6 ms·
There's a better video of the drones here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=prhDrfUgpB0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=prhDrfUgpB0 Google's delivery drones com
by michaelt 8y ago
There's a better video of the drones here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=prhDrfUgpB0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=prhDrfUgpB0
Google's delivery drones combine a multirotor design with fixed-wings. It seems like an eminently sensible design to me; fixed-wing operation will be quieter and more power-efficient, allowing longer travel distances (unlike the early Amazon Prime Air videos [1]), while hover capability avoids the need to parachute the load (unlike the current Zipline drones [2]) and provides a hover-and-land-almost-anywhere capability I imagine is useful.
Presumably the winch-down-the-load design reduces the risk of a user putting their hands into the blades - not to mention reducing the risk from customers choosing an inappropriate landing location; I imagine the drone can also jettison the winch cord if it gets caught on anything. It precludes delivering directly to apartment windows - but AFAIK no-one else is trying that either.
It's a pity they haven't released clear info on these drones' range, round-trip time and weight carrying capacity. Which are of course critical to working out the profitability of a citywide coffee delivery service.
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MR9PoBAssw0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MR9PoBAssw0
[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bnoUBfLxZz0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bnoUBfLxZz0
- cs02rm0 8y agoI wonder if the winch is to prevent people nicking the drone.
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoWhy would they? How often are delivery trucks stolen, for example?
- penagwin 8y agoDelivery trucks are hard to transport and store once they're reported stolen. It'd be more sensible to just steal the packages on the truck. The drone is "small", can be transported and stored without it being visible, so it get's lots of points there. Also I'd be concerned about stupid people/assholes and the shiny new drone. That said, Cameras+GPS, not to mention you don't want to steal the drone if it's delivering to you because it'd be kinda obvious.
- speeq 8y agohttps://www.engadget.com/2018/11/16/scoot-add-locks-scooters-combat-theft-vandalism/ https://www.engadget.com/2018/11/16/scoot-add-locks-scooters...
- michaelmior 8y agoDelivery trucks (currently) have drivers which does complicate theft.
- penagwin 8y agoYou know, I thought of a bunch of reasons why drones would be more likely to be stolen, but it never occurred to me that delivery trucks are accompanied by people.
- svantana 8y agoA better example could be electric scooters, which are indeed stolen sometimes, but apparently not enough to kill the various operator businesses (lime etc).
- oska 8y agoA better example might be shopping trolleys.
- phpnode 8y agoIt's to keep the drone as far away from landing hazards as possible - you don't want someone accidentally losing a finger to a rotor or the drone crashing through someone's window or landing in a location it's likely to get stuck.
- penagwin 8y agoYup it's a pretty good idea too. Pets, odd structures, children, terrain type, puddles, water run off areas. Not to mention you need to account for the wind. Drones can actually fly really well in wind, and while obviously they won't be flying in strong winds, you never know if there'll be a gust. In rural/suburban/residential districts the airspace is pretty darn clear above the treeline/buildings. Assuming you aren't next to a large airport, there is little to no air traffic, there's more wind but there's plenty of room, etc. I couldn't tell from the video, but I'd assume they drop the entire string to prevent it from being snagged.
- waltbosz 8y agoI saw the winch in the video and thought "what if someone grabbed the rope and used it to pull the drone to the ground", but then I saw the comment speculating that the drone could jettison the winch. I predict that when drone delivery services are commonplace, there will be a community of drone hunting enthusiasts.
- tlrobinson 8y ago> there will be a community of drone hunting enthusiasts. Probably not, at least in the US it's a federal crime: https://www.justice.gov/jm/criminal-resource-manual-2-aircraft-sabotage-18-usc-32 https://www.justice.gov/jm/criminal-resource-manual-2-aircra...
- Udik 8y agoHadn't heard of Zipline. And when I read it I imagined a simple cableway with small autonomous cars zipping along the line, possibly with branching points. I suspect it would be way cheaper to set up as an infrastructure and much more reliable than drones.
- penagwin 8y agoDrones don't really require infrastructure though? They don't require any setup at the physical locations, and they have a pretty obstacle free path above the trees. Zipline would require infrastructure setup on the scale of roads/telephone lines to be useful wouldn't it?
