7 ms·
In principle advertising is fine. Telling people that a product exists is useful. "Do you need a hat shaped exactly like a golf ball? At Dave's Golf Ball Hats w
by tialaramex 8y ago
In principle advertising is fine. Telling people that a product exists is useful. "Do you need a hat shaped exactly like a golf ball? At Dave's Golf Ball Hats we sell six sizes!". Targeting this advert to most likely be seen by people who actually had been thinking of buying a hat shaped like sporting equipment is still a good idea too.
But an advert that steals from you, or harms you is neither of those things. Google Ads doesn't need those to be profitable. It would suit them if those went away.
- JohnFen 8y ago> Targeting this advert to most likely be seen by people who actually had been thinking of buying a hat shaped like sporting equipment is still a good idea too. Not if that targeting is done using data gathered about me without my consent -- as it almost universally is. Targeting based on context (what sort of website the ad is on, for instance), is fine.
- bad_user 8y agoGoogle’s primary revenue source is AdWords, meaning ads served on their own properties, the bulk of it being in Google Search and most if that is contextual, most ads being served based on the search you’re making. Google doesn’t actually have a problem in serving contextual ads on their own properties, since they have plenty of context. The problem is with AdSense since there advertisers need some sort of user profile, plus in the EU bidding exchanges are in jeopardy due to the GDPR.
- jimmaswell 8y agoI don't understand this new position (that GDPR follows) that consent is required for information to be gathered on someone. If someone sees me wearing a blue shirt and writes in their notebook that I wore a blue shirt then I don't feel like I have some inherent right to coerce them to erase it or prevent them from selling that information to Blue Shirt Emporium.
- arthur_pryor 8y agosometimes it is right to treat scenarios that are fundamentally similar as different beasts in practice when those scenarios are actually happening at very different scales. i (and many others) believe that surveillance is like this. the effort that it takes to do what your describing does not scale, and cannot be used to implement dragnet surveillance and data collection (unless it's a police state and you have a lot of notetakers). lots of people (myself and many others) think dragnet surveillance (whether by private entities or governments) is a thing to be avoided (because it creates really bad power asymmetries, which i think are inherently a bad thing). also, i don't think that large companies should be granted the same rights as individuals. just because a person can do a thing on their own doesn't mean that a large entity should be able to do something similar in spirit at thousands or millions of times the scale.
- bravoetch 8y agoIf they wrote 'person wearing blue shirt', fine. But if they followed you home, took note of the address, cross referenced that to find your name and other personal info, then stored all that data to a company that decides who gets loans based on shirt color - not fine. Etc.
- joemag 8y agoMany laws and societal norms don’t require universal acceptance. So it’s totally reasonable for you to not care, while society in general feels the opposite. Or vice versa. And in your case of the note taker, a better example would be somebody that frequently follows you, and takes notes about what you wear. In many places, that could be grounds for harassment claim. In other words, it’s not the act that matters to most people, but the frequency and scale at which the act takes place.
- manigandham 8y agoData about you is not your data. Anyone can stand outside and watch what people do and take notes. That doesn't need your consent. It's the same thing here.
- JohnFen 8y ago> It's the same thing here. I disagree completely.
- manigandham 8y agoWhy?
- walterstucco 8y agoBecause they are not standing outside, they are inside my shoes, clothes and even underwear
- bravoetch 8y agoIn this case the clue is the word fingerprinting. If someone outside your door was taking fingerprint impressions, your name, and then writing down your license plate and selling that info to anyone with money - would you just let that continue? Unlikely.
- manigandham 8y agoIn the real world they can't physically touch you so let's replace that with passive facial recognition. In that case, yes they can do that all today. Someone can follow you all day from the moment you step out into public. We might not like it but it is legal and they own their observations.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- GoblinSlayer 8y ago
- crummy 8y ago> Targeting based on context (what sort of website the ad is on, for instance), is fine. Why? I didn't consent for that.
- darkpuma 8y agoUntargeted advertising is very often more egregious than merely telling people a product exists. Traditional pre-digital advertising runs the gamete from "Come to me and I'll fix your car" to "You are ugly and unpopular, but you can fix that by drinking our caramel colored sugar water." Advertising that tries to induce then exploit self esteem issues is a plague.
- ogre_codes 8y agoThis little bit of misdirection Google and Facebook have propagated about how much better the advertising you get with tracking is the slimiest piece of bait-and-switch in history. Seeing people repeat it like it's fact is testament to just how insidious it is. Targeted advertising is not designed to serve the viewer, it's designed to serve the advertiser. So advertisements you get are even sleazier than non-targeted advertising because they have by definition more information about the reader. So instead of generically exploiting people's self esteem, it exploits people's self esteem armed with much more information about the users. Targeting and tracking is a plague and should be discouraged and blocked to oblivion.
- mindcrime 8y agoTargeted advertising is not designed to serve the viewer, it's designed to serve the advertiser. Advertising doesn't help the advertiser unless it helps you. Showing you an ad for something you don't want, can't use, and would never buy, benefits nobody.
- gnud 8y agoAdvertising helps the advertiser if it results in a sale - it doesn't matter if the sale helps the viewer. If the ad results in the viewer getting an eating disorder, for example, that's fine for the advertiser if it also results in a sale.
- ogre_codes 8y agoAdvertising helps the advertiser if it results in a sale - it doesn't matter if the sale helps the viewer. Exactly this. Often it doesn't even require a sale. A lot of Facebook & Google advertising is for bullshit sites which push increasingly sketchy content backed by even sketchier advertising. Sometimes the goal isn't even profit, the Russians paid for advertising to influence politics.
- rurp 8y agoAn ad for a golf ball hat is a pretty benign use case but that exact same approach could be used in much more distasteful ways. For example, suppose depressed people are more likely to buy expensive impulse item X. Person A is depressed. Lets show them ads for item X! That would be a nicely profitable strategy that could emerge organically out of a sophisticated ML ad targeting model, something like... AdWords.
- packet_nerd 8y ago> "Do you need a hat shaped exactly like a golf ball? At Dave's Golf Ball Hats we sell six sizes!" The implicit message here is buy buy buy. "There's cool hats shaped like golf balls. Everyone's getting one! I need one too!" Do I really need a hat shaped like a gold ball? Do I need any of the crap our materialistic society says I need? Ads like this are trying to shape my expectations about myself, the meaning and purpose of my life, and what I need to feel fulfilled; and all for someone else's benefit, not my own. I have made it a personal goal to reject consumerism, and instead live a simple, sustainable, and efficient life. Rejecting ads (electronically blocking where possible, mentally blocking everywhere) is part of how I'm trying to achieve that goal. Any company trying to sell me something that I didn't seek out myself is my enemy.
- crummy 8y agoYou can imagine a company that has come up with a product that helps people live more sustainably, and they want to figure out how to tell people about it. You didn't seek them out though; are they your enemy?
- packet_nerd 8y agoYes. So they are trying to tell me how to be more sustainable, and make a profit on the side? Which objective is more important to them? Edit: I believe that analyzing the biases and incentives underlying the choices and abstractions presented to us is an important part of what it means to be an intelligent human being. Ads are not reliable sources of information, as the company is incentivized not to inform you, but to sell to you. There are many better sources of good ideas than ads.
- nukeop 8y agoThe purpose of advertising is to manipulate you into buying things you don't need, not to inform you about a product that is useful. Turn on the TV, or the radio, or any website, and show me one advert that is purely informative.