8 ms·
Sweden will vote against the copyright deal/article 13
- shmerl 8y agoGood, more countries should have opposed this corrupt censorship bill.
- jug 8y agoEurope was pretty torn and I got the impression that votes were ”for” by default and ”against” where there was an ongoing public debate. If true, I hope that was more due to politicians misunderstanding the consequences due to technical obstacles rather than lobbyism... The arguments in favor have also been strange, even from institutions like the Swedish EU Commision! They argued that this directive was no big deal because social networks already employ AI assisted filters to respect copyrights. Yeah, but those are also known to be heavy handed, and depend on huge training sets. It completely disregards small businesses and startups with no resources to deal with this.
- shmerl 8y agoIt doesn't look like misunderstanding. There was more than enough information about how bad this bill is. I'd blame corruption here.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoI would argue on the contrary, that this bill is massively helpful and much in line with the EU's focus on reigning in abuse by the tech industry. It'd be far preferable to implement this as-is and fix edge cases if needed than fail to act against these behemoths now.
- shmerl 8y agoI won't agree that a horrendous censorship bill is helfpul for anyone, except for corrupt supporters of police state methodology and control freaks from the obsolete industries who don't care about human rights as long as they can extend their information control craze (under pretense for copyright) to further reaches to satisfy their thirst for power. They are the abusers here and they should be stopped.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoHuman rights is at the forefront of my mind. Privacy is a human right, and these companies and these social platforms have been abusing it. Copyright protection is hardly "censorship", and contrary to the marketing and popular belief on the matter, all of the well-understood protections for fair use remain intact with this law.
- shmerl 8y ago> Copyright protection is hardly "censorship" It often is. Because by its nature, copyright is about restricting information flow, and therefore it naturally can conflict with free speech, especially when copyright maximalists go overboard with it (which they always do). So any kind of abusive copyright initiative should always be a suspect as attack on free speech. And this case is a very obvious example.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoIs this someone exercising free speech? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=glBB_Ftky8I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=glBB_Ftky8I It's not abusive to point out that finding full episodes of copyrighted shows in their entirety has been trivial and that YouTube benefits significantly from distributing stolen content. The reality is, tech companies have had over a decade to demonstrate that they could behave themselves, manage their own platforms, and balance the needs of both content creators and the public. They failed, and it's time for the party to end.
- shmerl 8y agoLet me put it very simply for you. Those who try to extend the copyright in all directions are often proponents of censorship and police state methodology. It's commonly the same ones who push for DRM and anti-circumvention laws. Example: http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~dst/GeoHot/ http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~dst/GeoHot/ Public should not tolerate such kind of garbage, especially when corrupt politicians lie through their teeth about the consequences of such kind of laws.
- ivan_gammel 8y agoThe bill will hit smaller business much harder than real behemoths, thus strengthening the rule of big American corporations which can afford content filtering.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoThis argument is made every time regulation against big companies is brought to the table, and it's almost always made... by big companies. If it were true, and it isn't, why would big companies be spending so much money fighting these regulations? Automated content filtering fails to meet the requirements of the EU article, so it will disproportionately impact large companies which rely on those systems, rather than smaller ones which use human moderation teams.
- shmerl 8y agoThis isn't a "regulation against big companies" though, this is a direct attack on free speech and a power grab by copyright maximalists, who are feeling that their industries are getting obsolete and want to tax everyone to compensate for their own failures (like the link tax and the like). I'd say let them crash and fail, no one owns them anything just because they can't compete.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoIt's impossible to argue with your portrayal of the law, as opposed to what it actually says, so I'm going to have to just agree to disagree with you. There is no "link tax", nor is there a "meme ban". Both of these concepts are not actually based in the law, but in marketing of those opposed to it.
- imtringued 8y agoThe actual law might not explicitly mandate upload filters but they are the only way to comply with the law other than just shutting down in the EU of course.
