10 ms·
How is ethical defined here? I cannot see a definition and I don't see what is the common denominator between all those tools. For example why isn't Telegram co
by dgellow 8y ago
How is ethical defined here? I cannot see a definition and I don't see what is the common denominator between all those tools. For example why isn't Telegram considered ethical but Signal and Wire are? What is unethical about Word or Excel (given that OpenOffice is mentioned as an alternative), is it the ownership by Microsoft? Or the use of proprietary format in the past? What is more ethical about Steemit or Mastodon than Twitter? I would understand if the focus was on privacy and taking back some control/ownership, but that's not really something I would consider to be an ethical argument.
- nkozyra 8y ago> How is ethical defined here? Yeah, I'm not sure I follow this at all. Is it just being open source or not (directly) run by a huge company?
- prolikewhoa 8y agoWage slavery and closed source code while companies invest in surveillance technology to work with an over-reaching government while also buying out US government to form an oligarchy is what isn't ethical about closed source products from large corporatioms.
- jmull 8y agoIf that's the criteria it should be included fairly prominently on the site -- so visitors can understand and choose whether or not to use and contribute to the site.
- mcv 8y agoI assume it's a mix of: open source > proprietary based in jurisdiction that respects freedom and privacy > based in authoritarian country empowering users > empowering corporations and governments privacy > no or compromised privacy powered by green energy > powered by coal recycling > no recycling paid by users > paid by targeted ads based on analysis of your behaviour
- UncleMeat 8y agoBut what if I don't want those things? I have never once personally edited the code in libreoffice. Open source isn't necessarily better than closed. Monetization models are even less clear. What if I'd prefer to not pay with cash?
- m12k 8y agoThen this page is not for you. If you think a lot of people would prefer your definition of ethical products over the one OP linked, then feel free to make a competing page.
- sbuk 8y agoHow exactly does this kind of snark help change opinion? Open Source is wonderful. I’m not a developer, but I use it and contribute in ways that I can. These sorts of replies fill me with rage! Replies like this categorically do not help further the cause. The GP of the whole thread has a point; whose ethics? The post is about a website declaring that some software is more “ethical” than others. They offer no real criterion as to what constitutes “ethical”. The burden of proof lies with the publishers and those that fully support the notion. “Go away” neither helps or positively affects others views.
- mcv 8y ago> whose ethics? But is that not clear? The ethics of the person who made that list. You may not agree with it, and that's fine, but it's still useful to people who do agree with these ethics, or even with just some of them. I do agree it'd be better if they offered some explanation about the basis of their selection, which would make it easier for people to determine if they agree with it or not, and it would certainly form a better starting point to discuss these ethics and suggest improvements. That they didn't include that explanation is absolutely very valid criticism. But ultimately, if you don't agree with it, then this selection is not going to be relevant for you, is it?
- jmkd 8y agoWhile we should certainly take care about the definition of ethical here, this remains a great list of 'alternatives to mainstream stuff' that mainstream users should be made more aware of. I'm interested in this topic and still only aware of about 15% of this list.
- Thomashuet 8y agoFrom their home page: > What do we mean by ethical? > We know that “ethical” isn’t an objective word — it can mean different things to different people. > But for us, ethical means moving in the direction of least possible harm against other people, animals and the planet.
- thecopy 8y agoThis just moves the definition into the definition of "harm against other people, animals and the planet"
- cblades 8y agoThat's a useless definition when it comes to software and software services. It's easy to think of good arguments for Twitter being ethical and unethical.
- ekianjo 8y ago> But for us, ethical means moving in the direction of least possible harm against other people, animals and the planet. Something that benefits humans is usually not good for the planet or for animals :-) It basically means nothing and everything.
- mancuso5 8y agoThe most basic ethical thing to do is simply being nice. Is that a popular thing on HN? :)
- mancuso5 8y agoGreat points! Short answer: it's an imperfect mix of open source, privacy centered, indie projects vs proprietary, mainstream corporations, VC funded etc. Hope that you and others interested in this topic will get involved with criticism ans suggestions here on on our forum in order to improve the list, devise a clearer "checklist" for listings, submit more stuff, etc: https://community.ethical.net/t/suggestions-for-our-ethical-resources-directory/105 https://community.ethical.net/t/suggestions-for-our-ethical-...
- cblades 8y agoYou shouldn't use the term "ethical" without very clearly defining your definition of ethical upfront. If someone proposes to me that murder isn't ethical, I can more-or-less get on board with that without a bunch of defining and qualifying. You're talking about software though. To suggest that Open Office is ethically superior to MS Office is not at all self-evident or the general consensus of most people. It comes off as you being oblivious or close-minded to competing ideas of ethics, which doesn't lend credibility to your use of the term.
- mancuso5 8y agoThanks for taking time to contribute to the cause :)
- cblades 8y agoAlso, taking a snarky, passive-agressive tone to people making legitimate criticisms makes me not trust the list at all. By saying "this is ethical, that is not", you are assuming a position that must be defended. edit: I am contributing to the cause. Ethics is necessarily a conversation. By minimizing and handwaving away the part of ethical decision making that actually matters, you're doing more harm than good. We don't need users to blindly use services somebody has slapped the "ethical" label on, we need to inspire users to bring ethics into their decision making process when choosing software services.
- DoofusOfDeath 8y ago
- nothis 8y agoHow would you define "ethical" in a way that covers Word, Chrome, Twitter and Dropbox?
- veridies 8y agoCreating tools that allow for rapid, powerful global conversation and collaboration by people of all technological skill levels.
- rootusrootus 8y agoIt would certainly be a more useful list to me if each choice was accompanied by a quick rundown of what factors make it the 'ethical' choice.
- everdev 8y agoThere are short descriptions below each service that explain just that.
- everdev 8y ago> But for us, ethical means moving in the direction of least possible harm against other people, animals and the planet.
- trpc 8y agoMany projects like this one turned out to be paid by companies like DuckDuckGo and Brave to promote their products, look at their aggressive cheap way of advertising and you will understand
- rdiddly 8y agoIt's funny how your comment answers all your own questions. You seem to be extracting the ethics of this list just fine.