12 ms·
Spotify Saved the Music Industry (But Not Necessarily Musicians)
- doctorpangloss 8y agoThe long tail is dead. The algorithm that was supposed to help you find it has killed it instead.
- mrob 8y agoThe long tail is more alive than ever, but algorithms have always been a bad way to find it. Instead, listen to personal recommendations on web forums etc. There are people who are passionate about any obscure micro-genre you can imagine, and they'll point you to the best of it. Bandcamp and Soundcloud are full of long tail music that's completely ignored by the mainstream music industry.
- mr_tristan 8y agoIt's interesting, I've gone back to Spotify from Apple Music primarily because I can easily find more interesting playlists from curators. I don't think Spotify has any kind of special algorithmic sauce, they just make it easy for people create and share playlists. It amazes me how most of the other streaming services try to turn everything into an algorithm, via "special radio" stations, etc. And yet, the best way to provide a long tail for music still seems to be basic web 2.0 - let the people make the content for you.
- scrooched_moose 8y agoThere's definitely some algorithmic shenanigans going on with Spotify on any of their auto playlists. Whatever algorithm they have decides that I absolutely love one specific artist and shoves them down my throat for months. For a solid year, any time I played a Daily Mix or let one of my personal playlists runout and it reverted to "recommended music", Neko Case was always in the first top 3 songs. Before that it was Iron and Wine. I don't mind either artist, but I have never chosen to play either one myself. I do like Spotify's curated playlists though. They are always a better source of new music than the automatic playlists.
- mr_tristan 8y agoRight, I'm not saying Spotify isn't trying out algorithms at all, but their algorithmic stuff doesn't seem much different from Apple Music, Google Play, etc. A lot of the "algorithmic" stuff enters into "lame" territory fast, where you see the issues like artist fixation, or "variations on a theme" where you get like 5 remixes or live cuts of the same song. The main benefit of Spotify is that I can just bypass the algorithms, and go straight to people. And that's really where the "long tail" effect seems to thrive.
- chewz 8y agoIn my humble opinion all discovery algorithms with all large providers are terrible. Instead of expanding they narrow down choices and never surprise me in a good way like some human curated playlist can. I had been switching between Apple Music, Spotify and Google Music in different countries. Currently I have settled on Google Music simply because Google practically abandoned Google Music so they are not so in my face with curated playlists and stations. On the other hand I think that there is opportunity for good (like in really working) AI engine for music recommendations.
- brycesbeard 8y agoWhat’s interesting is that these algos are trained on human feedback. What does that say about our revealed preferences in music?
- chewz 8y agoAs an anecdote I have left Apple Music after it had been suggesting to me at least 3 heavy metal playlists for 30 days. And this is the one genre I do not listen to. I had been clicking 'I don't like it' buttons hoping the AI will get it but no luck. So after 30 days I had enough and moved on back to Spotify. So much for human feedback.
- brycesbeard 8y agoMaybe you actually like heavy metal but won’t admit it to yourself ;). (Just kidding, but this kind of thing will be more common in the future, especially as we learn more about how little the brain knows about its own desires and motivations)
- rchaud 8y agoIf you let an algorithm script a movie, it would be a 2-hr superhero movie with extremely simplistic moral conundrums, that will cost $300m to make, but will gross $1 billion +. If the algo scripted a TV sitcom, it would be 5-6 mostly white people who occasionally hook up, break up, get married, struggle to conceive, and then everything eventually works out. Same goes for music. People have a habit of liking what's in front of them. Few are going to want to make the effort to find something that's more than "good enough".
- NoodleIncident 8y agoI don't know if this is (still?) true, but I've heard that user-generated playlists are their special algorithmic sauce, at least for "Discover Weekly". It's designed to take songs you're familiar with, look for them in other peoples' playlists, and fill the gaps between songs you already know about with songs that other people have filled the gaps with in their own user-generated playlists, but that you haven't heard yourself.
- mr_tristan 8y agoIt sure seems like the a lot of suggestions on Spotify try to find "similarities" based on things you've listened to recently. Makes sense that the similarities are very likely pulled from recent popular additions ... from curators. My sense is that is probably as good as it tends to get, unless you want to get incredibly creepy and start bringing outside personal information, e.g., associating that the 40-something living in Chicago may have an affinity towards Wilco. Personally, I'd rather deal with "meh" suggestions then have my music service track detailed demographic models of me.
