6 ms·
There is nothing about an AMP page that makes it inherently faster until it lands in and is served by a Google regional cache server. Otherwise my site is going
by ehnto 8y ago
There is nothing about an AMP page that makes it inherently faster until it lands in and is served by a Google regional cache server. Otherwise my site is going to be just as fast. I can make just as fast web pages and serve them from a server sitting in the same state as my customers. There will be no need for Google level scale for my site as it is regional. Yet I still get put below AMP sites.
From many different angles, AMP getting preferential treatment is heavy handed and clumsy, manipulative and forcing technology standards on the web that no one agreed on.
- underwater 8y agoAMP limits what the page can do, and allows Google to safely serve content through a cache. So Google can preload and prerender the page in an iframe. As a result clicks on the carousel are literally instant. That can't be done safely with a regular HTML page.
- warent 8y agoI can't help but wonder what problem they're solving for. Is there a huge market of people clamoring to make webpages load faster than they already do?
- yathern 8y agoYes. In many areas where phones are the main tool used to access the internet, and coverage is primarily still 3G. Not defending AMP - but making pages load faster is still something people want and need.
- C1sc0cat 8y agoFor a lot of niches usage is > 50% mobile already.
- Godel_unicode 8y agoYes.
- taytus 8y agoThere are billions of people with capped data plans and where 200kb/s is the standard.
- dmitriid 8y agoThere are no AMP pages that weigh less than 1MB. However, since Google aggressively preloads most of that data while you search, it gives you the illusion of AMP pages being lightweight. Non-AMP pages? Oh, Google will happily penalize them even if they perform better.
- danso 8y agoI did a mobile Google search for "Trump" to bring up the top news section on Google, and was able to find sites (generally non TV-news sites which aren't doing video with every story) that weighed less than 1MB: USA Today (582KB, first item in the top news section) https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.usatoday.com/amp/3431466002 https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.usatoday.com/amp/3431466002 Vox (486KB) https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.vox.com/platform/amp/policy-and-politics/2019/4/10/18305175/trump-border-immigration-military-texas https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.vox.com/platform/amp/policy... The New Yorker (565KB) https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.newyorker.com/news/current/william-barr-goes-full-trump/amp https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.newyorker.com/news/current/...
- geezerjay 8y agoUnless those articles are packed with raster infographics that's pretty bloated just to send a couple of pages worth of text. I meam, why exactly are 500kb of cruft is being served to present 5kb worth of data?
- rymate1234 8y agoThe EU experience of USA today weighs on at 248KB and that's without AMP So even if the AMP Pages are small, they're still much larger than the page ought to be
- 8y ago
- tzakrajs 8y agoYeah, I am sure there is some sort of KPI tracking engagement which helped to inform this behavior.
- systemBuilder 8y agoAs a former SRE for Google who cared for AMPHTML FROM BIRTH, NOBODY IS FORCING YOU TO USE AMP. In return for free hosting of the web content the publisher agrees to use the AMP format/subset. The whole point of the project was to stop walled gardens, like BBC app, like CNN app,etc., which arose because of crappy slow web pages! That was killing the searchable mobile web! AMP is to enable mobile search! The motivation is in the first page of every dang design doc for AMP at Google! You might be really surprised to learn that your supposed plan for world domination is run on a shoestring and a low priority at Google!
- justAnotherNET 8y agoAMP is a disgusting attack on the open web, and you should be ashamed for being a part of it. You're supposed to be a search engine, not a content "curator". I really wish this kind of arrogance wasn't typical Google behavior, but here we are.
- millstone 8y agoWow, a "shoestring low priority" project gets top search result placement, a custom icon callout, and cannot be disabled. What do the high-pri projects get?
- majewsky 8y agoHigh-prio projects get to be a requirement for commenting on Youtube.
- systemBuilder 8y agoThose moves were meant to stop mobile search from dying. You may not believe it, but you really haven't a clue of how bad things looked for Google when they conceived of AMP to stop the bleeding of open searchable content into walled gardens apps, and proprietary HTML replacements (yeah i'm talking YOU, Facebook.). If you want all news to come from unsearchable single website apps, go ahead, kill AMPHTML, the only open alternative.
