6 ms·
I assume it's a mix of: open source > proprietary based in jurisdiction that respects freedom and privacy > based in authoritarian country empowering users >
by mcv 8y ago
I assume it's a mix of:
open source > proprietary
based in jurisdiction that respects freedom and privacy > based in authoritarian country
empowering users > empowering corporations and governments
privacy > no or compromised privacy
powered by green energy > powered by coal
recycling > no recycling
paid by users > paid by targeted ads based on analysis of your behaviour
- UncleMeat 8y agoBut what if I don't want those things? I have never once personally edited the code in libreoffice. Open source isn't necessarily better than closed. Monetization models are even less clear. What if I'd prefer to not pay with cash?
- m12k 8y agoThen this page is not for you. If you think a lot of people would prefer your definition of ethical products over the one OP linked, then feel free to make a competing page.
- sbuk 8y agoHow exactly does this kind of snark help change opinion? Open Source is wonderful. I’m not a developer, but I use it and contribute in ways that I can. These sorts of replies fill me with rage! Replies like this categorically do not help further the cause. The GP of the whole thread has a point; whose ethics? The post is about a website declaring that some software is more “ethical” than others. They offer no real criterion as to what constitutes “ethical”. The burden of proof lies with the publishers and those that fully support the notion. “Go away” neither helps or positively affects others views.
- mcv 8y ago> whose ethics? But is that not clear? The ethics of the person who made that list. You may not agree with it, and that's fine, but it's still useful to people who do agree with these ethics, or even with just some of them. I do agree it'd be better if they offered some explanation about the basis of their selection, which would make it easier for people to determine if they agree with it or not, and it would certainly form a better starting point to discuss these ethics and suggest improvements. That they didn't include that explanation is absolutely very valid criticism. But ultimately, if you don't agree with it, then this selection is not going to be relevant for you, is it?
- phaemon 8y agoI have never once personally written for a newspaper. Freedom of the press isn't necessarily better than censorship.
- jeanlucas 8y agoThat's a petty argument. Plenty of times open source projects lack resources, quality or maybe have a different focus than a non open source solution. You can't just assume open source is better than the other
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- webmaven 8y agoit would probably help to assume an implied "all other things being equal" unless you have a specific unequality in mind that significantly reverses the balance of ethics in some common context. A good example of such a reversal elsewhere in this thread is the "local butter better than imported vegan margarine made from palm oil grown in clear-cut rainforests" argument. Personally, I extend that argument further, mostly for health reasons, but I'm not vegan.
- phaemon 8y agoI didn't assume any such thing nor does my comment even suggest it. If you find your own strawmen "petty" I suggest you try to think more clearly. It would likely improve the quality of your HN comments.
- mikestew 8y agoBut what if I don't want those things? When I see articles that don’t interest me, I close the tab, don’t go post contrarian comments to the originating forum, and then get on with my day. This technique has worked well for me over the years, you might give it a shot.
- moocowtruck 8y agointeresting, one of the first apps is firefox...yet most of their funding comes from as this page would characterize as 'unethical sources' so wouldn't they then by guilty ?
- mcv 8y agoLie I said, it's probably a mix of things. If Firefox ends up offering better privacy and user empowerment than the alternatives, it's still the better option. I suppose Opera when it was still a paid product might also be in here, but that didn't survive.
- tssva 8y agoMany would also consider the inclusion of Brave in the browser categories as dubious. Their business model comes very close to being a shakedown operation.
- infinitezest 8y agoCan you expand on why Brave is "close to a shakedown operation"? My impression was that they were on the up-and-up. Plus, I'm all for just about effort being made to move away from the current ad economy. I'd rather pay for services directly.
- tssva 8y agoI too support development of an alternative to the ad economy, but I don't support using the threat of income blocking to force a website to use a particular solution. This is in effect what Brave is doing. Brave deprives the website owner of income by blocking or replacing ads while at the same time pushing the website owner to sign up to Brave's rewards program, which Brave generates income from, instead of ads for funding.
- takeda 8y agoSo what you are saying Firefox is bad and instead it is better to use Chrome that is owned directly by a company they are trying to avoid? Creating and maintaining a web browser is not simple, Firefox is the freeest usable browser.
- mikorym 8y agoI know it's a sensitive topic, but they are also doing: vegan > not vegan In South Africa, I refuse to buy (vegan) margarine. It contains palm oil, whereas our own butter is locally farmed in the Eastern Cape. TLDR: I've been on said dairy farms and it's way better for me to buy that butter than the (vegan) alternatives that contain palm oil. The second issue I have is that they seem to have a book advertisement section. Apart from that, there seem to be useful links there.
- mcv 8y agoI feel similar about Organic (or "Biologisch", as it's called here). If I eat meat, I prefer it to be from an animal in a local field than meat that has all the right certifications but was shipped from the other side of the world (which happens). Palm oil is a similar issue. It was supposed to be very environmentally friendly, but it's not if they're cutting down rain forests to grow it. Direct knowledge of where it comes from still beats having the right names and certifications; if that's all that matters, companies will cut corners to tap into that market.
- mikorym 8y ago> Organic (or "Biologisch", as it's called here) Indeed a similar topic. Many people don't realise that "organic" is a marketing term. You cannot equate it with "ethical" or anything of the like from a terminology point of view. It (organic farming) has formal definitions in the countries where the products are sold and these are not always sensible or honest.
- nononononono2 8y agoThis is wrong, in the US and abroad in many cases. "All Natural" is a marketing term... "Organic" labeled foods are certified and (in the US) must meet specific requirements set by the USDA. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organic_certification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organic_certification I would agree that the GMO component seems overblown, but this also includes controls that protect the environment (reduced pesticides, reduced antibiotic use, more specific dumping regulations) and keeping better audit trails.