- rchaud 8y ago> It amazes me how most of the other streaming services try to turn everything into an algorithm, via "special radio" stations, I think they do that because it's the only way to keep people from switching to rival platforms. Spotify's selection isn't that different from Google Play Music/Apple Music/Amazon Prime Music etc. There's also little in the way of community interaction on those platforms beyond "sharing playlists". SoundCloud at least has a system where you can comment on specific parts of a song. It creates a really interesting visualization of which parts of a single song people enjoyed the most.
- kurthr 8y agoYeah, load in all your varied collection of interesting indie tunes and watch them spit out modern pop covers as recommendations. It's surreal... almost like the training set was, "what will.make us the most money to promote?"
- zwkrt 8y agoI've always found the opposite, in that Spotify points me toward music I'm sure they are paying almost nothing for.
- longerthoughts 8y agoCan you substantiate this? Based on conversations with musicians I know in that long tail, seems like it's helped them get discovered but they're not earning a livable wage from it. It's not clear to me that they'd be any better off in the absence of Spotify, although I don't have strong convictions either way.
- criddell 8y agoIf you are part of the long tail today, then you are definitely better off now than in previous years where your market was local audiences and whomever you could reach via zines.
- zwkrt 8y agoIt seems to me like musicians have always been in a precarious relation to the economy, same as all other artists. The only difference is that for a brief time in the 20th century the average person was willing to spend money on music, unlike every other time in human history. Nothing will ever stop people from making music, and 99% of working musicians are making a meager living doing what they enjoy, just like always.
- tunesmith 8y agoThat strikes me as dismissing "progress" as a mere blip in human history. The reason the average person was more willing to spend money on music is because we improved matters having to do with copyright and licensing. Good copyright and patent law serves a useful purpose in encouraging people to create or innovate in a system that would otherwise discourage doing so.
- wolco 8y agoComplete nonsense. Physical media played a part. Before the walkman you had to share music with everyone in the room. The identity association that began in the 60s. The rise of popstars, the Beatles, cds, etc. Nothing to do with copyright.. more people were breaking copyright during this period. In fact the people who broke copyright spent the most on music. Everyone broke copyright by recording songs from the radio. The first mass market recording devices were everywhere.
- shmerl 8y agoThat's nonsense. What improved are means of communication and distribution. I.e. Internet. You can reach a lot more people. Copyright and patents have nothing to do with it.
- zwkrt 8y agoIt wasn't progress, it was change.
- wwweston 8y ago> Nothing will ever stop people from making music The funny thing is how true this statement is, and yet how often it's deployed as if that means nobody needs to further consider or negotiate the present economics. How would one establish the idea that average person wasn't willing to spend money on music before the 20th century? Because I'd expect as long as there's been instruments and money, there's been some form of economic participation. But let's say it's true -- does that really direct a normative discussion on current economics? Because a hell of a lot of things about human society after industrialization have only been true for a brief time in human history, and that's no clear indicator of whether or not they have value. Here's a better standard: how well does what we're doing support people who are in a position to make musical contributions that people value? Recording sales fared pretty well by that standard, although there was the problem of predatory middlemen. Streaming revenues seem to have the same problem, and don't fare anywhere near as well.
- matthoiland 8y agoAs an amateur musician I still make most of my monthly sales from iTunes. Streaming pays so little, unless you're a big name – which incentivizes the big labels while squeezing the smaller artists. Early platform like Lala (bought by Apple) had a cool model – $0.10 per song, but you can only stream it. Ownership was still there, and artists were paid equally per sale. Nevertheless, getting your music distributed is easier today than ever, and I'm sure all artists are grateful for that.
- criddell 8y ago> Streaming pays so little, unless you're a big name Are you saying big acts get more per stream? Also, I'd love to hear what you think about how the incentives from Spotify et al are changing music itself. From what I understand, a play isn't registered until a certain portion of the song has been played. This hurts songs that have a slow build and so hooks are being pushed right up front. Do you think it's homogenizing music to any degree?