- imtringued 8y agoThose laws hurt small companies and small creators more than they hurt behemoths with large legal departments and already implemented filters.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoI responded to an almost identical comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19617420 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19617420
- JohnFen 8y ago> It'd be far preferable to implement this as-is and fix edge cases It looks to me like the "edge cases" constitute the majority.
- Mirioron 8y agoPeople seem too simply not know what goes on in the EU. And even if they do they feel powerless about it in smaller countries. I'm in an ex-Soviet country and some of the older people I've talked to about it have said that they think they have as much of a say in the EU as they did in the Soviet Union. (Which is none.)
- vkou 8y agoThe point of democracy is that individuals, or even small groups of individuals have almost no say in governance. So, yes, you are supposed to attach yourself to larger umbrella movements, to get your opinions heard. It's by design. One other small difference between the EU, and the USSR, is that T-54 tanks don't start rolling in, when your country decides to hold a little regime change... Or even a general strike.
- IntegrationDude 8y ago>One other small difference between the EU, and the USSR, is that T-54 tanks don't start rolling in, when your country decides to hold a little regime change... Or even a general strike. T-54 are quite outdated, so you're right there.
- int_19h 8y agoThe point of democracy is to prevent a minority of society from dictating the rules to the majority by excluding it from governance. It doesn't necessarily imply that individuals or small groups have almost no say in governance, especially on matters where they're uniquely affected.
- iknowstuff 8y agoLatvia, Lithuania and Estonia - the only ex-soviet member states - sure as hell have way more say in the EU than they did when they weren't even countries under USSR. Those older people are deluded. Not only do they each have 1/28th of the vote in the Council, they are over-represented in the Parliament. Those folks you mentioned probably don't even realize they have the right to vote for local representatives in the European Parliament. In fact, look at population per MEP: State Pop MEPs Pop/MEP Influence Malta 0.4 5 80,800 10.30 Cyprus 0.77 6 127,667 6.52 Estonia 1.34 6 224,000 3.72 Lithuania 3.4 12 283,583 2.94 Slovenia 2 7 286,143 2.91 Latvia 2.3 8 286,875 2.90 .... Germany 82.43 99 832,606 1.00 UK 60.64 72 839,194 0.99 France 62.89 72 873,417 0.95 Spain 43.76 50 875,160 0.9
- kalleboo 8y agoThe Swedish article linked in the tweet concludes that the Swedish vote makes absolutely no difference, and the only thing that can change the result is Germany changing its mind.
- SlowRobotAhead 8y agoDoes Germany have a disproportionate amount of control over the EU? Or are you saying the support is already split and Germany is the deciding factor in this case? Or both?
- Mirioron 8y agoThey have a proportionate control over the EU due to their population. Right now the vote went to the council where it needs a qualified majority (I think). This means that 55% of the member states (16) have to vote for it and 65% of the population has to have voted for it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tapland 8y agoYeah. It pretty much says that the smaller countries changing their votes doesn't have any effect without for example Germany doing the same.
