopped using the same practices. If you continue to murder people while shouting "murder is bad" then you might be correct but you're still a hypocrite.
- wool_gather 8y ago...which doesn't invalidate the argument. A charge of hypocrisy is a straight-up ad hominem. It might make you mistrust the person making the argument, but it doesn't say anything about the facts.
- roywiggins 8y agoYes, but the more important thing is that murder is wrong, not that someone's a hypocrite. Hypocrisy is the most minor of malfeasances. A smoker who writes a column that smoking is bad is still doing good writing.
- zwkrt 8y agoThis argument is very common against people with fringe political beliefs. "If you don't believe in property rights, why do you have a car?"
- luckylion 8y ago> In two places I worked, the sales people weren't even allowed to go into the newsroom. And the journalists in turn aren't allowed to look at their own websites when researching a story? > A reporter is not involved in how a web site is built, or what goes on behind the scenes. But they do talk to IT people when they write stories about IT things, don't they? I'm all with you that it doesn't change the story's correctness one bit, but it does question the self-awareness of journalists as part of companies. Unless it's a secret move to get people to focus on the stuff their organisation does which they can't publicly comment on for fear of being sacked (by the ads people, presumably), that would be quite different. edit: I'd love to reply, but somebody in their limitless wisdom has decided to time me out for whatever reason.
- reaperducer 8y agoBut they do talk to IT people when they write stories about IT things, don't they? Generally, no. They talk to people on the outside. Unless it's a secret move It's always amusing to me the conspiracy theories people have about journalism. These are people who boost their egos, their living, their careers by telling people things. The changes of hundreds of thousands of journalists keeping a secret about anything are pretty close to zero. fear of being sacked (by the ads people, presumably) This only very rarely happens (It happened to me once, and then the company contested by unemployment claim!), but only at very small organizations. Like where the entire newsroom is fewer than ten people.
- cbsmith 8y agoIf only journalists were trained to investigate and learn information from organizations outside their own...
- kristianc 8y ago> 1. In most responsible news organizations, there is a significant firewall between advertising and news. In two places I worked, the sales people weren't even allowed to go into the newsroom. Editor: "So your last screed about Facebook got a ton of clicks and shares, can you do another?" Tell me more about that firewall. In modern news orgs, you're selling the words next to the content, not the readership. > 2. News organizations are not IT departments. A reporter is not involved in how a web site is built, or what goes on behind the scenes. There are different people in different departments for that. Journalists are inquisitive, intellectually curious types. You have to call into question the ethics of someone prepared to write about something they have a good idea that their own company engages in. > 3. Just because a newspaper does something bad with its web site does not make what happens at Facebook/Google/etc... any less bad. SV needs to get over the whole "But Bobby jumped off the bridge, too!" mentality. This is just tu quoque. It's not exonerating Facebook at all (though Facebook typically have a deterministic data set to work with, which reduces the kind of shady practices they need to engage in with third party data sets), it's merely saying that you don't get a free pass on calling this kind of stuff out if you're engaging in the same kind of data gathering yourself.
- jonfw 8y ago> Journalists are inquisitive, intellectually curious types. You have to call into question the ethics of someone prepared to write about something they have a good idea that their own company engages in. So what is the ethical thing to do? Quit your job? Choose not to report on the unethical behavior? Escalate internally instead of externally? Write the story about the company you work for, knowing full well that you won't ever be published and it will end up being pointless? I don't think anybody wants to give buzzfeed a free pass, but I just don't see how buzzfeed's data practices reflect on the ethics of their individual journalists.
- WalterSear 8y agoThe cost of an action does not change its ethical merit, or lack thereof. People are responsible for doing unethical things, even if someone ordered them to.
- danShumway 8y agoIt doesn't make it any less bad, but it does make me question the motivations of the reporter. Either A) They know what their own website is doing and think it's OK, in which case there may be a conflict of interest. If that's the case, we should take any suggestions they have about how to resolve the problem with a gain of salt. or B) They don't know what their own website is doing, in which case they've done a pretty poor job researching their own article. I don't expect a reporter to be a tech expert, but I do expect them to be inquisitive enough to think, "when people say that advertising pays for reporting, might they conceivably mean the same thing as when they say that advertising pays for Facebook?" Facebook's privacy violations are bad. The hypocrisy of journalists calling them out doesn't change that. But in the privacy community, it should make us suspicious of their articles for the same reason we should be suspicious of a scientific study of sugar paid for by the meat industry. It should push us to double check their claims and question what their motivations are. These are people who's interests either happen to align with ours temporarily and that might change in the future, or they're allies who haven't done enough research to be able to make strong claims about what our responses and policy changes should be. It's not that Buzzfeed is wrong about Facebook. It's that they're not currently in a responsible or knowledgeable enough position to lead the conversation about Facebook.
- ehsankia 8y ago1. No one implied that this advertising was impacting their reporting. 2. They're reporters... if they don't know what's going on in their own backyard, there's a serious issue. 3. Maybe, but there's something ironic about the fact that this very reporting only exists because of these ad practices. This person most likely wouldn't have a job if the very practice they are reporting on didn't exist.
- rchaud 8y ago> This person most likely wouldn't have a job if the very practice they are reporting on didn't exist. Buzzfeed has picked up $496 million in VC funding [1] since its inception. It's a catch-22 where they could absolutely have done this reporting without ad-based monetization, but the potential for- ad-based monetization is why the VCs parted with money in the first place. [1]https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/buzzfeed#section-funding-rounds https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/buzzfeed#section-fun...
- areyouseriousxx 8y agoBack before the age of digital photography, there was a common issue with animal rights activists and photography. On one hand, photography required gelatin, an animal product, but on the other side, photographs of animal cruelty played an incredibly important role in spreading their message. It is an interesting line of thought to consider these compromises and when they may cross the line. Which means are justified by the ends? Which means are not?
- naravara 8y ago>2. They're reporters... if they don't know what's going on in their own backyard, there's a serious issue. The point is that it's not really their back yard. It's a different office on a different floor, possibly even a different subcontracted company than where the journalists are working. They don't have any more scope to be aware of the ad tech than they do understanding how a CDN works. By analogy, this is kind of like expecting a journalists in the old days to be especially aware of conditions in paper mills because their papers are printed on paper.
- 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- wolco 8y agoYou can't have it both ways. The buzzfeed platform is tracking/collecting. Either the reporter knows this and is ignoring it or is unaware which makes the article seem less creditable.
- kohtatsu 8y agoOr they know about it and were unable to enact change before publishing. Publishing articles with the same poison still raises awareness of the issue, though it would be best for them to disable ads on these articles, or to at least be upfront.
- mlb_hn 8y ago> 1. In most responsible news organizations, there is a significant firewall between advertising and news. In two places I worked, the sales people weren't even allowed to go into the newsroom. Do reporters not get any access to their analytics?
- musicale 8y agoThis is true: hypocrisy is not a proof of incorrectness. Smoking does not become healthy simply because a smoker told you it wasn't. On the other hand, if adtech practices are bad (and they are), then it is not only Facebook that needs to change.