- jasode 8y ago>Are you saying big acts get more per stream? The big acts may get more per stream because of 2 factors: 1) the Spotify allocation algorithm of subscription payments works top-down from the most popular artists' percentage of total streams instead of bottom-up from individuals' play logs. (The top comment of a previous HN thread discusses this.[1]) 2) Some record labels have (had?) negotiated sweetheart deals with Spotify for different revenue share and stream payouts. So a Universal/Sony/Warner major label with a roster of desirable artists that Spotify wanted may get slightly more per stream than an unknown indie label with no leverage. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9226497 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9226497
- criddell 8y ago> Some record labels have (had?) sweetheart deals with Spotify That reminds me of something else I've been thinking about. The labels all have substantial equity stakes in Spotify. It feels like that could be a massive conflict of interest or maybe a collusion problem. Why should the labels push for higher streaming fees when that could hurt Spotify's stock price which would hurt the label's own balance sheets?
- billmalarky 8y agoPlatforms like Spotify, YouTube, etc, are a marketing channel - not a revenue channel. They can be used effectively to develop an audience, but not to monetize it. For example see Pusheen the cat. Started off as a tumblr web comic/character and now generates millions in merchandising revenue: https://www.ndtv.com/world-news/how-an-internet-cat-craze-became-a-toy-empire-1287225 https://www.ndtv.com/world-news/how-an-internet-cat-craze-be...
- geden 8y agoNot true for Spotify, if you are regularly racking up millions of plays ie you are hitting editorial playlists, then Spotify is very lucrative. Good Spotify stats also signals to promoters that you are a good to book, so it boosts live income. I'd agree on YouTube however, artists I work with see very little income from YouTube, which is quite sickening and problematic for artists given how much of the younger demographic use YouTube as a primary source of music.
- wwweston 8y ago> Platforms like Spotify, YouTube, etc, are a marketing channel - not a revenue channel Which would be cool, if Spotify wasn't meant to be a replacement for a revenue channel.
- lmpostor 8y agoYou can't replace something that is dead.
- wwweston 8y agoRevenues from US digital recorded music sales steadily rose from the introduction of iTunes up into the billions through at least 2012. Maybe 2013/14-ish. I think at one point it'd actually matched 90s CD sales revenue, though I may not recall correctly. That was hardly "dead." There's this narrative that goes around "oh, yeah, the internet happened, copies are cheap, no one was ever going to buy music again" ... and it's not true. The truth is that there was a thriving digital recording sales growing up to take the place of physical recording sales. And buffet streaming kneecaped it.
- shmerl 8y agoI prefer to buy, not rent music. Luckily we have enough DRM-free music stores around that simply sell you music files. FLAC is the best option.
- kilroy123 8y agoLike what stores?
- ApolloFortyNine 8y agoBeatport and Bandcamp, at least. Though obligatory fuck Beatport, they only give you 24 hours to download what you buy and then the only way to download again is to rebuy, or beg. Even a FLAC is only ~30MB, there's no need to be this cheap.
- ry-n 8y agohttps://bandcamp.com/ https://bandcamp.com/ is really wonderful if you're asking about music in general and not artists hitting the billboard charts. However, as it supports free listening there isn't a barrier to searching around and discovering new things. If you want some good coding music for the day I'd suggest starting with https://wanderband.bandcamp.com/ https://wanderband.bandcamp.com/
- Semaphor 8y agoI love bandcamp. For 9 years now I've been getting almost all my music (I think maybe one or two albums from Amazon in-between) from them. I can get straightforward notifications, I can get whatever format I want and I can stream the whole album as much as I want before buying it (though I never listened to one fully before buying it – or deciding against it). And not to forget that I can often choose my own price (when I was a student I sometimes paid less, nowadays I usually pay a bit more)
- shmerl 8y agoYep, Bandcamp is my favorite store for music as well.