- nintendo95 8y agoGermany is losing that control. It seems peak German influence was during Greek crisis a few years back. Even though IMF and World Bank (sorry, but basically US based and influenced organizations) and the Obama Administration insisted on the Germany taking easier course on Greece crisis -- cutting the debt owned by Greeks -- Germany did it its own way, in opposition to the US demands -- and made a deal where Greece is and will be responsible for repaying all of the 100% debt it owes. Basically they did with the Greece as they pleased in sharp contrast to US open demands and criticism. There was US Secretary of Tresury Mr. Lew travelling to Berlin to speak to their senses, but was ignored. Soo... Now, of course, we can argue if it makes economical sense or not. The point though is that -- and forgive me, but I like playing in my mind, and this is my private little conspiracy theory I have never shared -- Germany seemed to be getting too much power in the EU. By the US standards that is. The US long term policy for EU and Europe is to make sure there is no single one power governing or having influence over the whole continent. So Germany seemed to be braking that rule. And, what happened next? Again, conspiracy theorist here, but good food for thought, just think about it: * Lufthansa airplane is suddenly dropping from the sky * German automanufacturer (VW) turns out to be braking federal laws, with its bosses in the US in prison because of the diesel-gate (VW was picked as one just to make an example. The same issues are with BMWs and Mercedes, but hey we just want to teach a lesson here, not destroy them completely, right?) * Migration crisis. German Chancellor is in no position now, even domestically speaking, to talk about issues with this or that -- fix that big mess with migrants first! That's what Ms Merkel hears from her voters. What EU power? Gone! Just a conspiracy theory. But it kind of fits. Ans looks very American too, i.e. soft power. You know if we want, your cars won't be sold here. If we want you will need to pay up too 2% GDP on military (and your voters hate it), if we want your airlines my look not that safe anymore. If we want we might even destabilize you a bit with huge influx of migrants. So, want to show Greece or some other European countries where they place in the hierarchy is? Well, make sure you discuss is with your overlord first. Again, conspiracy theory. My own private crazy thing. But to answer the question seriously -- German politics is blocked from entering EU stage with serious decisions regarding other countries by the migrant crisis. They are still the biggest and strongest player. But nothing compared to peak power during Greek Debt crisis. They started to feel to powerful and independent, seems all back to "normal".
- legohead 8y agotwitter is being evil with the back button now? click on the link, then click on one of the tweet replies.. then try going back to HN, twitter won't have that!
- kumarharsh 8y agoUse the native back button (if on Android) instead of Twitter's back button. It's been like that since a long time.
- reificator 8y agoChrome 73 on Windows 10, the site is definitely hijacking the browser's back button. Spamming it works, but a single press is not enough to get away from Twitter. Worth investigating whether this is due to a redirect, or whether it's due to misusing the history API. Either way, it feels very user-hostile.
- radford-neal 8y agoCan anyone explain why browsers allow this? Surely it's not technically hard to make "back" actually go back. Is there some downside to letting users control their own screen that I'm not aware of?
- aikah 8y agoI imagine that Twitter is abusing the HTML5 history API. It's a Web specification. It can be useful when used right, but any scriptable functionality is open for abuse.
- radford-neal 8y agoI'm not up on HTML5 APIs. But I do know that it is entirely possible for a browser to have a button labelled "back" that goes back. Always. Why don't they have it? Fear that something horrible will happen on some web page that relies on the user not exiting the page without control going throw their code? But such a web page is broken in any case, since the user might simply lose their internet connection...
- _bxg1 8y agoI thought the vote already happened? How can they change it?
- sirlantis 8y agoIt only passed in the parliament, hasn't passed the council yet (bicameral legislature like in the US and many other countries).
- framtidsljus 8y agoThe title of the article is not properly translated. "Sverige vill ändra" actually means "Swedens wants to change", not "will change". Also, "Sweden", in this case is the "EU committee" of the Swedish parliament. The committee wants the government to vote no. The matter isn't final yet I guess.
- 5ExJHrwW 8y agoThe responsible minister Morgan Johansson has said that the government will abide by the parliaments decision: "We have an order that we should anchor decisions in the Riksdag, now that the Riksdag has changed its attitude, the government will of course have to follow it." https://translate.google.com/translate?client=ubuntu&client=tw-ob&channel=fs&oe=utf-8&um=1&ie=UTF-8&hl=en&sl=auto&tl=en&u=https%3A%2F%2Ffemtejuli.se%2F2019%2F04%2F08%2Fregeringen-ar-pa-vag-att-backa-om-upphovsrattsdirektivet%2F https://translate.google.com/translate?client=ubuntu&client=...
- lelf 8y agohttps://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https%3A%2F%2Femanuelkarlsten.se%2F04%2Fsverige-vill-andra-sin-rost-om-artikel-13-har-ar-satten-det-kan-falla-direktivet https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https... Sweden wants to change its vote on “Article 13” — here are the ways it can trap the directive