- 8y ago
- krageon 8y agoYou should try loading "the modern web" over a not great but passable phone connection (ie 3G maximum) on a non-flagship phone. Nearly every normal website you will have an exceedingly bad time on. That's what AMP claims to solve. Far be it from me to claim they succeeded or that they are doing it in the right way, but I think pretending the problem doesn't exist at all is disingenuous.
- StreamBright 8y agoWhy not fixing “the moder web” then?
- r3bl 8y agoBecause convincing all the website owners to do anything (even if it clearly benefits everyone) is an impossible task. See HTTPS adoption.
- radus 8y agoIsn't https over the hump in most of the world?
- StreamBright 8y agoHTTPS adoption: https://storage.googleapis.com/cdn.thenewstack.io/media/2018/04/253fa7e9-ssl.png https://storage.googleapis.com/cdn.thenewstack.io/media/2018... Great example. You just proved my point that it is possible to have positive change in large communities.
- r3bl 8y agoI'm not sure that graph shows what you think it shows. That graph shows that there's an obnoxiously large number of websites that don't support something that there's zero reason not to support. It costs $0 and takes maybe half an hour to implement, browsers are screaming "not secure" to each visitor, and one in five websites still don't support it. "Make websites faster", on top of being vague, is way more difficult to implement.
- C1sc0cat 8y agoYes have you seen as lot of websites these days
- ehnto 8y agoI can serve content in miliseconds after the network request has been made. Near enough to appear instant to my users. I have caches too. You can't help the network request if it has to be made when the user clicks but there is nothing stopping browsers from preloading my site and nothing stopping google from noting that my site could be preloaded when it crawls it. Limiting ranking influence to sites with the AMP structure is an option Google has decided to make and not an inherent restriction in the technologies at play. The technology behind AMP is very cool mind you, I just find it being an exclusive ranking factor to be an unecessary pressure to use their technology when many other technologies could work just as well. Google is a major force in the way people make websites and they are being very heavy handed in this instance.
- joshuamorton 8y ago> nothing stopping google from noting that my site could be preloaded There's a whole host of security problems with trying to see if an arbitrary site can be preloaded. Logging, tracking, etc, not to mention more nefarious tricks like mining Bitcoin in the background. Maybe Google could try to detect those things, but then you just end up in a cat and mouse game. A "safe" subset of html and js that can't do those bad things is much, much easier to analyze. One such subset is AMP.
- bryanrasmussen 8y agoA safe subset of html that they can analyze could be summarized in a document and ranking things higher that conform to that subset. That is not what AMP is.
- jefftk 8y agoThat is exactly what AMP is attempting to be. It's a subset of HTML and CSS which guarantees that the site can be preloaded in a privacy-preserving way. There are a lot of things sites want to do that can't be done in pure HTML and CSS and allowing full use of JS would be incompatible with this goal, so that gap is filled with open source libraries. (Disclosure: I work at Google on Ads, and I work with the AMP folks a bunch. Speaking for myself, not the company.)
- feanaro 8y agoSuppose that this is true and that there is no way to achieve this without AMP. Are we going to route the whole web through Google's server so that pages are rendered faster? This is getting silly.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoIt's quite ironic that Google is getting into trouble with the EU for nonsense like excluding search engine spam from its results, when it's stuff like this that really has that classic Phone Company feel to it.
- jeltz 8y agoThe EU works slowly so it is way too early to say if Google will get in trouble or not for AMP.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoThe problem is that doesn't work to produce desired behavior. If you slap them for the wrong stuff then one of two things happens. The first is they conclude they're going to get slapped no matter what and then do whatever they want and write off the penalties as unavoidable because better behavior doesn't actually avoid them anyway. The second is they conclude that the only way to avoid the penalties is to grease the right palms, you induce them to figure out how to do that, and then they still do whatever they want because once you force them to corrupt your institutions in order to not be treated unfairly, those institutions no longer threaten them even when they misbehave. The only scenario that leads to behavior improvements is the one where all the penalties are assigned justly and proportionally, to behavior that could reasonably be predicted ahead of time as prohibited.
- geezerjay 8y ago> If you slap them for the wrong stuff None of the FAANG is being slapped by the EU for the wrong stuff. They aren't being slapped for your specific example (yet) but that doesn't mean that forcing their self-serving choices onto powerless users deserves a pass.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> None of the FAANG is being slapped by the EU for the wrong stuff. A lot of the other stuff is things like not putting links to another search engine's results page in their search engine's results page. It's pure nonsense.