- kristianc 8y agoIt's interesting how different types of music have thrived through the streaming economy. Hip hop is huge on Spotify, where it struggled for radio play and sales before because commercial radio is so conservative (in the sense of risk-averse). Then there's the whole Billie Eilish thing: huge on Spotify, almost no radio play at all. On the other hand, there are Billboard 100 artists who are more or less absent from the streaming landscape. Some sell lots of albums but aren't on the streaming charts at all. It's probably not as simple as saying that streaming is only good for established artists, but bad for the long tail. For some of the previous long tail, it's been very good. And for some of the oldies, it's been phenomenal - Spotify enables them to monetize their back catalogue with near zero promotion or distribution costs, year round.
- linuxftw 8y ago> Hip hop is huge on Spotify, where it struggled for radio play and sales before because commercial radio is so conservative. What? See how many rap albums are in this list [1]. 1: https://www.billboard.com/archive/charts/2000/top-album-sales https://www.billboard.com/archive/charts/2000/top-album-sale...
- kristianc 8y agoThere's a bit of cherry picking going on choosing a year where Eminem and Jay-Z were at their peak. 2000 was probably one of the top three years in the last 20 or so for hip hop. Scheduling Eminem for radio play while he is arguably the biggest artist on the planet is not really going out on a limb.
- linuxftw 8y agoI picked year 2000 because it was well before streaming. There were dedicated rap/hip-hop stations for well over a decade at point. > Scheduling Eminem for radio play while he is arguably the biggest artist on the planet is not really going out on a limb. I mean, you can't be the biggest artist on the planet without some level of main-stream support in the first place. To say that hip-hop became more popular due to streaming is just obviously nonsense.
- wwweston 8y agoIf something hasn't "necessarily" saved musicians, then there's not much of a defense of whatever else it's done for the industry. And any idea that services like Spotify were just the only way forward to revenue is one that thoroughly ignores the growth of digital recording sales that took place independent of it (not to mention what they may well have been like if it'd never happened). Buffet streaming services marry the worst of piracy and the old-school middleman capture. They give the illusory impression that you're actually rewarding value.
- ninth_ant 8y ago> Buffet streaming services marry the worst of piracy and the old-school middleman capture. You have an interesting perspective... as a consumer for me Spotify marries the best of those two worlds. I get the music I want and discoverability, quality, and ease of use is extremely good.
- wwweston 8y agoYou're talking experience rather than economics. The consumer experience of Spotify is certainly much more convenient and pleasant than the experience of P2P piracy. And it turns out that can be true even while the economics of buffet streaming services simultaneously effect the drastic cuts in first-order revenue that piracy brought directing it instead to distributor and label.
- ghaff 8y agoShort-term experience anyway. Long-term experience requires remaining a subscriber ad infinitum. I admittedly come from the perspective of someone who prefers to own music that I care about. Which, in turn, is very influenced by the fact that I had a very large digital/digitized music catalog before streaming came along so incremental purchases aren't very expensive.
- mediascreen 8y agoI think there is a difference between collectors and people who just want to listen to music. I gladly pay Spotify each month to NOT have to manage a collection of physical or digital music. I gladly pay HBO and Netflix as well, but it seems no matter what I pay, I cant get the same movie/series coverage that Spotify provides for music.
- thegayngler 8y agoI would argue that most musicians should be salaried employees making 80-150k. The label would then handle everything else. The musicians only need to focus on creation and performing. I have always been interested in the problem Spotify is trying to solve for. However, I think they've only solved half the problem. The other half of the problem is solved by putting long tail musicians on a salary and then they can graduate out of that once they achieve a certain level of commercial success. (Why is this being downvoted?) It is on topic and is not at all hostile.
- rhizome 8y agoThis is essentially the pre-Beatles model we saw in Tin Pan Alley and the Brill Building. Carole King's biggest hits were written for like $75/week. It declined as musicians started writing and recording their own songs and being self-contained creative acts, not to mention the, shall we say, "unfair equity strategies" the record labels used. That is, it's all well and good until the bosses take all the big money.
- thegayngler 8y agoThat's interesting. I didn't know this but I think this model should be brought back for most cases I think safe guards can be put into place to guard against "unfair equity strategies".
- rhizome 8y agoIt was the dominant musicwriting business model from the sheet-music era until about 1962.