- Udik 8y agoYep. But it seems it would be rather cheap to set up an infrastructure made principally of steel towers and (thin) cables, and there shouldn't be many technological challenges. It would be probably faster, more reliable and energy efficient than drones, allowing for heavier packages. Of course at the cost of having to build an infrastructure, and maybe of a smaller, fixed number of delivery points.
- elithrar 8y ago> But it seems it would be rather cheap to set up an infrastructure made principally of steel towers and (thin) cables, and there shouldn't be many technological challenges. Just huge logistical challenges with right-of-way, construction labour, tearing up and making good the {sidewalks,lawns,gardens,driveways,etc}, actual acquisition of poles, ongoing maintenance and trimming duties, etc. Greenfield installation of infrastructure in public areas is incredibly complex.
- penagwin 8y agoI actually have a drone I fly around freestyle for fun, after seeing how truly versatile they are, not to mention how cheap, I'm really not sold on constructing more towers. The EMax Hawk 5 is 250$ and while I don't know how much it can lift, it's actually a VERY decent amount, if we're just talking about a single person's mcdonalds then no problem. The expenses come from making it more robust, making sure it has signal, etc. But those issues are mostly already solved, especially with a winch the drone can stay above the tree line, a single radio tower would have incredible range - or they might be able to get away with existing 4G towers. Now you're just down to battery life, and noise. The hybrid fixed wing/multirotor system seems to at least partially address both.
- bloopernova 8y agoIs it possible to use a drone with a balloon on top to help it lift more? Or does that make it too susceptible to wind? Maybe if we have to dome our cities and thus have no wind to disrupt the drone. I wonder if it would be cheaper to use a small electric self-driving car like a mobile version of the amazon locker?
- skykooler 8y ago> Is it possible to use a drone with a balloon on top to help it lift more? That's essentially a blimp. Due to square/cube scaling, blimps have less lift and more drag relative to their size at small scales than large ones. The extra power needed to overcome the drag would by far negate the power savings from reduced lifting requirements.
- genericone 8y agoIf there were a mini-compressor-pump aboard the drone, is it possible that it could inflate/evacuate a balloon on demand during hover mode? Is the economics of such a thing even possible?
- rubicon33 8y agoInflate it with what? Raw air? That would do nothing. Are you proposing that it could somehow hook itself up to a helium or hydrogen source, while hovering?
- brianwawok 8y agoNot saying this idea is worth the complexity (sounds over-engineered), but I am pretty sure you could make like a 1"x2" can of compressed helium attached to a 3' balloon with a simple valve to pop open and inflate the balloon. Think of those little air cans that you use for refilling bike tires on the go. Only weigh a few grams, holds a lot of air.
- jerf 8y agoYou'll experience the same scaling issues with whatever it is you expect to inflate with. You're going to have a lot of volume dedicated to the pressure vessel and not so much in the pressure vessel, because of scaling issues. And I'm discarding the pump to put it back, assuming we're just going to vent to the atmosphere when we're done. Things get worse if you want to pump it back in.
- oska 8y ago> There's a better video of the drones here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=prhDrfUgpB0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=prhDrfUgpB0 Mount Tennent in the centre background at 0:10 in the video. Tidbinbilla Deep Space tracking station is a bit off to the right (and behind a range of hills). I'm frankly surprised that they've chosen Canberra (the nation's capital) as a launch city. The degree of nimbyism in Canberra would be very high with a lot of people who are very good at lobbying and political action (it's their job). In the case of this particular project I see that as a good thing. I think delivering coffees by a noisy drone that overflies urban areas is an incredibly stupid enterprise.
- anitil 8y agoMaybe because it's a fairly flat city with very easy layout?
- oska 8y agoEasy layout, yes. Fairly flat? No. Adelaide, Melbourne and Perth are far flatter. Canberra is situated in a horst and graben [1] landscape with multiple prominent ridges separating the various urban 'valley' sections of the city. Don't get me wrong, I can see some of the reasons why they may have picked Canberra. Generally a population with a high percentage of early tech adopters. Houses set back from the road with easy landing driveways at front. Power lines run along the back of property lines, not along the street. Etc, etc. Just I think they underestimated the resistance they are very likely to experience and also underestimated the danger of annoying the actual lawmakers who live there. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horst_and_graben https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horst_and_graben
- Sophistifunk 8y agoThey probably chose Canberra as it has no state government, which is an entire monolith of bureaucracy to avoid, and in the NT they'd probably just shoot at them ;-)