- kevincennis 8y agoThe problem with this is that it requires really successful artists to work for far less than the value they create, which they won't – because they know they could make far more money independently. And without the top performers subsidizing the salaries of everyone else, the whole thing falls apart.
- rob74 8y agoThe thing that fascinates me about Spotify and other streaming services is that the people who weren't willing to fork out 15$ for a CD in the past are now willing to pay 10$ every month for... pretty much nothing at all, if you think about it?!
- dmitriid 8y ago> willing to pay 10$ every month for... pretty much nothing at all A collection of 14 million songs doesn't sound like "nothing at all"
- codetrotter 8y ago> pretty much nothing at all Except for instant access to what is probably the biggest collection of music in the world. I don’t mean to be snarky but, have you ever used Spotify? It’s a godsend.
- renjimen 8y agoYou're getting a service? I used to buy a CD a week and listened to less music than I do now with Spotify for a quarter of the cost. Yes, it's nice to have a physical collection but I'd rather discover more new music
- melq 8y ago>For a company that doesn’t really make anything People think technology just develops itself huh?
- kraftman 8y agoWhat technology are they developing that people are asking for?
- dmitriid 8y agoSo, Spotify pays 70% of revenue to labels. In the end it's labels who pay the artists. Why does no one, literally no one ask: where the hell does that money disappear? Everyone is busy writing 20,000-word essays on how streaming is bad for artists. Maybe, just maybe, it's not streaming that's bad but the labels and their agreements with both the artists and the streaming services?
- IloveHN84 8y agoIt saved music labels from illegal p2p (maybe). But it introduced the shitty model pay-per-service and now you need 10 accounts to get 10 different things. The same applies for videos. The unique true service that can centralise everything is still Kodi + plugins
- esilver 8y agoThis interview sets up this false dichotomy where people ostensibly accessed music by spending $15 on a CD or not at all. The contention seems to be that piracy/Napster were a forgone conclusion because there was no real choice. People listened to ad-supported radio or they listened to records socially or borrowed them. That’s how it worked for about 80 years. I’m not defending the music industry, its practices, or its stalwart backwardness. But suggesting music was inaccessible is plainly false.
- rchaud 8y agoOr they made copies of friend's records ("ripping"). the CD-R drive has been around for 2 decades now, and came as a default option on many laptops and desktops in the early 2000s. And before that, people had CD/Casette Boomboxes where you could record CD tracks to the cassette. It was the only way to make mix tapes. I remember the days of ripping CDs borrowed from friends on a 4x speed drive; back then, you could do 8x but there was a risk of file corruption/recording failure.
- esilver 8y agoI completely forgot about this set of practices. Yes, a huge part of youth culture concerned itself with the creation and sharing of mix tapes. Looked at through this lens it makes me almost wistful thinking about the mix CDs I exchanged with friends in high school. They took a fair amount of work to put together and were often deeply personalized for the receiver. Makes you wonder who’s missing out, us or “kids these days.”
- rchaud 8y agoYeah, those were the days of making mixes for actual events, like road trips, relationship anniversaries, etc; these would be highly personal mixes, with inside jokes and obscure references. Now the trend has shifted to becoming an influencer with public playlists.
- Animats 8y agoNow can someone do Spotify for old movies? The online Netflix catalog keeps shrinking. Studios are cracking down on Youtube showing movies that used to be used as filler on late-night TV.
- Daishiman 8y agoPeople love to complain about nothing, eh? Think about what the distribution landscape for musicians used to be like in the past. You can literally put up your entire music catalog at almost no effort and and generate enough popularity to support your act through live plays. Live shows have always been the main source of revenue for artists. People saying that the situation for artists is bleak have no idea of what they're talking about. It has never in history been easier to start a music act and get followers from all around the world. It has never been easier to concentrate fans of every possible little genre into their own communities. What most people don't realize is that the live act scene has exploded all over the world. There a literally thousands of live music festivals going on every summer that just weren't there 20 years ago. Modern festival culture is fueled by streaming media, Soundcloud, BandCamp and Youtube. I follow scenes where an artist's greatest hit gets 20k plays on YouTube and 500 physical vinyl copies. That's literally enough to make a living and tour around a little on your free weekends. How possible do you think that was before Youtube?